Detecting Adversarial Attacks in Semantic Segmentation via Uncertainty Estimation: A Deep Analysis
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores techniques for detecting adversarial attacks in semantic segmentation models, which are used in autonomous driving and other applications.
- The researchers investigate the use of uncertainty estimation to identify adversarial examples that can fool these models.
- They conduct a deep analysis to understand the strengths and limitations of this approach.
Plain English Explanation
Semantic segmentation is a computer vision technique that allows machines to understand the contents of an image by labeling each pixel with the object or scene it represents. This is crucial for applications like autonomous driving, where the car needs to identify things like roads, pedestrians, and other vehicles.
However, these semantic segmentation models can be vulnerable to adversarial attacks - small, imperceptible changes to the input image that cause the model to make mistakes. This paper explores using uncertainty estimation to detect when an image has been tampered with in this way.
The researchers analyze the performance of this approach in depth, looking at factors like the type of attack, the strength of the attack, and the model architecture. They find that uncertainty estimation can be an effective way to catch adversarial examples, but there are also limitations and tradeoffs to consider.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by reviewing related work on adversarial attacks and defenses for semantic segmentation. It then describes the researchers' approach, which involves training a semantic segmentation model to output not just class predictions, but also an estimate of the uncertainty in those predictions.
To evaluate this approach, the researchers conduct experiments on popular semantic segmentation datasets and models. They generate adversarial examples using a range of attack techniques, and then use the uncertainty estimates to try to detect which images have been tampered with.
The results show that uncertainty estimation can be an effective defense, with the ability to catch many adversarial examples without significantly impacting the model's normal performance. However, the researchers also find that the approach has limitations - for example, it may struggle with more powerful attacks or fail to detect adversarial examples that are close to the decision boundary.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough and thoughtful analysis of using uncertainty estimation to defend against adversarial attacks in semantic segmentation. The researchers carefully consider the strengths and weaknesses of their approach, and identify several important areas for future work.
One potential limitation is that the analysis is primarily focused on white-box attacks, where the attacker has full knowledge of the model. It would be valuable to also explore the performance against black-box attacks, where the attacker has less information about the model.
Additionally, the paper does not directly compare the uncertainty-based defense to other potential approaches, such as adversarial training or input preprocessing. Understanding how this method stacks up against alternatives would help provide a more complete picture.
Overall, this paper makes a valuable contribution by rigorously examining the use of uncertainty estimation for adversarial attack detection in semantic segmentation. The insights and limitations it uncovers can help guide future research in this important area.
Conclusion
This paper presents a deep analysis of using uncertainty estimation to detect adversarial attacks in semantic segmentation models. The researchers find that this approach can be an effective defense, but also identify key limitations and areas for further exploration.
The findings have important implications for the development of robust and trustworthy computer vision systems, particularly in safety-critical applications like autonomous driving. As AI models become more widely deployed, techniques like this will be crucial for ensuring their reliability and security in the face of adversarial threats.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Detecting Adversarial Attacks in Semantic Segmentation via Uncertainty Estimation: A Deep Analysis
Kira Maag, Roman Resner, Asja Fischer
Deep neural networks have demonstrated remarkable effectiveness across a wide range of tasks such as semantic segmentation. Nevertheless, these networks are vulnerable to adversarial attacks that add imperceptible perturbations to the input image, leading to false predictions. This vulnerability is particularly dangerous in safety-critical applications like automated driving. While adversarial examples and defense strategies are well-researched in the context of image classification, there is comparatively less research focused on semantic segmentation. Recently, we have proposed an uncertainty-based method for detecting adversarial attacks on neural networks for semantic segmentation. We observed that uncertainty, as measured by the entropy of the output distribution, behaves differently on clean versus adversely perturbed images, and we utilize this property to differentiate between the two. In this extended version of our work, we conduct a detailed analysis of uncertainty-based detection of adversarial attacks including a diverse set of adversarial attacks and various state-of-the-art neural networks. Our numerical experiments show the effectiveness of the proposed uncertainty-based detection method, which is lightweight and operates as a post-processing step, i.e., no model modifications or knowledge of the adversarial example generation process are required.
Read more8/20/2024
0
Evaluating the Adversarial Robustness of Semantic Segmentation: Trying Harder Pays Off
Levente Halmosi, B'alint Mohos, M'ark Jelasity
Machine learning models are vulnerable to tiny adversarial input perturbations optimized to cause a very large output error. To measure this vulnerability, we need reliable methods that can find such adversarial perturbations. For image classification models, evaluation methodologies have emerged that have stood the test of time. However, we argue that in the area of semantic segmentation, a good approximation of the sensitivity to adversarial perturbations requires significantly more effort than what is currently considered satisfactory. To support this claim, we re-evaluate a number of well-known robust segmentation models in an extensive empirical study. We propose new attacks and combine them with the strongest attacks available in the literature. We also analyze the sensitivity of the models in fine detail. The results indicate that most of the state-of-the-art models have a dramatically larger sensitivity to adversarial perturbations than previously reported. We also demonstrate a size-bias: small objects are often more easily attacked, even if the large objects are robust, a phenomenon not revealed by current evaluation metrics. Our results also demonstrate that a diverse set of strong attacks is necessary, because different models are often vulnerable to different attacks.
Read more7/15/2024
0
Towards Reliable Evaluation and Fast Training of Robust Semantic Segmentation Models
Francesco Croce, Naman D Singh, Matthias Hein
Adversarial robustness has been studied extensively in image classification, especially for the $ell_infty$-threat model, but significantly less so for related tasks such as object detection and semantic segmentation, where attacks turn out to be a much harder optimization problem than for image classification. We propose several problem-specific novel attacks minimizing different metrics in accuracy and mIoU. The ensemble of our attacks, SEA, shows that existing attacks severely overestimate the robustness of semantic segmentation models. Surprisingly, existing attempts of adversarial training for semantic segmentation models turn out to be weak or even completely non-robust. We investigate why previous adaptations of adversarial training to semantic segmentation failed and show how recently proposed robust ImageNet backbones can be used to obtain adversarially robust semantic segmentation models with up to six times less training time for PASCAL-VOC and the more challenging ADE20k. The associated code and robust models are available at https://github.com/nmndeep/robust-segmentation
Read more7/17/2024
0
Instance-wise Uncertainty for Class Imbalance in Semantic Segmentation
Lu'is Almeida, In^es Dutra, Francesco Renna
Semantic segmentation is a fundamental computer vision task with a vast number of applications. State of the art methods increasingly rely on deep learning models, known to incorrectly estimate uncertainty and being overconfident in predictions, especially in data not seen during training. This is particularly problematic in semantic segmentation due to inherent class imbalance. Popular uncertainty quantification approaches are task-agnostic and fail to leverage spatial pixel correlations in uncertainty estimates, crucial in this task. In this work, a novel training methodology specifically designed for semantic segmentation is presented. Training samples are weighted by instance-wise uncertainty masks computed by an ensemble. This is shown to increase performance on minority classes, boost model generalization and robustness to domain-shift when compared to using the inverse of class proportions or no class weights at all. This method addresses the challenges of class imbalance and uncertainty estimation in semantic segmentation, potentially enhancing model performance and reliability across various applications.
Read more7/18/2024