Cross-Silo Federated Learning Across Divergent Domains with Iterative Parameter Alignment
2311.04818
0
0
š¤æ
Abstract
Learning from the collective knowledge of data dispersed across private sources can provide neural networks with enhanced generalization capabilities. Federated learning, a method for collaboratively training a machine learning model across remote clients, achieves this by combining client models via the orchestration of a central server. However, current approaches face two critical limitations: i) they struggle to converge when client domains are sufficiently different, and ii) current aggregation techniques produce an identical global model for each client. In this work, we address these issues by reformulating the typical federated learning setup: rather than learning a single global model, we learn N models each optimized for a common objective. To achieve this, we apply a weighted distance minimization to model parameters shared in a peer-to-peer topology. The resulting framework, Iterative Parameter Alignment, applies naturally to the cross-silo setting, and has the following properties: (i) a unique solution for each participant, with the option to globally converge each model in the federation, and (ii) an optional early-stopping mechanism to elicit fairness among peers in collaborative learning settings. These characteristics jointly provide a flexible new framework for iteratively learning from peer models trained on disparate datasets. We find that the technique achieves competitive results on a variety of data partitions compared to state-of-the-art approaches. Further, we show that the method is robust to divergent domains (i.e. disjoint classes across peers) where existing approaches struggle.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper proposes a new framework called Iterative Parameter Alignment (IPA) for federated learning, which aims to address two key limitations of current approaches.
- Federated learning is a method for training machine learning models across multiple remote devices, without centralizing the training data.
- Current federated learning approaches struggle to converge when the data domains of the participating clients are sufficiently different, and produce a single global model that may not be optimal for each individual client.
- IPA reformulates the federated learning setup to learn N separate models, each optimized for a common objective, by applying a weighted distance minimization to shared model parameters in a peer-to-peer topology.
Plain English Explanation
The paper addresses a problem in the field of federated learning, which is a way for multiple devices or organizations to collaborate on training a machine learning model without sharing their private data.
One issue with current federated learning approaches is that they struggle to converge on a good model when the data available to the participating devices or organizations is quite different. Another problem is that these approaches produce a single global model, which may not be the best fit for each individual participant.
The researchers propose a new framework called Iterative Parameter Alignment (IPA) that tries to solve these problems. Instead of learning a single global model, IPA learns N separate models, each optimized for a common objective. It does this by having the participants share their model parameters with each other in a peer-to-peer network, and then applying a technique called "weighted distance minimization" to align the parameters.
This approach has a few key benefits: 1) each participant gets a unique model that is optimized for their own data, and 2) there is an optional mechanism to ensure the models converge to a shared state if desired. The researchers show that IPA performs well on a variety of data partitions compared to other federated learning methods, and is particularly robust when the data domains of the participants are quite different (e.g. they have completely non-overlapping classes).
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a new federated learning framework called Iterative Parameter Alignment (IPA) that aims to address two key limitations of current approaches: 1) the inability to converge when client domains are sufficiently different, and 2) the production of a single global model that may not be optimal for each individual client.
Instead of learning a single global model, IPA learns N separate models, each optimized for a common objective. This is achieved by applying a weighted distance minimization to model parameters that are shared in a peer-to-peer topology. The resulting framework has two key properties:
- A unique solution for each participant, with the option to globally converge each model in the federation
- An optional early-stopping mechanism to elicit fairness among peers in collaborative learning settings
The researchers evaluate IPA on a variety of data partitions and find that it achieves competitive results compared to state-of-the-art federated learning approaches. Importantly, they show that IPA is robust to divergent domains (i.e. non-overlapping classes across clients) where existing methods struggle.
The technical details of the IPA framework involve formulating the federated learning problem as a weighted distance minimization across a peer-to-peer network of clients. This allows each client to maintain their own unique model while still benefiting from collaboration. The early-stopping mechanism helps ensure fair convergence across the federated models.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising new approach to federated learning that addresses some key limitations of existing methods. The ability to learn N unique models optimized for each client's data, rather than a single global model, is a valuable innovation that could significantly improve performance in real-world federated learning scenarios.
However, the paper does not extensively explore the potential downsides or limitations of the IPA framework. For example, the computational and communication overhead of maintaining N separate models may be non-trivial, especially as the number of clients scales. There could also be challenges around model versioning and updates in a dynamic federated learning environment.
Additionally, the evaluation in the paper is relatively limited, focusing mainly on classification tasks with non-overlapping classes across clients. It would be helpful to see how IPA performs on a wider range of federated learning problems, including regression, multi-task, and multi-modal tasks, as described in related work.
Overall, the IPA framework represents a valuable contribution to the federated learning literature, but further research is needed to fully understand its strengths, weaknesses, and practical applicability across diverse federated learning scenarios.
Conclusion
The paper introduces a new federated learning framework called Iterative Parameter Alignment (IPA) that addresses two key limitations of current approaches: the inability to converge when client data domains are significantly different, and the production of a single global model that may not be optimal for each individual client.
IPA reformulates the federated learning setup to learn N separate models, each optimized for a common objective, by applying a weighted distance minimization to shared model parameters in a peer-to-peer topology. This results in a flexible framework with unique models for each participant and an optional mechanism to globally converge the models if desired.
Experimental results show that IPA achieves competitive performance compared to state-of-the-art federated learning methods, and is particularly robust to divergent data domains where existing approaches struggle. While the paper does not extensively explore potential limitations, the IPA framework represents an important step forward in enabling effective federated learning across a wide range of real-world scenarios.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Federated Unsupervised Domain Generalization using Global and Local Alignment of Gradients
Farhad Pourpanah, Mahdiyar Molahasani, Milad Soltany, Michael Greenspan, Ali Etemad
0
0
We address the problem of federated domain generalization in an unsupervised setting for the first time. We first theoretically establish a connection between domain shift and alignment of gradients in unsupervised federated learning and show that aligning the gradients at both client and server levels can facilitate the generalization of the model to new (target) domains. Building on this insight, we propose a novel method named FedGaLA, which performs gradient alignment at the client level to encourage clients to learn domain-invariant features, as well as global gradient alignment at the server to obtain a more generalized aggregated model. To empirically evaluate our method, we perform various experiments on four commonly used multi-domain datasets, PACS, OfficeHome, DomainNet, and TerraInc. The results demonstrate the effectiveness of our method which outperforms comparable baselines. Ablation and sensitivity studies demonstrate the impact of different components and parameters in our approach. The source code will be available online upon publication.
5/28/2024
š®
Locally Adaptive Federated Learning
Sohom Mukherjee, Nicolas Loizou, Sebastian U. Stich
0
0
Federated learning is a paradigm of distributed machine learning in which multiple clients coordinate with a central server to learn a model, without sharing their own training data. Standard federated optimization methods such as Federated Averaging (FedAvg) ensure balance among the clients by using the same stepsize for local updates on all clients. However, this means that all clients need to respect the global geometry of the function which could yield slow convergence. In this work, we propose locally adaptive federated learning algorithms, that leverage the local geometric information for each client function. We show that such locally adaptive methods with uncoordinated stepsizes across all clients can be particularly efficient in interpolated (overparameterized) settings, and analyze their convergence in the presence of heterogeneous data for convex and strongly convex settings. We validate our theoretical claims by performing illustrative experiments for both i.i.d. non-i.i.d. cases. Our proposed algorithms match the optimization performance of tuned FedAvg in the convex setting, outperform FedAvg as well as state-of-the-art adaptive federated algorithms like FedAMS for non-convex experiments, and come with superior generalization performance.
5/15/2024
š
Cross-Silo Federated Learning for Multi-Tier Networks with Vertical and Horizontal Data Partitioning
Anirban Das, Timothy Castiglia, Shiqiang Wang, Stacy Patterson
0
0
We consider federated learning in tiered communication networks. Our network model consists of a set of silos, each holding a vertical partition of the data. Each silo contains a hub and a set of clients, with the silo's vertical data shard partitioned horizontally across its clients. We propose Tiered Decentralized Coordinate Descent (TDCD), a communication-efficient decentralized training algorithm for such two-tiered networks. The clients in each silo perform multiple local gradient steps before sharing updates with their hub to reduce communication overhead. Each hub adjusts its coordinates by averaging its workers' updates, and then hubs exchange intermediate updates with one another. We present a theoretical analysis of our algorithm and show the dependence of the convergence rate on the number of vertical partitions and the number of local updates. We further validate our approach empirically via simulation-based experiments using a variety of datasets and objectives.
4/26/2024
Fair Federated Learning under Domain Skew with Local Consistency and Domain Diversity
Yuhang Chen, Wenke Huang, Mang Ye
0
0
Federated learning (FL) has emerged as a new paradigm for privacy-preserving collaborative training. Under domain skew, the current FL approaches are biased and face two fairness problems. 1) Parameter Update Conflict: data disparity among clients leads to varying parameter importance and inconsistent update directions. These two disparities cause important parameters to potentially be overwhelmed by unimportant ones of dominant updates. It consequently results in significant performance decreases for lower-performing clients. 2) Model Aggregation Bias: existing FL approaches introduce unfair weight allocation and neglect domain diversity. It leads to biased model convergence objective and distinct performance among domains. We discover a pronounced directional update consistency in Federated Learning and propose a novel framework to tackle above issues. First, leveraging the discovered characteristic, we selectively discard unimportant parameter updates to prevent updates from clients with lower performance overwhelmed by unimportant parameters, resulting in fairer generalization performance. Second, we propose a fair aggregation objective to prevent global model bias towards some domains, ensuring that the global model continuously aligns with an unbiased model. The proposed method is generic and can be combined with other existing FL methods to enhance fairness. Comprehensive experiments on Digits and Office-Caltech demonstrate the high fairness and performance of our method.
5/28/2024