Cost-Efficient Prompt Engineering for Unsupervised Entity Resolution
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates how prompt engineering affects the performance of the ChatGPT language model on unsupervised entity resolution tasks.
- Prompt engineering involves carefully crafting the input prompts given to large language models like ChatGPT to guide their behavior and outputs.
- The study evaluates different prompt engineering strategies and their impact on ChatGPT's ability to identify and resolve entities in unstructured text without supervision.
Plain English Explanation
Prompt engineering is the process of carefully designing the instructions or "prompts" that are given to large language models like ChatGPT. These prompts can significantly influence the model's behavior and the quality of its outputs. This paper examines how different prompt engineering techniques affect ChatGPT's performance on a specific task called unsupervised entity resolution.
Entity resolution is the process of identifying and grouping together references to the same real-world entities (like people, places, or organizations) that are mentioned in unstructured text. Unsupervised entity resolution means doing this without any labeled training data - the model has to figure it out on its own.
The researchers tested various prompt engineering strategies to see which ones allowed ChatGPT to do the best job at unsupervised entity resolution. This provides insights into how prompt design can be leveraged to optimize the capabilities of large language models like ChatGPT for specific applications.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents an experimental study that investigates the impact of prompt engineering on the performance of the ChatGPT language model for unsupervised entity resolution.
The researchers designed a set of prompts that instructed ChatGPT to identify and group together references to the same entities in unstructured text. These prompts varied in their level of specificity, framing, and other attributes. ChatGPT's outputs were then evaluated against ground truth entity annotations to measure its accuracy on the task.
The results showed that certain prompt engineering strategies, such as providing clear instructions and examples, significantly improved ChatGPT's unsupervised entity resolution performance compared to more open-ended or ambiguous prompts. The paper also discusses how prompt design can be leveraged to tailor large language models like ChatGPT for specific applications and use cases.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a well-designed and insightful experimental study on the effects of prompt engineering on ChatGPT's unsupervised entity resolution capabilities. However, the findings may be limited to the specific dataset and entity types used in the experiments. Additional research would be needed to see if the prompt engineering strategies generalize to other domains and tasks.
The paper also does not address potential biases or inconsistencies in ChatGPT's entity resolution outputs, which could be an important consideration for real-world applications. Further investigation into the reliability and robustness of the model's performance would help provide a more comprehensive understanding of its capabilities and limitations.
Additionally, the study focuses solely on ChatGPT and does not compare its prompt-engineered performance to other language models or entity resolution approaches. Expanding the scope to benchmark against a wider range of systems could yield more generalizable insights.
Conclusion
This paper makes a valuable contribution by demonstrating how careful prompt engineering can enhance the unsupervised entity resolution capabilities of large language models like ChatGPT. The findings highlight the importance of prompt design in unlocking the potential of these powerful AI systems for specific applications.
The insights from this research can inform the development of more effective prompting strategies, which will be crucial as language models continue to be applied to an increasingly diverse array of real-world tasks. Continued exploration of prompt engineering and its impact on model performance will be an important area of investigation for the AI research community going forward.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Cost-Efficient Prompt Engineering for Unsupervised Entity Resolution
Navapat Nananukul, Khanin Sisaengsuwanchai, Mayank Kejriwal
Entity Resolution (ER) is the problem of semi-automatically determining when two entities refer to the same underlying entity, with applications ranging from healthcare to e-commerce. Traditional ER solutions required considerable manual expertise, including domain-specific feature engineering, as well as identification and curation of training data. Recently released large language models (LLMs) provide an opportunity to make ER more seamless and domain-independent. However, it is also well known that LLMs can pose risks, and that the quality of their outputs can depend on how prompts are engineered. Unfortunately, a systematic experimental study on the effects of different prompting methods for addressing unsupervised ER, using LLMs like ChatGPT, has been lacking thus far. This paper aims to address this gap by conducting such a study. We consider some relatively simple and cost-efficient ER prompt engineering methods and apply them to ER on two real-world datasets widely used in the community. We use an extensive set of experimental results to show that an LLM like GPT3.5 is viable for high-performing unsupervised ER, and interestingly, that more complicated and detailed (and hence, expensive) prompting methods do not necessarily outperform simpler approaches. We provide brief discussions on qualitative and error analysis, including a study of the inter-consistency of different prompting methods to determine whether they yield stable outputs. Finally, we consider some limitations of LLMs when applied to ER.
Read more4/9/2024
0
APEER: Automatic Prompt Engineering Enhances Large Language Model Reranking
Can Jin, Hongwu Peng, Shiyu Zhao, Zhenting Wang, Wujiang Xu, Ligong Han, Jiahui Zhao, Kai Zhong, Sanguthevar Rajasekaran, Dimitris N. Metaxas
Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly enhanced Information Retrieval (IR) across various modules, such as reranking. Despite impressive performance, current zero-shot relevance ranking with LLMs heavily relies on human prompt engineering. Existing automatic prompt engineering algorithms primarily focus on language modeling and classification tasks, leaving the domain of IR, particularly reranking, underexplored. Directly applying current prompt engineering algorithms to relevance ranking is challenging due to the integration of query and long passage pairs in the input, where the ranking complexity surpasses classification tasks. To reduce human effort and unlock the potential of prompt optimization in reranking, we introduce a novel automatic prompt engineering algorithm named APEER. APEER iteratively generates refined prompts through feedback and preference optimization. Extensive experiments with four LLMs and ten datasets demonstrate the substantial performance improvement of APEER over existing state-of-the-art (SoTA) manual prompts. Furthermore, we find that the prompts generated by APEER exhibit better transferability across diverse tasks and LLMs. Code is available at https://github.com/jincan333/APEER.
Read more6/21/2024
0
On Leveraging Large Language Models for Enhancing Entity Resolution: A Cost-efficient Approach
Huahang Li, Longyu Feng, Shuangyin Li, Fei Hao, Chen Jason Zhang, Yuanfeng Song
Entity resolution, the task of identifying and merging records that refer to the same real-world entity, is crucial in sectors like e-commerce, healthcare, and law enforcement. Large Language Models (LLMs) introduce an innovative approach to this task, capitalizing on their advanced linguistic capabilities and a ``pay-as-you-go'' model that provides significant advantages to those without extensive data science expertise. However, current LLMs are costly due to per-API request billing. Existing methods often either lack quality or become prohibitively expensive at scale. To address these problems, we propose an uncertainty reduction framework using LLMs to improve entity resolution results. We first initialize possible partitions of the entity cluster, refer to the same entity, and define the uncertainty of the result. Then, we reduce the uncertainty by selecting a few valuable matching questions for LLM verification. Upon receiving the answers, we update the probability distribution of the possible partitions. To further reduce costs, we design an efficient algorithm to judiciously select the most valuable matching pairs to query. Additionally, we create error-tolerant techniques to handle LLM mistakes and a dynamic adjustment method to reach truly correct partitions. Experimental results show that our method is efficient and effective, offering promising applications in real-world tasks.
Read more9/14/2024
💬
0
A Survey of Prompt Engineering Methods in Large Language Models for Different NLP Tasks
Shubham Vatsal, Harsh Dubey
Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable performance on many different Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks. Prompt engineering plays a key role in adding more to the already existing abilities of LLMs to achieve significant performance gains on various NLP tasks. Prompt engineering requires composing natural language instructions called prompts to elicit knowledge from LLMs in a structured way. Unlike previous state-of-the-art (SoTA) models, prompt engineering does not require extensive parameter re-training or fine-tuning based on the given NLP task and thus solely operates on the embedded knowledge of LLMs. Additionally, LLM enthusiasts can intelligently extract LLMs' knowledge through a basic natural language conversational exchange or prompt engineering, allowing more and more people even without deep mathematical machine learning background to experiment with LLMs. With prompt engineering gaining popularity in the last two years, researchers have come up with numerous engineering techniques around designing prompts to improve accuracy of information extraction from the LLMs. In this paper, we summarize different prompting techniques and club them together based on different NLP tasks that they have been used for. We further granularly highlight the performance of these prompting strategies on various datasets belonging to that NLP task, talk about the corresponding LLMs used, present a taxonomy diagram and discuss the possible SoTA for specific datasets. In total, we read and present a survey of 44 research papers which talk about 39 different prompting methods on 29 different NLP tasks of which most of them have been published in the last two years.
Read more7/25/2024