The complexity of approximate (coarse) correlated equilibrium for incomplete information games
0
🤿
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper examines the complexity of finding approximate (coarse) correlated equilibria in incomplete information games.
- The authors prove a lower bound on the external regret that any efficient algorithm must suffer when trying to find such equilibria.
- This result has implications for the polynomial-time approximation scheme equilibriums games and the convergence to coarse correlated equilibria problems.
Plain English Explanation
In games where players have incomplete information about each other's strategies or payoffs, finding an approximate "correlated equilibrium" is a challenging problem. A correlated equilibrium is a way for players to coordinate their actions in a game to achieve a better outcome for everyone. However, when players don't have full information, it becomes harder to find these kinds of stable coordinated strategies.
The authors of this paper show that any efficient algorithm tasked with finding these approximate correlated equilibria must suffer a certain minimum amount of "external regret." External regret measures how much a player's payoff could have improved if they had access to additional information. The lower bound on external regret proven in this paper indicates that there are fundamental limitations on how quickly we can find these types of equilibria in incomplete information games, even with approximations.
This result has implications for related problems, such as finding good approximations of Nash equilibria and efficiently converging to coarse correlated equilibria. It suggests that there are inherent challenges in designing fast algorithms for these tasks, especially when players have incomplete information about the game.
Technical Explanation
The paper proves a lower bound on the external regret that any efficient algorithm must suffer when trying to find an approximate (coarse) correlated equilibrium in an incomplete information game. Specifically, the authors show that any algorithm that runs in polynomial time can be forced to have external regret that is at least inverse-polynomial in the size of the game.
This result builds on prior work on learning Nash equilibria in zero-sum Markov games and near-optimal policy optimization in correlated equilibrium. The authors leverage techniques from computational complexity theory, including reductions from the Unique Games Conjecture, to establish this lower bound.
The significance of this result is that it suggests inherent limitations on how quickly we can find approximate correlated equilibria, even with access to polynomial-time algorithms. This has implications for applications where efficient equilibrium computation is crucial, such as in convergence to coarse correlated equilibria and polynomial-time approximation schemes for equilibriums in games.
Critical Analysis
The authors provide a thorough and technically rigorous analysis of the complexity of finding approximate correlated equilibria in incomplete information games. Their proof of the lower bound on external regret is well-constructed and leverages established results from computational complexity theory.
One potential limitation of the work is that it focuses solely on the theoretical complexity of the problem, without considering the practical implications or potential workarounds. For example, the authors do not discuss whether there are specific game classes or settings where the lower bound might not apply, or if there are ways to circumvent the regret limitations through alternative algorithmic approaches.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the potential real-world impact of this result. It would be valuable to understand how this complexity result might affect the development of applications that rely on efficient equilibrium computation, such as in multi-agent systems or mechanism design.
Overall, the paper makes an important contribution to the theoretical understanding of the challenges involved in finding approximate correlated equilibria. However, further research is needed to fully contextualize the implications of this work and explore potential solutions or mitigating factors.
Conclusion
This paper establishes a lower bound on the external regret that any efficient algorithm must suffer when trying to find an approximate (coarse) correlated equilibrium in an incomplete information game. The authors prove that any polynomial-time algorithm can be forced to have regret that is at least inverse-polynomial in the size of the game.
This result has significant implications for related problems, such as finding good approximations of Nash equilibria and efficiently converging to coarse correlated equilibria. It suggests that there are inherent limitations on how quickly we can compute these types of equilibria, even with access to powerful algorithms.
While the paper provides a rigorous theoretical analysis, further research is needed to fully understand the practical implications of this complexity result and explore potential solutions or workarounds. Nonetheless, this work represents an important step forward in understanding the challenges involved in equilibrium computation for incomplete information games.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤿
0
The complexity of approximate (coarse) correlated equilibrium for incomplete information games
Binghui Peng, Aviad Rubinstein
We study the iteration complexity of decentralized learning of approximate correlated equilibria in incomplete information games. On the negative side, we prove that in $mathit{extensive}$-$mathit{form}$ $mathit{games}$, assuming $mathsf{PPAD} notsubset mathsf{TIME}(n^{mathsf{polylog}(n)})$, any polynomial-time learning algorithms must take at least $2^{log_2^{1-o(1)}(|mathcal{I}|)}$ iterations to converge to the set of $epsilon$-approximate correlated equilibrium, where $|mathcal{I}|$ is the number of nodes in the game and $epsilon > 0$ is an absolute constant. This nearly matches, up to the $o(1)$ term, the algorithms of [PR'24, DDFG'24] for learning $epsilon$-approximate correlated equilibrium, and resolves an open question of Anagnostides, Kalavasis, Sandholm, and Zampetakis [AKSZ'24]. Our lower bound holds even for the easier solution concept of $epsilon$-approximate $mathit{coarse}$ correlated equilibrium On the positive side, we give uncoupled dynamics that reach $epsilon$-approximate correlated equilibria of a $mathit{Bayesian}$ $mathit{game}$ in polylogarithmic iterations, without any dependence of the number of types. This demonstrates a separation between Bayesian games and extensive-form games.
Read more6/5/2024
0
Polynomial-time Approximation Scheme for Equilibriums of Games
Hongbo Sun, Chongkun Xia, Junbo Tan, Bo Yuan, Xueqian Wang, Bin Liang
Whether a PTAS (polynomial-time approximation scheme) exists for game equilibriums has been an open question, and the absence of this polynomial-time algorithm has indications and consequences in three fields, such as the practicality of methods in algorithmic game theory, non-stationarity and curse of multiagency in MARL (multi-agent reinforcement learning), and the tractability of PPAD in computational complexity theory. In this paper, we introduce a geometric object called equilibrium bundle, which leads to a fundamental leap in the understanding of game equilibriums. Regarding the equilibrium bundle, first, we formalize perfect equilibriums of dynamic games as the zero points of its canonical section, second, we formalize a hybrid iteration of dynamic programming and interior point method as a line search on it, such that the method is an FPTAS (fully PTAS) for any perfect equilibrium of any dynamic game, implying PPAD=FP, third, we give the existence and oddness theorems of it as an extension of those of Nash equilibriums. As intermediate results, we introduce a concept called policy cone to give the sufficient and necessary condition for dynamic programming to converge to perfect equilibriums, and introduce two concepts called unbiased barrier problem and unbiased KKT conditions to make the interior point method to approximate Nash equilibriums. In experiment, the line search process is animated, and the method is tested on 2000 randomly generated dynamic games where it converges to a perfect equilibrium in every single case.
Read more9/10/2024
0
$widetilde{O}(T^{-1})$ Convergence to (Coarse) Correlated Equilibria in Full-Information General-Sum Markov Games
Weichao Mao, Haoran Qiu, Chen Wang, Hubertus Franke, Zbigniew Kalbarczyk, Tamer Bac{s}ar
No-regret learning has a long history of being closely connected to game theory. Recent works have devised uncoupled no-regret learning dynamics that, when adopted by all the players in normal-form games, converge to various equilibrium solutions at a near-optimal rate of $widetilde{O}(T^{-1})$, a significant improvement over the $O(1/sqrt{T})$ rate of classic no-regret learners. However, analogous convergence results are scarce in Markov games, a more generic setting that lays the foundation for multi-agent reinforcement learning. In this work, we close this gap by showing that the optimistic-follow-the-regularized-leader (OFTRL) algorithm, together with appropriate value update procedures, can find $widetilde{O}(T^{-1})$-approximate (coarse) correlated equilibria in full-information general-sum Markov games within $T$ iterations. Numerical results are also included to corroborate our theoretical findings.
Read more4/24/2024
🛠️
0
Near-Optimal Policy Optimization for Correlated Equilibrium in General-Sum Markov Games
Yang Cai, Haipeng Luo, Chen-Yu Wei, Weiqiang Zheng
We study policy optimization algorithms for computing correlated equilibria in multi-player general-sum Markov Games. Previous results achieve $O(T^{-1/2})$ convergence rate to a correlated equilibrium and an accelerated $O(T^{-3/4})$ convergence rate to the weaker notion of coarse correlated equilibrium. In this paper, we improve both results significantly by providing an uncoupled policy optimization algorithm that attains a near-optimal $tilde{O}(T^{-1})$ convergence rate for computing a correlated equilibrium. Our algorithm is constructed by combining two main elements (i) smooth value updates and (ii) the optimistic-follow-the-regularized-leader algorithm with the log barrier regularizer.
Read more5/3/2024