Diagnosing and Re-learning for Balanced Multimodal Learning

Read original: arXiv:2407.09705 - Published 7/16/2024 by Yake Wei, Siwei Li, Ruoxuan Feng, Di Hu
Total Score

0

Diagnosing and Re-learning for Balanced Multimodal Learning

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • The paper presents a method for diagnosing and re-learning multimodal learning models to achieve more balanced performance across different modalities.
  • The proposed approach involves identifying and addressing imbalances in the learning process to improve the overall performance and robustness of multimodal models.
  • The research aims to address the common challenge of some modalities dominating the learning process and overshadowing others, leading to suboptimal model performance.

Plain English Explanation

Multimodal learning models are designed to process and learn from different types of data, such as images, text, and audio. However, these models can sometimes struggle to balance the learning across the various modalities, with some modalities dominating the learning process and others being neglected.

The researchers in this paper have developed a method to diagnose and address this imbalance. Their approach involves analyzing the learning process of the model to identify which modalities are being prioritized and which are being overlooked. Based on this analysis, the researchers then devise a way to "re-learn" the model, adjusting the training process to ensure that all modalities are given equal attention and importance.

This is important because a balanced multimodal model is more robust and reliable, able to perform well across a variety of tasks and input types. By addressing the imbalance in the learning process, the researchers aim to create models that are more accurate, consistent, and adaptable in real-world applications.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a two-stage approach to address the problem of imbalanced multimodal learning. In the first stage, the researchers introduce a "learning state diagnosing" method to analyze the model's learning process and identify any imbalances between the different modalities.

This diagnosing stage involves tracking the gradients and representations of the model during training, and using this information to determine which modalities are being prioritized and which are being neglected. The researchers then use this analysis to identify the root causes of the imbalance, such as differences in the quality or quantity of training data for each modality.

In the second stage, the researchers develop a "re-learning" approach that adjusts the training process to address the identified imbalances. This involves modifying the loss function, gradient flow, or other aspects of the model to ensure that all modalities are given equal attention and importance during the learning process.

The proposed method is evaluated on several multimodal benchmark datasets, and the results demonstrate that the approach is effective in improving the overall performance and robustness of the models, particularly in cases where there are significant imbalances between the modalities.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge that their approach is not a panacea for all multimodal learning challenges, and that there may be inherent limitations or biases in the training data or model architecture that cannot be fully addressed by their re-learning method.

Additionally, the paper does not provide a comprehensive analysis of the computational and memory requirements of the proposed approach, which could be a practical concern for real-world deployment of these models.

That said, the researchers have made a valuable contribution to the field of multimodal learning by addressing a critical issue that has often been overlooked in previous research. By introducing a systematic way to diagnose and address imbalances in the learning process, the researchers have laid the groundwork for more robust and reliable multimodal models that can be applied across a wide range of domains.

Conclusion

The paper presents a novel approach for diagnosing and re-learning multimodal learning models to achieve more balanced performance across different modalities. By identifying and addressing imbalances in the learning process, the researchers demonstrate a way to improve the overall accuracy, robustness, and adaptability of these models.

The proposed method represents an important step forward in the field of multimodal learning, addressing a key challenge that has often been overlooked in previous research. While there are still areas for further improvement and refinement, the insights and techniques presented in this paper have the potential to significantly advance the development of more effective and reliable multimodal models for a wide range of applications.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Diagnosing and Re-learning for Balanced Multimodal Learning
Total Score

0

Diagnosing and Re-learning for Balanced Multimodal Learning

Yake Wei, Siwei Li, Ruoxuan Feng, Di Hu

To overcome the imbalanced multimodal learning problem, where models prefer the training of specific modalities, existing methods propose to control the training of uni-modal encoders from different perspectives, taking the inter-modal performance discrepancy as the basis. However, the intrinsic limitation of modality capacity is ignored. The scarcely informative modalities can be recognized as ``worse-learnt'' ones, which could force the model to memorize more noise, counterproductively affecting the multimodal model ability. Moreover, the current modality modulation methods narrowly concentrate on selected worse-learnt modalities, even suppressing the training of others. Hence, it is essential to consider the intrinsic limitation of modality capacity and take all modalities into account during balancing. To this end, we propose the Diagnosing & Re-learning method. The learning state of each modality is firstly estimated based on the separability of its uni-modal representation space, and then used to softly re-initialize the corresponding uni-modal encoder. In this way, the over-emphasizing of scarcely informative modalities is avoided. In addition, encoders of worse-learnt modalities are enhanced, simultaneously avoiding the over-training of other modalities. Accordingly, multimodal learning is effectively balanced and enhanced. Experiments covering multiple types of modalities and multimodal frameworks demonstrate the superior performance of our simple-yet-effective method for balanced multimodal learning. The source code and dataset are available at url{https://github.com/GeWu-Lab/Diagnosing_Relearning_ECCV2024}.

Read more

7/16/2024

Modality-Balanced Learning for Multimedia Recommendation
Total Score

0

Modality-Balanced Learning for Multimedia Recommendation

Jinghao Zhang, Guofan Liu, Qiang Liu, Shu Wu, Liang Wang

Many recommender models have been proposed to investigate how to incorporate multimodal content information into traditional collaborative filtering framework effectively. The use of multimodal information is expected to provide more comprehensive information and lead to superior performance. However, the integration of multiple modalities often encounters the modal imbalance problem: since the information in different modalities is unbalanced, optimizing the same objective across all modalities leads to the under-optimization problem of the weak modalities with a slower convergence rate or lower performance. Even worse, we find that in multimodal recommendation models, all modalities suffer from the problem of insufficient optimization. To address these issues, we propose a Counterfactual Knowledge Distillation method that could solve the imbalance problem and make the best use of all modalities. Through modality-specific knowledge distillation, it could guide the multimodal model to learn modality-specific knowledge from uni-modal teachers. We also design a novel generic-and-specific distillation loss to guide the multimodal student to learn wider-and-deeper knowledge from teachers. Additionally, to adaptively recalibrate the focus of the multimodal model towards weaker modalities during training, we estimate the causal effect of each modality on the training objective using counterfactual inference techniques, through which we could determine the weak modalities, quantify the imbalance degree and re-weight the distillation loss accordingly. Our method could serve as a plug-and-play module for both late-fusion and early-fusion backbones. Extensive experiments on six backbones show that our proposed method can improve the performance by a large margin. The source code will be released at url{https://github.com/CRIPAC-DIG/Balanced-Multimodal-Rec}

Read more

8/14/2024

📈

Total Score

0

Improving Multimodal Learning with Multi-Loss Gradient Modulation

Konstantinos Kontras, Christos Chatzichristos, Matthew Blaschko, Maarten De Vos

Learning from multiple modalities, such as audio and video, offers opportunities for leveraging complementary information, enhancing robustness, and improving contextual understanding and performance. However, combining such modalities presents challenges, especially when modalities differ in data structure, predictive contribution, and the complexity of their learning processes. It has been observed that one modality can potentially dominate the learning process, hindering the effective utilization of information from other modalities and leading to sub-optimal model performance. To address this issue the vast majority of previous works suggest to assess the unimodal contributions and dynamically adjust the training to equalize them. We improve upon previous work by introducing a multi-loss objective and further refining the balancing process, allowing it to dynamically adjust the learning pace of each modality in both directions, acceleration and deceleration, with the ability to phase out balancing effects upon convergence. We achieve superior results across three audio-video datasets: on CREMA-D, models with ResNet backbone encoders surpass the previous best by 1.9% to 12.4%, and Conformer backbone models deliver improvements ranging from 2.8% to 14.1% across different fusion methods. On AVE, improvements range from 2.7% to 7.7%, while on UCF101, gains reach up to 6.1%.

Read more

5/14/2024

Detached and Interactive Multimodal Learning
Total Score

0

Detached and Interactive Multimodal Learning

Yunfeng Fan, Wenchao Xu, Haozhao Wang, Junhong Liu, Song Guo

Recently, Multimodal Learning (MML) has gained significant interest as it compensates for single-modality limitations through comprehensive complementary information within multimodal data. However, traditional MML methods generally use the joint learning framework with a uniform learning objective that can lead to the modality competition issue, where feedback predominantly comes from certain modalities, limiting the full potential of others. In response to this challenge, this paper introduces DI-MML, a novel detached MML framework designed to learn complementary information across modalities under the premise of avoiding modality competition. Specifically, DI-MML addresses competition by separately training each modality encoder with isolated learning objectives. It further encourages cross-modal interaction via a shared classifier that defines a common feature space and employing a dimension-decoupled unidirectional contrastive (DUC) loss to facilitate modality-level knowledge transfer. Additionally, to account for varying reliability in sample pairs, we devise a certainty-aware logit weighting strategy to effectively leverage complementary information at the instance level during inference. Extensive experiments conducted on audio-visual, flow-image, and front-rear view datasets show the superior performance of our proposed method. The code is released at https://github.com/fanyunfeng-bit/DI-MML.

Read more

7/30/2024