Collaborative Group: Composed Image Retrieval via Consensus Learning from Noisy Annotations

Overview

• Composed image retrieval allows users to search for images using reference images and captions that describe their intent.
• Current methods face an issue called triplet ambiguity, where multiple visually dissimilar images can be matched to the same reference pair (image + caption).
• To address this, the paper proposes the Consensus Network (Css-Net), which uses a consensus module with diverse compositors and a Kullback-Leibler divergence loss to promote consensual outputs.
• Css-Net demonstrates significant improvements on benchmark datasets, particularly in recall metrics.

Plain English Explanation

Composed image retrieval is a way for users to search for images using a reference image and a caption that describes what they're looking for. This goes beyond traditional content-based image retrieval, which only uses the image itself.

The key challenge the paper addresses is "triplet ambiguity." This refers to a problem where multiple visually different images can be matched to the same reference pair (image + caption). This is due to limitations in how the captions represent the content, leading to many "noisy" triplets (reference image, caption, target image).

To solve this, the paper proposes the Consensus Network (Css-Net). This system has two main components:

1. A consensus module with four diverse "compositors" that each generate their own unique image-text embeddings. This helps capture different perspectives and mitigates reliance on any single, potentially biased compositor.

2. A Kullback-Leibler divergence loss that encourages the compositors to learn how to work together and produce more consensual outputs.

During evaluation, the decisions of the four compositors are combined using a weighting scheme to enhance overall agreement.

Css-Net demonstrates significant improvements on benchmark datasets, particularly FashionIQ. It achieves notable gains in recall metrics, suggesting it is better able to address the fundamental limitations of existing methods.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes the Consensus Network (Css-Net) to address the issue of triplet ambiguity in composed image retrieval systems.

Triplet ambiguity refers to the semantic ambiguity that can arise between the reference image, the relative caption, and the target image. This is primarily due to the limited representation of the annotated text, resulting in many noisy triplets where multiple visually dissimilar candidate images can be matched to an identical reference pair.

To mitigate this challenge, Css-Net comprises two core components:

1. Consensus Module: This module includes four diverse compositors, each generating distinct image-text embeddings. This fosters complementary feature extraction and reduces dependence on any single, potentially biased compositor.

2. Kullback-Leibler Divergence Loss: This loss function encourages the compositors to learn how to interact and promote consensual outputs. By minimizing the Kullback-Leibler divergence between the compositors' outputs, the system learns to produce more aligned representations.

During evaluation, the decisions of the four compositors are combined through a weighting scheme, enhancing the overall agreement and robustness of the system.

Experiments on benchmark datasets, particularly FashionIQ, demonstrate that Css-Net achieves significant improvements, especially in recall metrics. Specifically, it shows a 2.77% increase in R@10 and a 6.67% boost in R@50, indicating its effectiveness in addressing the fundamental limitations of existing methods.

Critical Analysis

The paper does a commendable job of identifying and addressing the issue of triplet ambiguity, which is a significant challenge in composed image retrieval systems. The proposed Consensus Network (Css-Net) offers a novel solution by leveraging a consensus module with diverse compositors and a Kullback-Leibler divergence loss to promote consensual outputs.

One potential limitation of the approach is the reliance on four separate compositors, which may increase the computational complexity and training time of the system. It would be interesting to explore whether a similar level of performance can be achieved with a more efficient architecture.

Additionally, the paper does not provide much insight into the specific strengths and weaknesses of the individual compositors within the consensus module. Understanding how each compositor contributes to the final result could lead to further improvements in the system design.

Another area for further research could be investigating the generalizability of Css-Net to other domains beyond fashion, such as general composed image retrieval or composed video retrieval. Exploring the system's performance on diverse datasets and use cases could shed light on its broader applicability.

Conclusion

The Consensus Network (Css-Net) proposed in this paper represents a significant advancement in addressing the triplet ambiguity challenge in composed image retrieval systems. By leveraging a consensus module with diverse compositors and a Kullback-Leibler divergence loss, Css-Net demonstrates marked improvements in recall metrics, particularly on the FashionIQ dataset.

This research highlights the importance of addressing fundamental limitations in existing methods and the potential of collaborative approaches to enhance the robustness and performance of image-text retrieval systems. As the field of composed image retrieval continues to evolve, the insights and techniques introduced in this paper can serve as a valuable foundation for further advancements.