Concurrent aggregate queries
0
🗣️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper addresses the lack of concurrent data structures that support efficient aggregate queries, which are essential for many applications.
- The authors formalize a type of aggregate queries that can be efficiently supported by concurrent trees and present two algorithms for implementing these queries.
- The algorithms offer a trade-off between update time and query time, allowing developers to choose the approach that best fits their needs.
Plain English Explanation
Concurrent computing is an essential part of modern software systems, and data structures that can handle concurrent access are crucial building blocks. While many concurrent versions of basic data structures like lists and queues have been developed, one notable gap is a concurrent tree data structure that can efficiently perform aggregate queries.
Aggregate queries are a type of analysis that summarizes information across a range of data items. For example, you might want to calculate the average salary of all employees in their 30s. These kinds of queries are commonly taught in computer science courses and are used in many real-world applications.
The researchers in this paper tackled the problem of designing a concurrent tree data structure that can handle these aggregate queries efficiently. They came up with two different algorithms, each of which has its own strengths and tradeoffs. One algorithm optimizes for fast tree updates, while the other focuses on speeding up the aggregate queries.
By providing these two options, the researchers give developers the flexibility to choose the approach that works best for their specific needs. If your application prioritizes frequently updating the data, you might go with the first algorithm. But if you need to run aggregate queries often, the second algorithm could be a better fit.
Overall, this research helps fill an important gap in the world of concurrent data structures and opens the door for more powerful and flexible data analysis capabilities in a wide range of applications.
Technical Explanation
The core contribution of this paper is the design and analysis of two concurrent tree data structures that support efficient aggregate queries. These structures are based on the binary search tree, a fundamental data structure commonly taught in computer science courses.
The first algorithm, optimized for tree updates, uses a lock-based synchronization approach to ensure consistency during concurrent modifications. It achieves this by acquiring locks on individual tree nodes, which allows multiple threads to safely update different parts of the tree simultaneously.
The second algorithm, optimized for aggregate queries, takes a different approach. It employs a lock-free design, where updates are performed without any locks. Instead, it relies on atomic operations and a partial order data structure to maintain consistency. This lock-free approach allows for faster query times, as there is no contention for locks during the query process.
The authors provide a detailed analysis of the correctness and complexity of these two algorithms, demonstrating the trade-offs between update time and query time. They show that the lock-based algorithm has better update performance, while the lock-free algorithm excels at aggregate queries.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a valuable contribution by addressing the lack of concurrent tree data structures that support efficient aggregate queries. By providing two different algorithms, the authors give developers the flexibility to choose the approach that best fits their application's needs.
However, the paper does not discuss the potential impact of the size of the tree on the performance of the algorithms. In real-world scenarios, trees can grow quite large, and the scalability of these concurrent tree structures as the data size increases is an important consideration.
Additionally, the paper focuses on a specific type of aggregate query, but there may be other types of aggregate queries that could be supported by these concurrent tree structures. Exploring the generalizability of the approach to a wider range of aggregate queries could be an interesting area for future research.
Finally, the paper does not provide any empirical evaluation of the algorithms' performance in real-world or simulated scenarios. Implementing and benchmarking these concurrent tree structures would be a valuable next step to validate the theoretical analysis and understand their practical implications.
Conclusion
This paper presents an important contribution to the field of concurrent data structures by proposing two algorithms for implementing concurrent trees that support efficient aggregate queries. These data structures have the potential to enable more powerful and flexible data analysis capabilities in a wide range of applications.
The trade-off between update time and query time offered by the two algorithms gives developers the flexibility to choose the approach that best fits their needs. This flexibility is a key strength of the research, as the optimal solution can vary depending on the specific requirements of the application.
Overall, this work helps to fill a notable gap in the concurrent data structures landscape and lays the groundwork for further advancements in this area. As the demand for efficient and scalable data analysis tools continues to grow, the insights and techniques presented in this paper could have significant implications for the future of concurrent computing.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🗣️
0
Concurrent aggregate queries
Gal Sela, Erez Petrank
Concurrent data structures serve as fundamental building blocks for concurrent computing. Many concurrent counterparts have been designed for basic sequential mechanisms; however, one notable omission is a concurrent tree that supports aggregate queries. Aggregate queries essentially compile succinct information about a range of data items, for example, calculating the average salary of employees in their 30s. Such queries play an essential role in various applications and are commonly taught in undergraduate data structures courses. In this paper, we formalize a type of aggregate queries that can be efficiently supported by concurrent trees and present a design for implementing these queries on concurrent trees. We bring two algorithms implementing this design, where one optimizes for tree update time, while the other optimizes for aggregate query time. We analyze their correctness and complexity, demonstrating the trade-offs between query time and update time.
Read more5/14/2024
0
Efficient Distributed Data Structures for Future Many-core Architectures
Panagiota Fatourou, Nikolaos D. Kallimanis, Eleni Kanellou, Odysseas Makridakis, Christi Symeonidou
We study general techniques for implementing distributed data structures on top of future many-core architectures with non cache-coherent or partially cache-coherent memory. With the goal of contributing towards what might become, in the future, the concurrency utilities package in Java collections for such architectures, we end up with a comprehensive collection of data structures by considering different variants of these techniques. To achieve scalability, we study a generic scheme which makes all our implementations hierarchical. We consider a collection of known techniques for improving the scalability of concurrent data structures and we adjust them to work in our setting. We have performed experiments which illustrate that some of these techniques have indeed high impact on achieving scalability. Our experiments also reveal the performance and scalability power of the hierarchical approach. We finally present experiments to study energy consumption aspects of the proposed techniques by using an energy model recently proposed for such architectures.
Read more4/9/2024
📊
10
Concurrent Data Structures Made Easy (Extended Version)
Callista Le, Kiran Gopinathan, Koon Wen Lee, Seth Gilbert, Ilya Sergey
Design of an efficient thread-safe concurrent data structure is a balancing act between its implementation complexity and performance. Lock-based concurrent data structures, which are relatively easy to derive from their sequential counterparts and to prove thread-safe, suffer from poor throughput under even light multi-threaded workload. At the same time, lock-free concurrent structures allow for high throughput, but are notoriously difficult to get right and require careful reasoning to formally establish their correctness. We explore a solution to this conundrum based on batch parallelism, an approach for designing concurrent data structures via a simple insight: efficiently processing a batch of a priori known operations in parallel is easier than optimising performance for a stream of arbitrary asynchronous requests. Alas, batch-parallel structures have not seen wide practical adoption due to (i) the inconvenience of having to structure multi-threaded programs to explicitly group operations and (ii) the lack of a systematic methodology to implement batch-parallel structures as simply as lock-based ones. We present OBatcher-an OCaml library that streamlines the design, implementation, and usage of batch-parallel structures. It solves the first challenge (how to use) by suggesting a new lightweight implicit batching design that is built on top of generic asynchronous programming mechanisms. The second challenge (how to implement) is addressed by identifying a family of strategies for converting common sequential structures into efficient batch-parallel ones. We showcase OBatcher with a diverse set of benchmarks. Our evaluation of all the implementations on large asynchronous workloads shows that (a) they consistently outperform the corresponding coarse-grained lock-based implementations and that (b) their throughput scales reasonably with the number of processors.
Read more8/27/2024
📊
0
CSSTs: A Dynamic Data Structure for Partial Orders in Concurrent Execution Analysis
Hunkar Can Tunc{c}, Ameya Prashant Deshmukh, Berk c{C}irisci, Constantin Enea, Andreas Pavlogiannis
Dynamic analyses are a standard approach to analyzing and testing concurrent programs. Such techniques observe program traces and analyze them to infer the presence or absence of bugs. At its core, each analysis maintains a partial order $P$ that represents order dependencies between events of the analyzed trace $sigma$. Naturally, the scalability of the analysis largely depends on how efficiently it maintains $P$. The standard data structure for this task has thus far been vector clocks. These, however, are slow for analyses that follow a non-streaming style, costing $O(n)$ for inserting (and propagating) each new ordering in $P$, where $n$ is the size of $sigma$, while they cannot handle the deletion of existing orderings. In this paper we develop collective sparse segment trees (CSSTs), a simple but elegant data structure for generically maintaining a partial order $P$. CSSTs thrive when the width $k$ of $P$ is much smaller than the size $n$ of its domain, allowing inserting, deleting, and querying for orderings in $P$ to run in $O(logn)$ time. For a concurrent trace, $k$ is bounded by the number of its threads, and is normally orders of magnitude smaller than its size $n$, making CSSTs fitting for this setting. Our experimental results confirm that CSSTs are the best data structure currently to handle a range of dynamic analyses from existing literature.
Read more4/1/2024