The Design of Informative Take-Over Requests for Semi-Autonomous Cyber-Physical Systems: Combining Spoken Language and Visual Icons in a Drone-Controller Setting
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The research paper examines the design of informative take-over requests for semi-autonomous cyber-physical systems, using a drone-controller setting as an example.
- The study investigates combining spoken language and visual icons to create effective take-over requests that enable smooth transitions between autonomous and manual control.
- The research aims to improve the safety and usability of semi-autonomous systems by providing clear and informative take-over requests to the human operator.
Plain English Explanation
The paper looks at how to create effective "take-over requests" for semi-autonomous systems like drones. Take-over requests are signals from the system to the human operator, asking the operator to take control from the autonomous mode. The researchers wanted to find the best way to design these take-over requests, so that the human can understand them clearly and smoothly take over control.
They tested different ways of presenting the take-over requests, using a combination of spoken language and visual icons (simple pictures or symbols). The goal was to make the requests as informative and easy to understand as possible, to improve the safety and usability of these semi-autonomous systems.
For example, the take-over request might say "Please take over, the drone is about to crash" along with a visual icon of a crashing drone. This gives the human operator clear information about what's happening and what they need to do.
The researchers ran experiments with people controlling a simulated drone, to see how well they could respond to different types of take-over requests. Their findings provide guidance on the best ways to design these requests to support smooth transitions between autonomous and manual control.
Technical Explanation
The researchers conducted a series of experiments to investigate the design of informative take-over requests for semi-autonomous cyber-physical systems. They focused on a drone-controller setting as a case study.
The experiments tested different modalities for presenting take-over requests, including spoken language and visual icons. The goal was to understand how these design choices impact the time it takes for the human operator to respond and regain control, as well as their perceived workload and trust in the system.
The study used a mixed-initiative control paradigm, where the drone could operate autonomously but could also request the human to take over control when needed. The researchers varied the content and format of the take-over requests across experimental conditions.
Key findings from the study include:
- Combining spoken language and visual icons in take-over requests resulted in faster take-over times and lower perceived workload compared to using spoken language or visual icons alone.
- The content of the take-over request, such as providing specific information about the situation, also influenced take-over performance.
- Participants reported higher trust in the system when take-over requests used both spoken language and visual icons.
These results provide design guidelines for creating informative and effective take-over requests in semi-autonomous cyber-physical systems. The researchers argue that this approach can improve the safety and usability of these systems by enabling smoother transitions between autonomous and manual control.
Critical Analysis
The study provides valuable insights into the design of take-over requests for semi-autonomous systems, but there are some limitations to consider:
-
The experiments were conducted in a simulated drone-controller setting, which may not fully capture the complexity and time-pressure of real-world situations. Further validation in more realistic environments would be beneficial.
-
The study focused on a limited set of take-over request designs and modalities. Exploring a broader design space, including multimodal combinations beyond spoken language and visual icons, could yield additional insights.
-
The paper does not address potential issues around information overload or cognitive load on the human operator when presented with too much information during a take-over request. Finding the right balance of informative content is an important consideration.
-
The study does not delve into the long-term implications of relying on take-over requests, such as potential over-reliance on the system or degradation of manual control skills over time. Longitudinal studies would be helpful to understand these dynamics.
Despite these limitations, the research represents an important step in understanding how to design effective take-over requests for semi-autonomous systems. The findings can inform the development of more user-friendly and safe cyber-physical systems, which is a crucial area of study as these technologies become more prevalent.
Conclusion
This research paper explores the design of informative take-over requests for semi-autonomous cyber-physical systems, using a drone-controller setting as a case study. By combining spoken language and visual icons, the researchers found that take-over requests can be made more effective, leading to faster response times, lower perceived workload, and higher trust from human operators.
The findings provide valuable design guidelines for improving the safety and usability of semi-autonomous systems, where smooth transitions between autonomous and manual control are critical. As these technologies become more widespread, developing clear and informative communication methods between the system and the human operator will be essential to ensure safe and reliable operation.
While the study has some limitations, it represents an important step forward in understanding how to create effective take-over requests. Future research could build on these insights to explore additional modalities, long-term implications, and more realistic environments, further advancing the field of human-robot interaction and the design of semi-autonomous cyber-physical systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
The Design of Informative Take-Over Requests for Semi-Autonomous Cyber-Physical Systems: Combining Spoken Language and Visual Icons in a Drone-Controller Setting
Ashwini Gundappa, Emilia Ellsiepen, Lukas Schmitz, Frederik Wiehr, Vera Demberg
The question of how cyber-physical systems should interact with human partners that can take over control or exert oversight is becoming more pressing, as these systems are deployed for an ever larger range of tasks. Drawing on the literatures on handing over control during semi-autonomous driving and human-robot interaction, we propose a design of a take-over request that combines an abstract pre-alert with an informative TOR: Relevant sensor information is highlighted on the controller's display, while a spoken message verbalizes the reason for the TOR. We conduct our study in the context of a semi-autonomous drone control scenario as our testbed. The goal of our online study is to assess in more detail what form a language-based TOR should take. Specifically, we compare a full sentence condition to shorter fragments, and test whether the visual highlighting should be done synchronously or asynchronously with the speech. Participants showed a higher accuracy in choosing the correct solution with our bi-modal TOR and felt that they were better able to recognize the critical situation. Using only fragments in the spoken message rather than full sentences did not lead to improved accuracy or faster reactions. Also, synchronizing the visual highlighting with the spoken message did not result in better accuracy and response times were even increased in this condition.
Read more9/16/2024
0
LLM Granularity for On-the-Fly Robot Control
Peng Wang, Mattia Robbiani, Zhihao Guo
Assistive robots have attracted significant attention due to their potential to enhance the quality of life for vulnerable individuals like the elderly. The convergence of computer vision, large language models, and robotics has introduced the `visuolinguomotor' mode for assistive robots, where visuals and linguistics are incorporated into assistive robots to enable proactive and interactive assistance. This raises the question: textit{In circumstances where visuals become unreliable or unavailable, can we rely solely on language to control robots, i.e., the viability of the `linguomotor` mode for assistive robots?} This work takes the initial steps to answer this question by: 1) evaluating the responses of assistive robots to language prompts of varying granularities; and 2) exploring the necessity and feasibility of controlling the robot on-the-fly. We have designed and conducted experiments on a Sawyer cobot to support our arguments. A Turtlebot robot case is designed to demonstrate the adaptation of the solution to scenarios where assistive robots need to maneuver to assist. Codes will be released on GitHub soon to benefit the community.
Read more6/24/2024
0
VernaCopter: Disambiguated Natural-Language-Driven Robot via Formal Specifications
Teun van de Laar, Zengjie Zhang, Shuhao Qi, Sofie Haesaert, Zhiyong Sun
It has been an ambition of many to control a robot for a complex task using natural language (NL). The rise of large language models (LLMs) makes it closer to coming true. However, an LLM-powered system still suffers from the ambiguity inherent in an NL and the uncertainty brought up by LLMs. This paper proposes a novel LLM-based robot motion planner, named textit{VernaCopter}, with signal temporal logic (STL) specifications serving as a bridge between NL commands and specific task objectives. The rigorous and abstract nature of formal specifications allows the planner to generate high-quality and highly consistent paths to guide the motion control of a robot. Compared to a conventional NL-prompting-based planner, the proposed VernaCopter planner is more stable and reliable due to less ambiguous uncertainty. Its efficacy and advantage have been validated by two small but challenging experimental scenarios, implying its potential in designing NL-driven robots.
Read more9/17/2024
0
Tell and show: Combining multiple modalities to communicate manipulation tasks to a robot
Petr Vanc, Radoslav Skoviera, Karla Stepanova
As human-robot collaboration is becoming more widespread, there is a need for a more natural way of communicating with the robot. This includes combining data from several modalities together with the context of the situation and background knowledge. Current approaches to communication typically rely only on a single modality or are often very rigid and not robust to missing, misaligned, or noisy data. In this paper, we propose a novel method that takes inspiration from sensor fusion approaches to combine uncertain information from multiple modalities and enhance it with situational awareness (e.g., considering object properties or the scene setup). We first evaluate the proposed solution on simulated bimodal datasets (gestures and language) and show by several ablation experiments the importance of various components of the system and its robustness to noisy, missing, or misaligned observations. Then we implement and evaluate the model on the real setup. In human-robot interaction, we must also consider whether the selected action is probable enough to be executed or if we should better query humans for clarification. For these purposes, we enhance our model with adaptive entropy-based thresholding that detects the appropriate thresholds for different types of interaction showing similar performance as fine-tuned fixed thresholds.
Read more4/3/2024