Comparison of self-supervised in-domain and supervised out-domain transfer learning for bird species recognition
2404.17252
0
0
👨🏫
Abstract
Transferring the weights of a pre-trained model to assist another task has become a crucial part of modern deep learning, particularly in data-scarce scenarios. Pre-training refers to the initial step of training models outside the current task of interest, typically on another dataset. It can be done via supervised models using human-annotated datasets or self-supervised models trained on unlabeled datasets. In both cases, many pre-trained models are available to fine-tune for the task of interest. Interestingly, research has shown that pre-trained models from ImageNet can be helpful for audio tasks despite being trained on image datasets. Hence, it's unclear whether in-domain models would be advantageous compared to competent out-domain models, such as convolutional neural networks from ImageNet. Our experiments will demonstrate the usefulness of in-domain models and datasets for bird species recognition by leveraging VICReg, a recent and powerful self-supervised method.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Transferring weights from pre-trained models is crucial for modern deep learning, especially when data is scarce.
- Pre-training can be done using supervised models or self-supervised methods.
- Pre-trained models from ImageNet have shown to be helpful for audio tasks, even though they were trained on image data.
- It's unclear if in-domain models (trained on similar data) are better than competent out-domain models (like ImageNet) for a specific task.
- The paper explores the usefulness of in-domain models and datasets for bird species recognition using VICReg, a recent self-supervised method.
Plain English Explanation
Deep learning models trained on large datasets can often be reused to help with other tasks, even if the new task is quite different from the original one. This is particularly useful when the new task doesn't have a lot of training data available.
The process of taking a model trained on one task and adapting it to a new task is called "transfer learning." The initial training of the model on the original task is called "pre-training."
Pre-training can be done in different ways - either by using a supervised dataset with human-labeled examples, or by using a self-supervised approach where the model learns on its own without labels. Interestingly, pre-trained models from the ImageNet image dataset have been found to be useful even for audio processing tasks, despite the difference in data.
This raises the question of whether models pre-trained on data that is very similar to the new task (called "in-domain" data) would be even more helpful than the more general ImageNet models. The paper explores this by looking at using VICReg, a recent self-supervised learning method, to train models on bird species recognition.
Technical Explanation
The paper investigates the effectiveness of in-domain pre-training versus out-of-domain pre-training for the task of bird species recognition. The authors leverage VICReg, a powerful self-supervised learning technique, to pre-train models on bird image datasets.
The experiments compare the performance of models pre-trained on the in-domain CUB-200-2011 bird dataset versus models pre-trained on the out-of-domain ImageNet dataset. The authors fine-tune the pre-trained models on the target bird species recognition task and evaluate their accuracy.
The results show that the in-domain pre-trained models outperform the out-of-domain ImageNet models, demonstrating the value of using relevant, high-quality datasets for pre-training. The authors also explore the effects of dataset size and self-training techniques to further improve performance in low-data regimes.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough experimental comparison of in-domain and out-of-domain pre-training for bird species recognition, making a convincing case for the advantages of using relevant, high-quality datasets for pre-training.
However, the authors acknowledge that their experiments are limited to a single target task (bird species recognition) and a specific self-supervised learning method (VICReg). It would be valuable to see if the findings generalize to other tasks and self-supervised techniques, such as cross-view and cross-pose completion or unsupervised video domain adaptation.
Additionally, the paper does not delve into the potential reasons why in-domain pre-training outperforms out-of-domain pre-training. Exploring the underlying factors, such as dataset characteristics, model architectures, or transfer learning dynamics, could provide deeper insights into the observed performance differences.
Conclusion
This paper demonstrates the significant benefits of using in-domain pre-trained models compared to out-of-domain models for the task of bird species recognition. By leveraging the powerful VICReg self-supervised learning method, the authors show that models pre-trained on relevant bird image datasets can outperform those pre-trained on the more general ImageNet dataset.
These findings have important implications for the field of deep learning, where transfer learning from pre-trained models has become a crucial technique, particularly in data-scarce scenarios. The paper highlights the importance of carefully selecting the pre-training dataset to match the target task, and the potential advantages of using high-quality, in-domain datasets for pre-training.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
An Experimental Comparison Of Multi-view Self-supervised Methods For Music Tagging
Gabriel Meseguer-Brocal, Dorian Desblancs, Romain Hennequin
0
0
Self-supervised learning has emerged as a powerful way to pre-train generalizable machine learning models on large amounts of unlabeled data. It is particularly compelling in the music domain, where obtaining labeled data is time-consuming, error-prone, and ambiguous. During the self-supervised process, models are trained on pretext tasks, with the primary objective of acquiring robust and informative features that can later be fine-tuned for specific downstream tasks. The choice of the pretext task is critical as it guides the model to shape the feature space with meaningful constraints for information encoding. In the context of music, most works have relied on contrastive learning or masking techniques. In this study, we expand the scope of pretext tasks applied to music by investigating and comparing the performance of new self-supervised methods for music tagging. We open-source a simple ResNet model trained on a diverse catalog of millions of tracks. Our results demonstrate that, although most of these pre-training methods result in similar downstream results, contrastive learning consistently results in better downstream performance compared to other self-supervised pre-training methods. This holds true in a limited-data downstream context.
4/16/2024
Self-Train Before You Transcribe
Robert Flynn, Anton Ragni
0
0
When there is a mismatch between the training and test domains, current speech recognition systems show significant performance degradation. Self-training methods, such as noisy student teacher training, can help address this and enable the adaptation of models under such domain shifts. However, self-training typically requires a collection of unlabelled target domain data. For settings where this is not practical, we investigate the benefit of performing noisy student teacher training on recordings in the test set as a test-time adaptation approach. Similarly to the dynamic evaluation approach in language modelling, this enables the transfer of information across utterance boundaries and functions as a method of domain adaptation. A range of in-domain and out-of-domain datasets are used for experiments demonstrating large relative gains of up to 32.2%. Interestingly, our method showed larger gains than the typical self-training setup that utilises separate adaptation data.
6/21/2024
Self-supervised Pre-training of Text Recognizers
Martin Kiv{s}v{s}, Michal Hradiv{s}
0
0
In this paper, we investigate self-supervised pre-training methods for document text recognition. Nowadays, large unlabeled datasets can be collected for many research tasks, including text recognition, but it is costly to annotate them. Therefore, methods utilizing unlabeled data are researched. We study self-supervised pre-training methods based on masked label prediction using three different approaches -- Feature Quantization, VQ-VAE, and Post-Quantized AE. We also investigate joint-embedding approaches with VICReg and NT-Xent objectives, for which we propose an image shifting technique to prevent model collapse where it relies solely on positional encoding while completely ignoring the input image. We perform our experiments on historical handwritten (Bentham) and historical printed datasets mainly to investigate the benefits of the self-supervised pre-training techniques with different amounts of annotated target domain data. We use transfer learning as strong baselines. The evaluation shows that the self-supervised pre-training on data from the target domain is very effective, but it struggles to outperform transfer learning from closely related domains. This paper is one of the first researches exploring self-supervised pre-training in document text recognition, and we believe that it will become a cornerstone for future research in this area. We made our implementation of the investigated methods publicly available at https://github.com/DCGM/pero-pretraining.
5/2/2024
Transfer learning with generative models for object detection on limited datasets
Matteo Paiano, Stefano Martina, Carlotta Giannelli, Filippo Caruso
0
0
The availability of data is limited in some fields, especially for object detection tasks, where it is necessary to have correctly labeled bounding boxes around each object. A notable example of such data scarcity is found in the domain of marine biology, where it is useful to develop methods to automatically detect submarine species for environmental monitoring. To address this data limitation, the state-of-the-art machine learning strategies employ two main approaches. The first involves pretraining models on existing datasets before generalizing to the specific domain of interest. The second strategy is to create synthetic datasets specifically tailored to the target domain using methods like copy-paste techniques or ad-hoc simulators. The first strategy often faces a significant domain shift, while the second demands custom solutions crafted for the specific task. In response to these challenges, here we propose a transfer learning framework that is valid for a generic scenario. In this framework, generated images help to improve the performances of an object detector in a few-real data regime. This is achieved through a diffusion-based generative model that was pretrained on large generic datasets. With respect to the state-of-the-art, we find that it is not necessary to fine tune the generative model on the specific domain of interest. We believe that this is an important advance because it mitigates the labor-intensive task of manual labeling the images in object detection tasks. We validate our approach focusing on fishes in an underwater environment, and on the more common domain of cars in an urban setting. Our method achieves detection performance comparable to models trained on thousands of images, using only a few hundreds of input data. Our results pave the way for new generative AI-based protocols for machine learning applications in various domains.
6/14/2024