Cyber Deception: State of the art, Trends and Open challenges

Read original: arXiv:2409.07194 - Published 9/12/2024 by Pedro Beltr'an L'opez, Manuel Gil P'erez, Pantaleone Nespoli
Total Score

0

Cyber Deception: State of the art, Trends and Open challenges

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper provides a comprehensive review of the state-of-the-art in cyber deception, including the latest trends and open challenges in the field.
  • Cyber deception involves using techniques like honeypots, moving target defense, and artificial intelligence to deceive and misdirect cyber attackers.
  • The paper covers the motivation behind cyber deception, the key concepts and techniques, real-world applications, and areas for future research.

Plain English Explanation

Cyber attacks are a major threat, with hackers constantly trying to infiltrate computer systems for malicious purposes. To defend against these attacks, researchers have developed a field called cyber deception. The core idea is to use trickery and misdirection to confuse and mislead the attackers, making it harder for them to successfully breach a system.

Some common cyber deception techniques include honeypots, which are fake computer systems designed to lure in and trap attackers. Another approach is moving target defense, where the system's attack surface is constantly changing to thwart intrusions. Artificial intelligence can also be used to automate and enhance cyber deception strategies.

By using these deceptive tactics, defenders can gain valuable information about the attackers' methods, slow down the attack, and ultimately improve the overall security of their systems. This is an active area of research with many exciting developments and open challenges to explore.

Technical Explanation

The paper begins by highlighting the growing threat of cyber attacks and the limitations of traditional security measures. It then introduces cyber deception as a promising reactive defense approach that can complement preventative security controls.

The authors provide an overview of the key cyber deception techniques, including honeypots, deceptive credentials, and moving target defense. They also discuss how artificial intelligence can be leveraged to automate and enhance these deceptive tactics.

The paper then explores real-world applications of cyber deception, such as deceiving attackers at the application layer, using deception to protect industrial control systems, and deploying symbiotic game-based models for cyber deception operations.

Throughout the paper, the authors highlight the key trends and open challenges in the field of cyber deception, such as the need for better evaluation frameworks, the challenge of scaling deception techniques, and the ethical considerations around the use of deception.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a comprehensive and well-structured overview of the state-of-the-art in cyber deception, covering a wide range of techniques and applications. The authors have done a commendable job of synthesizing the current research and highlighting the key trends and open challenges in the field.

One potential limitation of the paper is that it does not delve deeply into the specific technical details of the various cyber deception approaches. While this is understandable given the broad scope of the review, some readers may have wished for a more in-depth technical analysis of the underlying mechanisms and architectures.

Additionally, the paper could have benefited from a more critical examination of the potential drawbacks and ethical considerations surrounding the use of cyber deception. While the authors do acknowledge these issues, a more thorough discussion of the potential risks and mitigation strategies could have further strengthened the analysis.

Overall, this paper serves as an excellent starting point for researchers and practitioners interested in understanding the current state of cyber deception and the directions for future work in this rapidly evolving field.

Conclusion

This comprehensive review paper provides a detailed overview of the state-of-the-art in cyber deception, covering the key concepts, techniques, real-world applications, and emerging trends in the field. By leveraging deceptive tactics like honeypots, moving target defense, and AI-powered automation, cyber defenders can gain valuable insights into the attackers' methods and improve the overall security of their systems.

While cyber deception is a promising approach, the paper also highlights several open challenges, such as the need for better evaluation frameworks, the scalability of deception techniques, and the ethical considerations around the use of deception. Addressing these challenges will be crucial for the continued advancement and widespread adoption of cyber deception strategies.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Cyber Deception: State of the art, Trends and Open challenges
Total Score

0

Cyber Deception: State of the art, Trends and Open challenges

Pedro Beltr'an L'opez, Manuel Gil P'erez, Pantaleone Nespoli

The growing interest in cybersecurity has significantly increased articles designing and implementing various Cyber Deception (CYDEC) mechanisms. This trend reflects the urgent need for new strategies to address cyber threats effectively. Since its emergence, CYDEC has established itself as an innovative defense against attackers, thanks to its proactive and reactive capabilities, finding applications in numerous real-life scenarios. Despite the considerable work devoted to CYDEC, the literature still presents significant gaps. In particular, there has not been (i) a comprehensive analysis of the main components characterizing CYDEC, (ii) a generic classification covering all types of solutions, nor (iii) a survey of the current state of the literature in various contexts. This article aims to fill these gaps through a detailed review of the main features that comprise CYDEC, developing a comprehensive classification taxonomy. In addition, the different frameworks used to generate CYDEC are reviewed, presenting a more comprehensive one. Existing solutions in the literature using CYDEC, both without Artificial Intelligence (AI) and with AI, are studied and compared. Finally, the most salient trends of the current state of the art are discussed, offering a list of pending challenges for future research.

Read more

9/12/2024

🖼️

Total Score

0

Application Layer Cyber Deception without Developer Interaction

Mario Kahlhofer, Stefan Rass

Cyber deception techniques that are tightly intertwined with applications pose significant technical challenges in production systems. Security measures are usually the responsibility of a system operator, but they are typically limited to accessing built software artifacts, not their source code. This limitation makes it particularly challenging to deploy cyber deception techniques at application runtime and without full control over the software development lifecycle. This work reviews 19 technical methods to accomplish this and evaluates them based on technical, topological, operational, and efficacy properties. We find some novel techniques beyond honeypots and reverse proxies that seem to have received little research interest despite their promise for cyber deception. We believe that overcoming these technical challenges can drive the adoption of more dynamic and personalized cyber deception techniques, tailored to specific classes of applications.

Read more

5/22/2024

Deception Analysis with Artificial Intelligence: An Interdisciplinary Perspective
Total Score

0

Deception Analysis with Artificial Intelligence: An Interdisciplinary Perspective

Stefan Sarkadi

Humans and machines interact more frequently than ever and our societies are becoming increasingly hybrid. A consequence of this hybridisation is the degradation of societal trust due to the prevalence of AI-enabled deception. Yet, despite our understanding of the role of trust in AI in the recent years, we still do not have a computational theory to be able to fully understand and explain the role deception plays in this context. This is a problem because while our ability to explain deception in hybrid societies is delayed, the design of AI agents may keep advancing towards fully autonomous deceptive machines, which would pose new challenges to dealing with deception. In this paper we build a timely and meaningful interdisciplinary perspective on deceptive AI and reinforce a 20 year old socio-cognitive perspective on trust and deception, by proposing the development of DAMAS -- a holistic Multi-Agent Systems (MAS) framework for the socio-cognitive modelling and analysis of deception. In a nutshell this paper covers the topic of modelling and explaining deception using AI approaches from the perspectives of Computer Science, Philosophy, Psychology, Ethics, and Intelligence Analysis.

Read more

6/12/2024

Tackling Cyberattacks through AI-based Reactive Systems: A Holistic Review and Future Vision
Total Score

0

Tackling Cyberattacks through AI-based Reactive Systems: A Holistic Review and Future Vision

Sergio Bernardez Molina, Pantaleone Nespoli, F'elix G'omez M'armol

There is no denying that the use of Information Technology (IT) is undergoing exponential growth in today's world. This digital transformation has also given rise to a multitude of security challenges, notably in the realm of cybercrime. In response to these growing threats, public and private sectors have prioritized the strengthening of IT security measures. In light of the growing security concern, Artificial Intelligence (AI) has gained prominence within the cybersecurity landscape. This paper presents a comprehensive survey of recent advancements in AI-driven threat response systems. To the best of our knowledge, the most recent survey covering the AI reaction domain was conducted in 2017. Since then, considerable literature has been published, and therefore, it is worth reviewing it. In this comprehensive survey of the state of the art reaction systems, five key features with multiple values have been identified, facilitating a homogeneous comparison between the different works. In addition, through a meticulous methodology of article collection, the 22 most relevant publications in the field have been selected. Then each of these publications has been subjected to a detailed analysis using the features identified, which has allowed for the generation of a comprehensive overview revealing significant relationships between the papers. These relationships are further elaborated in the paper, along with the identification of potential gaps in the literature, which may guide future contributions. A total of seven research challenges have been identified, pointing out these potential gaps and suggesting possible areas of development through concrete proposals.

Read more

5/30/2024