Demystifying SGD with Doubly Stochastic Gradients

Overview

• Optimization problems with intractable expectations, such as those found in diffusion models, variational autoencoders, and many other machine learning models, are becoming increasingly important.
• A popular strategy for addressing these problems is to use stochastic gradient descent (SGD) with "doubly stochastic gradients" (doubly SGD), which estimates the expectations using gradient estimators and the sum using subsampling.
• Despite the widespread use of doubly SGD, its convergence properties were not well understood, especially under more general conditions such as dependent gradient estimators.

Plain English Explanation

Many machine learning models, like diffusion models and variational autoencoders, have optimization objectives that are difficult to calculate exactly. Instead, these objectives are expressed as a sum of many smaller, hard-to-compute parts.

To train these models, researchers often use a technique called "stochastic gradient descent with doubly stochastic gradients" (or "doubly SGD" for short). Doubly SGD works by first estimating the individual, hard-to-compute parts using a technique called a "gradient estimator." Then, it estimates the overall sum by randomly selecting and averaging a few of these gradient estimators.

Despite the popularity of doubly SGD, scientists didn't fully understand how it behaves, especially when the gradient estimators are dependent on each other (which is often the case in real-world models). This paper aims to provide a better understanding of how doubly SGD converges under more general conditions.

Technical Explanation

The paper establishes the convergence of doubly SGD with independent minibatching and random reshuffling, even when the component gradient estimators are dependent. This extends previous analyses that relied on stronger assumptions, such as bounded variance of the gradient estimators.

The key insights from the analysis are:

1. For a fixed computational budget (i.e., a certain number of gradient evaluations per iteration), the analysis suggests how to best allocate the budget between the minibatch size and the number of Monte Carlo samples used to estimate the gradients. This can lead to more efficient implementations of doubly SGD.

2. The paper proves that random reshuffling (RR) of the data can improve the complexity dependence on the subsampling noise, compared to using independent minibatches. This suggests that RR may be a valuable technique for improving the performance of doubly SGD.

The analysis encompasses a broad class of problems where the optimization objective is expressed as a sum of intractable expectations, including diffusion models, variational autoencoders, and many others.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a rigorous theoretical analysis of doubly SGD under more general conditions than previous work. However, the analysis still relies on some assumptions, such as the gradients having a certain degree of smoothness and the gradient estimators having bounded higher-order moments.

Additionally, the paper does not explore the practical implications of the analysis in depth. While the insights about budget allocation and the benefits of random reshuffling are valuable, the paper does not include detailed experiments or comparisons to other optimization methods for these types of problems.

It would be interesting to see future work that bridges the gap between the theoretical analysis and practical performance, perhaps by applying the insights to specific machine learning models and comparing the empirical results to the theoretical predictions.

Conclusion

This paper advances the understanding of the convergence properties of doubly SGD, a popular optimization technique for machine learning models with intractable expectations in their objective functions. By providing a comprehensive analysis under more general conditions, the paper offers insights that can help researchers and practitioners design more efficient and effective optimization algorithms for these types of problems.

The theoretical guarantees and practical recommendations from this work have the potential to contribute to the continued development and improvement of advanced machine learning models, with applications in areas like generative modeling, unsupervised learning, and beyond.