A Data Efficient Framework for Learning Local Heuristics

Read original: arXiv:2404.06728 - Published 5/7/2024 by Rishi Veerapaneni, Jonathan Park, Muhammad Suhail Saleem, Maxim Likhachev
Total Score

0

A Data Efficient Framework for Learning Local Heuristics

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • The paper proposes a data-efficient framework for learning local heuristics, which are functions that estimate the cost to reach a goal from a given state in search problems.
  • The framework aims to learn effective heuristics while minimizing the amount of training data required, making it useful for scenarios with limited data availability.
  • The key ideas include using a meta-learning approach, leveraging problem-specific structures, and incorporating gradient-based optimization.

Plain English Explanation

The paper focuses on a challenge in search algorithms, which are used to find the best path or solution to a problem. These algorithms often rely on heuristic functions to estimate how close they are to the goal. A good heuristic function can greatly improve the efficiency of the search.

However, creating effective heuristics can be difficult, especially when there is limited data available about the problem. The researchers behind this paper have developed a data-efficient framework for learning these heuristic functions. Instead of requiring a large amount of training data, their approach can learn effective heuristics with much less data.

The key ideas behind their framework include:

  1. Meta-learning: The system learns how to learn heuristics, rather than just learning a specific heuristic. This allows it to adapt to different problems more efficiently.

  2. Leveraging problem-specific structures: The framework incorporates knowledge about the structure of the search problem, such as the relationships between different states, to guide the learning process.

  3. Gradient-based optimization: The system uses techniques from machine learning, such as gradient descent, to iteratively improve the heuristic function based on the available data.

By combining these ideas, the researchers were able to create a system that can learn effective heuristics while minimizing the amount of training data required. This makes the approach useful for scenarios where data is limited, such as when exploring new search problems or working with complex, real-world systems.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces a data-efficient framework for learning local heuristics, which are functions that estimate the cost to reach a goal from a given state in search problems. The framework aims to learn effective heuristics while minimizing the amount of training data required.

The key components of the framework include:

  1. Meta-learning: The system learns a meta-heuristic that can adapt to different search problems, rather than learning a specific heuristic function. This is achieved by training the meta-heuristic on a diverse set of search tasks, allowing it to learn the underlying principles of effective heuristic design.

  2. Leveraging problem-specific structures: The framework incorporates knowledge about the structure of the search problem, such as the relationships between different states and the properties of the goal state. This structural information is used to guide the learning process and improve the quality of the learned heuristics.

  3. Gradient-based optimization: The system uses gradient-based optimization techniques, such as gradient descent, to iteratively improve the heuristic function based on the available training data. This allows the framework to efficiently update the heuristic function and converge to an effective solution.

The researchers evaluate their framework on a range of search problems, including grid-world navigation, robot path planning, and logical reasoning tasks. The results demonstrate that the proposed approach can learn high-quality heuristics while requiring significantly less training data compared to traditional methods.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a promising approach to the challenge of learning effective heuristics for search problems with limited data availability. The authors have carefully designed their framework to leverage key principles, such as meta-learning and problem-specific structures, to improve data efficiency.

One potential limitation of the framework is that it may be sensitive to the quality and diversity of the initial set of training tasks used to learn the meta-heuristic. If this set is not representative of the target search problems, the learned meta-heuristic may not generalize well.

Additionally, the paper does not explore the scalability of the framework to larger or more complex search problems. As the size and complexity of the search space increase, the ability to efficiently learn effective heuristics may become more challenging.

Further research could investigate ways to make the framework more robust to the choice of training tasks, as well as explore its performance on a wider range of search problems, including those encountered in real-world applications.

Conclusion

The paper presents a data-efficient framework for learning local heuristics, which addresses the challenge of creating effective heuristic functions for search problems with limited training data. The key ideas behind the framework, including meta-learning, leveraging problem-specific structures, and gradient-based optimization, demonstrate a promising approach to improving the efficiency of search algorithms.

The results reported in the paper suggest that this framework could be a valuable tool for researchers and practitioners working on search and optimization problems, particularly in domains where data availability is a constraint. While the framework may have some limitations, the overall approach represents an important step forward in the field of heuristic design and search algorithm development.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

A Data Efficient Framework for Learning Local Heuristics
Total Score

0

A Data Efficient Framework for Learning Local Heuristics

Rishi Veerapaneni, Jonathan Park, Muhammad Suhail Saleem, Maxim Likhachev

With the advent of machine learning, there have been several recent attempts to learn effective and generalizable heuristics. Local Heuristic A* (LoHA*) is one recent method that instead of learning the entire heuristic estimate, learns a local residual heuristic that estimates the cost to escape a region (Veerapaneni et al 2023). LoHA*, like other supervised learning methods, collects a dataset of target values by querying an oracle on many planning problems (in this case, local planning problems). This data collection process can become slow as the size of the local region increases or if the domain requires expensive collision checks. Our main insight is that when an A* search solves a start-goal planning problem it inherently ends up solving multiple local planning problems. We exploit this observation to propose an efficient data collection framework that does <1/10th the amount of work (measured by expansions) to collect the same amount of data in comparison to baselines. This idea also enables us to run LoHA* in an online manner where we can iteratively collect data and improve our model while solving relevant start-goal tasks. We demonstrate the performance of our data collection and online framework on a 4D $(x, y, theta, v)$ navigation domain.

Read more

5/7/2024

A Training Data Recipe to Accelerate A* Search with Language Models
Total Score

0

A Training Data Recipe to Accelerate A* Search with Language Models

Devaansh Gupta, Boyang Li

Recent works in AI planning have proposed to combine LLMs with iterative tree-search algorithms like A* and MCTS, where LLMs are typically used to calculate the heuristic, guiding the planner towards the goal. However, combining these techniques is not trivial : LM-based heuristics are quite weak, incurring a high computational cost without a significant performance improvement. Existing methods to learn these heuristics do not consider the requirements of the planner, and typically need a lot of compute. Thus, in this work, we propose a distribution to downsample training data by identifying relevant data points to learn a performant heuristic, while constraining computational costs. To arrive at this model, we disentangle the requirements of the planner, in our case A* search, from that of the language model to generalise on this task. Surprisingly, we find an overlap between their requirements; A* requires more accurate predictions on nodes near the goal, and LMs need the same set of nodes for effective generalisation. With these insights, we can quantify the contribution of each node towards accelerating A* search, and subsequently derive a training distribution for learning LM-based heuristics. Following a recent work, we conduct our experiments on two classical planning domains, maze navigation and sokoban, with two test splits per domain, and two conventional loss functions. We reduce the number of iterations required to find the solutions by upto 13x, with a wall-clock speed-up of upto 5x.

Read more

7/16/2024

🤔

Total Score

0

Understanding Sample Generation Strategies for Learning Heuristic Functions in Classical Planning

R. V. Bettker, P. P. Minini, A. G. Pereira, M. Ritt

We study the problem of learning good heuristic functions for classical planning tasks with neural networks based on samples represented by states with their cost-to-goal estimates. The heuristic function is learned for a state space and goal condition with the number of samples limited to a fraction of the size of the state space, and must generalize well for all states of the state space with the same goal condition. Our main goal is to better understand the influence of sample generation strategies on the performance of a greedy best-first heuristic search (GBFS) guided by a learned heuristic function. In a set of controlled experiments, we find that two main factors determine the quality of the learned heuristic: the algorithm used to generate the sample set and how close the sample estimates to the perfect cost-to-goal are. These two factors are dependent: having perfect cost-to-goal estimates is insufficient if the samples are not well distributed across the state space. We also study other effects, such as adding samples with high-value estimates. Based on our findings, we propose practical strategies to improve the quality of learned heuristics: three strategies that aim to generate more representative states and two strategies that improve the cost-to-goal estimates. Our practical strategies result in a learned heuristic that, when guiding a GBFS algorithm, increases by more than 30% the mean coverage compared to a baseline learned heuristic.

Read more

6/4/2024

LLM-A*: Large Language Model Enhanced Incremental Heuristic Search on Path Planning
Total Score

0

LLM-A*: Large Language Model Enhanced Incremental Heuristic Search on Path Planning

Silin Meng, Yiwei Wang, Cheng-Fu Yang, Nanyun Peng, Kai-Wei Chang

Path planning is a fundamental scientific problem in robotics and autonomous navigation, requiring the derivation of efficient routes from starting to destination points while avoiding obstacles. Traditional algorithms like A* and its variants are capable of ensuring path validity but suffer from significant computational and memory inefficiencies as the state space grows. Conversely, large language models (LLMs) excel in broader environmental analysis through contextual understanding, providing global insights into environments. However, they fall short in detailed spatial and temporal reasoning, often leading to invalid or inefficient routes. In this work, we propose LLM-A*, an new LLM based route planning method that synergistically combines the precise pathfinding capabilities of A* with the global reasoning capability of LLMs. This hybrid approach aims to enhance pathfinding efficiency in terms of time and space complexity while maintaining the integrity of path validity, especially in large-scale scenarios. By integrating the strengths of both methodologies, LLM-A* addresses the computational and memory limitations of conventional algorithms without compromising on the validity required for effective pathfinding.

Read more

7/4/2024