Automated Security Response through Online Learning with Adaptive Conjectures

Overview

• Researchers study automated security response for IT infrastructure
• Interaction between attacker and defender formulated as a partially observed, non-stationary game
• Relax assumption that game model is correctly specified
• Each player has probabilistic conjecture about model, which may be misspecified
• Allows capturing uncertainty about infrastructure and player intents

Plain English Explanation

The researchers looked at how to automatically respond to security threats in an IT network. They modeled the interaction between an attacker and a defender as a type of game where each player has an idea, or "conjecture," about how the game works, but that conjecture might not match reality. This allows the model to account for uncertainty about the network and what the players are trying to do.

To develop effective security strategies, the researchers designed a method where each player repeatedly updates their conjecture using Bayesian learning and then updates their strategy based on that conjecture. The paper shows that the conjectures will converge to the best guesses, and the strategy updates will improve performance.

The researchers also propose a new type of game equilibrium, called Berk-Nash equilibrium, to represent the stable state of the game. They demonstrate their method using a real-world advanced persistent threat scenario, and find that it produces effective security strategies that can adapt to changes in the environment. Compared to current reinforcement learning techniques, this new method also converges faster.

Technical Explanation

The researchers formulate the interaction between an attacker and a defender as a partially observed, non-stationary game. They relax the standard assumption that the game model is correctly specified, and instead consider that each player has a probabilistic conjecture about the model, which may be misspecified compared to the true model.

To learn effective game strategies online, the researchers design a novel method where a player iteratively adapts its conjecture using Bayesian learning and updates its strategy through rollout. They prove that the conjectures converge to best fits, and provide a bound on the performance improvement that rollout enables with a conjectured model.

To characterize the steady state of the game, the researchers propose a variant of the Berk-Nash equilibrium. They present their method through an advanced persistent threat use case, and testbed evaluations show that their method produces effective security strategies that adapt to a changing environment. They also find that their method enables faster convergence than current reinforcement learning techniques.

Critical Analysis

The paper addresses an important challenge in cybersecurity by allowing for uncertainty in the game model. This is a realistic extension, as in practice, defenders often have imperfect information about the infrastructure and attacker strategies.

One potential limitation is the reliance on Bayesian learning, which can be computationally intensive, especially as the model complexity increases. The researchers mention this and suggest exploring approximation techniques to improve scalability.

Additionally, the proposed Berk-Nash equilibrium concept is novel, and its real-world applicability and convergence properties may require further investigation and validation. Comparing the performance of this equilibrium to other solution concepts, such as Stackelberg equilibrium, could provide additional insights.

Conclusion

This research proposes a novel approach to modeling security interactions as a game with model uncertainty. By allowing players to have misspecified conjectures about the game, the method can better capture the realities of cybersecurity, where defenders often have incomplete information about the infrastructure and attacker intentions.

The researchers demonstrate that their online learning approach can produce effective security strategies that adapt to changing environments, and that it converges faster than existing reinforcement learning techniques. While the computational complexity and the properties of the Berk-Nash equilibrium require further study, this work represents an important step towards more realistic and adaptive security systems.