ComFeAT: Combination of Neural and Spectral Features for Improved Depression Detection
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Researchers developed a new approach called ComFeAT for detecting depression using a combination of neural and spectral audio features.
- The method aims to improve upon previous speech-based depression detection techniques by leveraging complementary information from different feature types.
- The paper presents empirical results demonstrating the effectiveness of the ComFeAT approach compared to using only neural or spectral features alone.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers in this study wanted to find a better way to detect depression using someone's speech. Previous methods had focused on either analyzing the neural patterns in the voice (how the brain controls the voice) or the spectral patterns (the different frequencies and tones). The new ComFeAT approach combines these two types of features to get a more complete picture.
The idea is that the neural and spectral features capture different, but complementary, information about a person's mental state and how it's reflected in their speech. By putting these two types of features together, the researchers hoped to create a more accurate depression detection system.
To test this, they compared the performance of the ComFeAT method to using just neural features or just spectral features alone. The results showed that the combined approach did indeed outperform the individual feature types, demonstrating the value of this new technique.
Technical Explanation
The researchers developed the ComFeAT (Combination of Neural and Spectral Features for Improved [speech-based] Depression Detection) approach, which combines neural and spectral audio features to improve upon prior methods that have used only one type of feature.
Previous speech-based depression detection research has explored neural features, which capture information about how the brain controls the voice, and spectral features, which capture information about the different frequencies and tones in the voice. The ComFeAT method seeks to leverage the complementary information provided by these two feature types.
The neural feature extraction and spectral feature extraction components are combined using a graph-based multi-feature fusion technique. This allows the model to learn how to best integrate the neural and spectral information for depression detection.
The researchers evaluated the ComFeAT approach on a speech-based depression dataset and found that it outperformed using just neural or just spectral features alone. This novel fusion architecture demonstrates the value of combining complementary feature types for improved clinical depression screening.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough evaluation of the ComFeAT method and its performance relative to using only neural or spectral features. However, the dataset used in the experiments is not publicly available, which limits the ability to independently verify the results.
Additionally, the paper does not provide much insight into the specific types of neural and spectral features that were most informative for depression detection. Further analysis of the learned feature representations could yield additional insights.
The authors also acknowledge that their approach assumes the availability of clean, high-quality audio recordings, which may not always be the case in real-world clinical settings. Robustness to noise and other real-world challenges would be an important area for future research.
Overall, the ComFeAT method represents a promising advance in speech-based depression detection, but additional work is needed to fully understand its strengths, limitations, and practical deployment considerations.
Conclusion
The ComFeAT approach developed in this paper demonstrates the value of combining neural and spectral audio features for improved speech-based depression detection. By leveraging the complementary information captured by these two feature types, the researchers were able to outperform methods using only one feature type.
This work highlights the potential for multimodal approaches to mental health screening and diagnosis, where different data sources and feature representations can be integrated to provide a more comprehensive assessment. As the field of speech-based mental health continues to evolve, techniques like ComFeAT may become increasingly important for developing robust, practical clinical tools.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
ComFeAT: Combination of Neural and Spectral Features for Improved Depression Detection
Orchid Chetia Phukan, Sarthak Jain, Shubham Singh, Muskaan Singh, Arun Balaji Buduru, Rajesh Sharma
In this work, we focus on the detection of depression through speech analysis. Previous research has widely explored features extracted from pre-trained models (PTMs) primarily trained for paralinguistic tasks. Although these features have led to sufficient advances in speech-based depression detection, their performance declines in real-world settings. To address this, in this paper, we introduce ComFeAT, an application that employs a CNN model trained on a combination of features extracted from PTMs, a.k.a. neural features and spectral features to enhance depression detection. Spectral features are robust to domain variations, but, they are not as good as neural features in performance, suprisingly, combining them shows complementary behavior and improves over both neural and spectral features individually. The proposed method also improves over previous state-of-the-art (SOTA) works on E-DAIC benchmark.
Read more6/12/2024
0
Density Adaptive Attention-based Speech Network: Enhancing Feature Understanding for Mental Health Disorders
Georgios Ioannides, Adrian Kieback, Aman Chadha, Aaron Elkins
Speech-based depression detection poses significant challenges for automated detection due to its unique manifestation across individuals and data scarcity. Addressing these challenges, we introduce DAAMAudioCNNLSTM and DAAMAudioTransformer, two parameter efficient and explainable models for audio feature extraction and depression detection. DAAMAudioCNNLSTM features a novel CNN-LSTM framework with multi-head Density Adaptive Attention Mechanism (DAAM), focusing dynamically on informative speech segments. DAAMAudioTransformer, leveraging a transformer encoder in place of the CNN-LSTM architecture, incorporates the same DAAM module for enhanced attention and interpretability. These approaches not only enhance detection robustness and interpretability but also achieve state-of-the-art performance: DAAMAudioCNNLSTM with an F1 macro score of 0.702 and DAAMAudioTransformer with an F1 macro score of 0.72 on the DAIC-WOZ dataset, without reliance on supplementary information such as vowel positions and speaker information during training/validation as in previous approaches. Both models' significant explainability and efficiency in leveraging speech signals for depression detection represent a leap towards more reliable, clinically useful diagnostic tools, promising advancements in speech and mental health care. To foster further research in this domain, we make our code publicly available.
Read more9/4/2024
0
Predicting Individual Depression Symptoms from Acoustic Features During Speech
Sebastian Rodriguez, Sri Harsha Dumpala, Katerina Dikaios, Sheri Rempel, Rudolf Uher, Sageev Oore
Current automatic depression detection systems provide predictions directly without relying on the individual symptoms/items of depression as denoted in the clinical depression rating scales. In contrast, clinicians assess each item in the depression rating scale in a clinical setting, thus implicitly providing a more detailed rationale for a depression diagnosis. In this work, we make a first step towards using the acoustic features of speech to predict individual items of the depression rating scale before obtaining the final depression prediction. For this, we use convolutional (CNN) and recurrent (long short-term memory (LSTM)) neural networks. We consider different approaches to learning the temporal context of speech. Further, we analyze two variants of voting schemes for individual item prediction and depression detection. We also include an animated visualization that shows an example of item prediction over time as the speech progresses.
Read more6/26/2024
0
A Depression Detection Method Based on Multi-Modal Feature Fusion Using Cross-Attention
Shengjie Li, Yinhao Xiao
Depression, a prevalent and serious mental health issue, affects approximately 3.8% of the global population. Despite the existence of effective treatments, over 75% of individuals in low- and middle-income countries remain untreated, partly due to the challenge in accurately diagnosing depression in its early stages. This paper introduces a novel method for detecting depression based on multi-modal feature fusion utilizing cross-attention. By employing MacBERT as a pre-training model to extract lexical features from text and incorporating an additional Transformer module to refine task-specific contextual understanding, the model's adaptability to the targeted task is enhanced. Diverging from previous practices of simply concatenating multimodal features, this approach leverages cross-attention for feature integration, significantly improving the accuracy in depression detection and enabling a more comprehensive and precise analysis of user emotions and behaviors. Furthermore, a Multi-Modal Feature Fusion Network based on Cross-Attention (MFFNC) is constructed, demonstrating exceptional performance in the task of depression identification. The experimental results indicate that our method achieves an accuracy of 0.9495 on the test dataset, marking a substantial improvement over existing approaches. Moreover, it outlines a promising methodology for other social media platforms and tasks involving multi-modal processing. Timely identification and intervention for individuals with depression are crucial for saving lives, highlighting the immense potential of technology in facilitating early intervention for mental health issues.
Read more7/19/2024