Conjectural Online Learning with First-order Beliefs in Asymmetric Information Stochastic Games

Overview

• Asymmetric information stochastic games (AISGs) arise in complex systems like cyber-physical infrastructure.
• Existing methods for AISGs are primarily offline and cannot adapt to changes in equilibrium.
• Current methods are limited to specific information structures to avoid belief hierarchies.
• This paper proposes conjectural online learning (COL), an online learning method for AISGs with generic information structures.

Plain English Explanation

Asymmetric information stochastic games (AISGs) are a type of strategic decision-making scenario that occurs in many real-world complex systems, such as the management of cyber-physical infrastructure or IT networks. In these situations, different parties have access to different information, which affects their decision-making and the overall dynamics of the system.

The existing computational methods for solving AISGs are primarily offline, meaning they are performed before the system is put into operation. This means they cannot adapt to changes or deviations from the expected equilibrium that may occur during real-world usage. Additionally, current methods are limited to specific information structures in order to avoid the complexity of dealing with "belief hierarchies" - the reasoning that players have about each other's knowledge and beliefs.

To address these limitations, the researchers propose a new approach called conjectural online learning (COL). COL is an online learning method, meaning it can continuously adapt the players' strategies based on feedback from the system. Importantly, COL can handle generic information structures, not just the limited cases that current methods can handle.

The key idea behind COL is to use a "forecaster-actor-critic" architecture. The "forecaster" component tries to conjecture or predict the other players' strategies within a certain "lookahead horizon." The "actor-critic" component then uses this forecasted information, along with feedback from the system, to adapt the player's own strategy in an ongoing way. This allows COL to operate effectively even in nonstationary environments where the optimal strategies may change over time.

Technical Explanation

The conjectural online learning (COL) approach proposed in this paper uses a forecaster-actor-critic (FAC) architecture to tackle AISGs with generic information structures. The forecaster component tries to conjecture the opponents' strategies within a lookahead horizon, while the actor-critic component uses online rollout with cost function approximation to adapt the player's own strategy based on information feedback.

The key innovation is that the conjectures produced by COL are asymptotically consistent with the information feedback, in the sense of a relaxed Bayesian consistency. This means the conjectures converge to the true underlying strategies as more information is observed over time. The paper also proves that the empirical strategy profile induced by COL converges to the Berk-Nash equilibrium, a solution concept that characterizes rationality under subjectivity (i.e., when players have different information and beliefs).

Experimental results from an intrusion response use case demonstrate that COL achieves faster convergence compared to state-of-the-art reinforcement learning methods, especially when facing nonstationary attacks.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a valuable contribution by proposing COL, an online learning approach for AISGs that can handle generic information structures. This is an important advance over existing methods, which are limited to specific information structures to avoid the complexity of belief hierarchies.

However, the paper does not extensively discuss the potential limitations or caveats of the COL approach. For example, it is unclear how COL would scale to large, complex systems with many players and information asymmetries. The convergence guarantees are also based on asymptotic results, so the performance of COL in practical, finite-time scenarios may differ.

Additionally, the experimental evaluation is focused on a single use case of intrusion response. It would be helpful to see how COL performs across a wider range of AISG applications to better understand its strengths and weaknesses.

Conclusion

This paper introduces conjectural online learning (COL), a novel approach for solving asymmetric information stochastic games (AISGs) that can handle generic information structures. By using a forecaster-actor-critic architecture, COL is able to adapt players' strategies in an online manner, even in nonstationary environments.

The key theoretical contributions are the proofs of asymptotic consistency for the conjectures and convergence to the Berk-Nash equilibrium. Experimentally, COL is shown to outperform state-of-the-art reinforcement learning methods in an intrusion response use case.

While the paper represents an important advance, further research is needed to fully understand the strengths, limitations, and scalability of the COL approach across a wider range of AISG applications. Nonetheless, this work demonstrates the potential of online learning methods to tackle the challenges of decision-making under asymmetric information in complex, dynamic systems.