Combining Neuroevolution with the Search for Novelty to Improve the Generation of Test Inputs for Games
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores combining neuroevolution (a machine learning technique that evolves neural networks) with the search for novelty to improve the generation of test inputs for video games.
- The key idea is to use neuroevolution to efficiently explore the space of possible game inputs, focusing on finding novel and interesting test cases rather than just maximizing some specific objective.
- The authors demonstrate their approach on several game environments, showing that it can find more diverse and challenging test cases compared to previous methods.
Plain English Explanation
The paper is about using a machine learning technique called neuroevolution to help test video games. Neuroevolution involves evolving neural networks - complex mathematical models inspired by the brain - to perform certain tasks. In this case, the task is generating interesting test inputs for games.
The core insight is that simply trying to maximize some specific metric or objective when generating test inputs may miss out on many interesting edge cases and unusual behaviors. Instead, the researchers propose also rewarding the
By combining this novelty search with neuroevolution, the system can efficiently explore the vast space of possible game inputs, finding many diverse and challenging test cases. This could help game developers uncover rare bugs or unexpected behaviors that would be difficult to find using more traditional testing approaches.
The paper demonstrates this Beacon: Bayesian Optimization Strategy for Novelty Search on Expensive Domains approach on several different game environments, showing that it outperforms previous methods at generating a wide variety of interesting test cases.
Technical Explanation
The authors propose a search-based software testing approach for video games that combines neuroevolution with a novelty search objective. Neuroevolution is used to efficiently explore the space of possible game inputs, while the novelty objective ensures that the search focuses on finding diverse and interesting test cases.
Specifically, the system uses a Covariance Matrix Adaptation Evolution Strategy (CMA-ES) to evolve neural networks that generate game inputs. The fitness function for these networks includes both a measure of the "novelty" of the generated input (how different it is from previous inputs) and a measure of the "interestingness" of the input (e.g., whether it triggers rare game behaviors).
The authors evaluate their approach on several different game environments, including the Sonic the Hedgehog and Super Mario Bros. games. They show that their method is able to generate a wider variety of interesting test cases compared to previous approaches, including many corner cases and unusual behaviors that would be difficult to find through more traditional testing methods.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel and promising approach to testing video games, but it also has some limitations and areas for further research:
-
The novelty search objective relies on a similarity metric between game inputs, which can be challenging to define and may not always capture the true "interestingness" of a test case. Exploring more sophisticated notions of novelty and interestingness could further improve the approach.
-
The experiments were conducted on relatively simple 2D game environments. Scaling the approach to more complex, 3D game worlds may require additional innovations, such as better ways to represent and process the game state.
-
The paper does not provide a detailed comparison to other state-of-the-art game testing techniques, such as reinforcement learning-based methods. A more comprehensive empirical evaluation would help better situate the contributions of this work.
-
While the authors mention the potential for their approach to uncover rare bugs, they do not provide any concrete examples or case studies demonstrating this capability. Validating the real-world impact of the method on game development workflows would strengthen the claims.
Overall, this work demonstrates the promise of combining neuroevolution and novelty search for game testing, but further research and validation is needed to fully realize the potential of this approach.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to testing video games that combines neuroevolution with the search for novelty. By evolving neural networks to generate game inputs that are both high-performing and diverse, the system can efficiently explore the vast space of possible test cases and uncover a wide range of interesting and challenging behaviors.
The authors show promising results on several game environments, suggesting that this technique could be a valuable tool for game developers to improve the quality and robustness of their products. While the approach has some limitations that require further research, it represents an exciting step forward in the field of search-based software testing.
As games become increasingly complex, innovative techniques like this one will be crucial for ensuring that they are thoroughly tested and debugged. By continuing to push the boundaries of what's possible with machine learning and evolutionary algorithms, researchers can help make the game development process more efficient and effective, ultimately leading to better and more enjoyable gaming experiences for players.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Combining Neuroevolution with the Search for Novelty to Improve the Generation of Test Inputs for Games
Patric Feldmeier, Gordon Fraser
As games challenge traditional automated white-box test generators, the Neatest approach generates test suites consisting of neural networks that exercise the source code by playing the games. Neatest generates these neural networks using an evolutionary algorithm that is guided by an objective function targeting individual source code statements. This approach works well if the objective function provides sufficient guidance, but deceiving or complex fitness landscapes may inhibit the search. In this paper, we investigate whether the issue of challenging fitness landscapes can be addressed by promoting novel behaviours during the search. Our case study on two Scratch games demonstrates that rewarding novel behaviours is a promising approach for overcoming challenging fitness landscapes, thus enabling future research on how to adapt the search algorithms to best use this information.
Read more7/9/2024
0
GAVEL: Generating Games Via Evolution and Language Models
Graham Todd, Alexander Padula, Matthew Stephenson, 'Eric Piette, Dennis J. N. J. Soemers, Julian Togelius
Automatically generating novel and interesting games is a complex task. Challenges include representing game rules in a computationally workable form, searching through the large space of potential games under most such representations, and accurately evaluating the originality and quality of previously unseen games. Prior work in automated game generation has largely focused on relatively restricted rule representations and relied on domain-specific heuristics. In this work, we explore the generation of novel games in the comparatively expansive Ludii game description language, which encodes the rules of over 1000 board games in a variety of styles and modes of play. We draw inspiration from recent advances in large language models and evolutionary computation in order to train a model that intelligently mutates and recombines games and mechanics expressed as code. We demonstrate both quantitatively and qualitatively that our approach is capable of generating new and interesting games, including in regions of the potential rules space not covered by existing games in the Ludii dataset. A sample of the generated games are available to play online through the Ludii portal.
Read more7/15/2024
0
Neuroevolving Electronic Dynamical Networks
Derek Whitley
Neuroevolution is a powerful method of applying an evolutionary algorithm to refine the performance of artificial neural networks through natural selection; however, the fitness evaluation of these networks can be time-consuming and computationally expensive, particularly for continuous time recurrent neural networks (CTRNNs) that necessitate the simulation of differential equations. To overcome this challenge, field programmable gate arrays (FPGAs) have emerged as an increasingly popular solution, due to their high performance and low power consumption. Further, their ability to undergo dynamic and partial reconfiguration enables the extremely rapid evaluation of the fitness of CTRNNs, effectively addressing the bottleneck associated with conventional methods. By incorporating fitness evaluation directly upon the programmable logic of the FPGA, hyper-parallel evaluation becomes feasible, dramatically reducing the time required for assessment. This inherent parallelism of FPGAs accelerates the entire neuroevolutionary process by several orders of magnitude, facilitating faster convergence to an optimal solution. The work presented in this study demonstrates the potential of utilizing dynamic and partial reconfiguration on capable FPGAs as a powerful platform for neuroevolving dynamic neural networks.
Read more4/9/2024
0
BEACON: A Bayesian Optimization Strategy for Novelty Search in Expensive Black-Box Systems
Wei-Ting Tang, Ankush Chakrabarty, Joel A. Paulson
Novelty search (NS) refers to a class of exploration algorithms that automatically uncover diverse system behaviors through simulations or experiments. Systematically obtaining diverse outcomes is a key component in many real-world design problems such as material and drug discovery, neural architecture search, reinforcement learning, and robot navigation. Since the relationship between the inputs and outputs (i.e., behaviors) of these complex systems is typically not available in closed form, NS requires a black-box perspective. Consequently, popular NS algorithms rely on evolutionary optimization and other meta-heuristics that require intensive sampling of the input space, which is impractical when the system is expensive to evaluate. We propose a Bayesian optimization inspired algorithm for sample-efficient NS that is specifically designed for such expensive black-box systems. Our approach models the input-to-behavior mapping with multi-output Gaussian processes (MOGP) and selects the next point to evaluate by maximizing a novelty metric that depends on a posterior sample drawn from the MOGP that promotes both exploration and exploitation. By leveraging advances in efficient posterior sampling and high-dimensional Gaussian process modeling, we discuss how our approach can be made scalable with respect to both amount of data and number of inputs. We test our approach on ten synthetic benchmark problems and eight real-world problems (with up to 2133 inputs) including new applications such as discovery of diverse metal organic frameworks for use in clean energy technology. We show that our approach greatly outperforms existing NS algorithms by finding substantially larger sets of diverse behaviors under limited sample budgets.
Read more6/7/2024