An Experimental Comparison Of Multi-view Self-supervised Methods For Music Tagging
2404.09177
0
0
Abstract
Self-supervised learning has emerged as a powerful way to pre-train generalizable machine learning models on large amounts of unlabeled data. It is particularly compelling in the music domain, where obtaining labeled data is time-consuming, error-prone, and ambiguous. During the self-supervised process, models are trained on pretext tasks, with the primary objective of acquiring robust and informative features that can later be fine-tuned for specific downstream tasks. The choice of the pretext task is critical as it guides the model to shape the feature space with meaningful constraints for information encoding. In the context of music, most works have relied on contrastive learning or masking techniques. In this study, we expand the scope of pretext tasks applied to music by investigating and comparing the performance of new self-supervised methods for music tagging. We open-source a simple ResNet model trained on a diverse catalog of millions of tracks. Our results demonstrate that, although most of these pre-training methods result in similar downstream results, contrastive learning consistently results in better downstream performance compared to other self-supervised pre-training methods. This holds true in a limited-data downstream context.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents an experimental comparison of different multi-view self-supervised methods for music tagging.
- Music tagging is the task of automatically assigning semantic tags (e.g., genres, moods, instruments) to music audio.
- The authors evaluate several self-supervised pretext tasks, where the model learns representations by solving auxiliary objectives without the need for labeled data.
- The goal is to understand which self-supervised methods are most effective for downstream music tagging performance.
Plain English Explanation
In this paper, the researchers explored different techniques for teaching computers to understand and categorize music without relying on labeled data. Music tagging is the process of automatically assigning semantic labels, like genre or mood, to music audio files. The researchers evaluated several "self-supervised" methods, where the model learns useful representations by solving auxiliary tasks, rather than being trained directly on the final music tagging objective.
The motivation behind this work is to find self-supervised approaches that can effectively capture the rich information in music and lead to strong performance on the downstream music tagging task, without the need for large amounts of labeled training data. By comparing the effectiveness of different self-supervised pretext tasks, the researchers aim to provide insights into which techniques work best for understanding and categorizing music.
Technical Explanation
The paper evaluates several multi-view self-supervised learning methods for music tagging, including popular techniques like contrastive learning and multi-stage pre-training. The authors consider both single-modal and multi-modal pretext tasks, leveraging different views of the music data such as the raw audio waveform, mel-spectrograms, and text lyrics.
The key experiment is to train models on these self-supervised pretext tasks and then evaluate their performance on the downstream music tagging benchmark. The authors analyze how the choice of pretext task and data modalities impact the final tagging accuracy. They also investigate the role of dataset size and explore how self-supervised pre-training can benefit from data augmentation techniques.
Through their extensive experiments, the researchers provide insights into the relative strengths and weaknesses of different self-supervised approaches for music understanding. The findings can inform the design of more effective self-supervised models for music analysis and other audio-based tasks.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough empirical comparison of several state-of-the-art self-supervised methods for music tagging. The authors acknowledge that the performance of these techniques can be sensitive to hyperparameter choices and the specifics of the downstream task. Further research is needed to better understand the factors that contribute to the effectiveness of self-supervised learning for music understanding.
Additionally, the authors only evaluate on a single music tagging benchmark dataset. It would be valuable to assess the generalization of these findings across a wider range of music datasets and tasks, such as music genre classification or music generation. Exploring the interpretability and robustness of the learned representations could also yield additional insights.
Conclusion
This paper provides a comprehensive experimental comparison of different multi-view self-supervised methods for music tagging. The authors demonstrate that self-supervised learning can be an effective approach for music understanding, with certain pretext tasks and data modalities outperforming others on the downstream music tagging task.
The insights from this work can guide the development of more powerful self-supervised models for music analysis and other audio-based applications. By leveraging large unlabeled datasets, self-supervised learning offers a promising path for advancing the state of the art in music understanding without the need for extensive manual labeling.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Self-supervised Pre-training of Text Recognizers
Martin Kiv{s}v{s}, Michal Hradiv{s}
0
0
In this paper, we investigate self-supervised pre-training methods for document text recognition. Nowadays, large unlabeled datasets can be collected for many research tasks, including text recognition, but it is costly to annotate them. Therefore, methods utilizing unlabeled data are researched. We study self-supervised pre-training methods based on masked label prediction using three different approaches -- Feature Quantization, VQ-VAE, and Post-Quantized AE. We also investigate joint-embedding approaches with VICReg and NT-Xent objectives, for which we propose an image shifting technique to prevent model collapse where it relies solely on positional encoding while completely ignoring the input image. We perform our experiments on historical handwritten (Bentham) and historical printed datasets mainly to investigate the benefits of the self-supervised pre-training techniques with different amounts of annotated target domain data. We use transfer learning as strong baselines. The evaluation shows that the self-supervised pre-training on data from the target domain is very effective, but it struggles to outperform transfer learning from closely related domains. This paper is one of the first researches exploring self-supervised pre-training in document text recognition, and we believe that it will become a cornerstone for future research in this area. We made our implementation of the investigated methods publicly available at https://github.com/DCGM/pero-pretraining.
5/2/2024
š
A review on discriminative self-supervised learning methods
Nikolaos Giakoumoglou, Tania Stathaki
0
0
In the field of computer vision, self-supervised learning has emerged as a method to extract robust features from unlabeled data, where models derive labels autonomously from the data itself, without the need for manual annotation. This paper provides a comprehensive review of discriminative approaches of self-supervised learning within the domain of computer vision, examining their evolution and current status. Through an exploration of various methods including contrastive, self-distillation, knowledge distillation, feature decorrelation, and clustering techniques, we investigate how these approaches leverage the abundance of unlabeled data. Finally, we have comparison of self-supervised learning methods on the standard ImageNet classification benchmark.
5/9/2024
šØāš«
Comparison of self-supervised in-domain and supervised out-domain transfer learning for bird species recognition
Houtan Ghaffari, Paul Devos
0
0
Transferring the weights of a pre-trained model to assist another task has become a crucial part of modern deep learning, particularly in data-scarce scenarios. Pre-training refers to the initial step of training models outside the current task of interest, typically on another dataset. It can be done via supervised models using human-annotated datasets or self-supervised models trained on unlabeled datasets. In both cases, many pre-trained models are available to fine-tune for the task of interest. Interestingly, research has shown that pre-trained models from ImageNet can be helpful for audio tasks despite being trained on image datasets. Hence, it's unclear whether in-domain models would be advantageous compared to competent out-domain models, such as convolutional neural networks from ImageNet. Our experiments will demonstrate the usefulness of in-domain models and datasets for bird species recognition by leveraging VICReg, a recent and powerful self-supervised method.
4/29/2024
Exploring Self-Supervised Multi-view Contrastive Learning for Speech Emotion Recognition with Limited Annotations
Bulat Khaertdinov, Pedro Jeuris, Annanda Sousa, Enrique Hortal
0
0
Recent advancements in Deep and Self-Supervised Learning (SSL) have led to substantial improvements in Speech Emotion Recognition (SER) performance, reaching unprecedented levels. However, obtaining sufficient amounts of accurately labeled data for training or fine-tuning the models remains a costly and challenging task. In this paper, we propose a multi-view SSL pre-training technique that can be applied to various representations of speech, including the ones generated by large speech models, to improve SER performance in scenarios where annotations are limited. Our experiments, based on wav2vec 2.0, spectral and paralinguistic features, demonstrate that the proposed framework boosts the SER performance, by up to 10% in Unweighted Average Recall, in settings with extremely sparse data annotations.
6/13/2024