Modality-Balanced Learning for Multimedia Recommendation

Read original: arXiv:2408.06360 - Published 8/14/2024 by Jinghao Zhang, Guofan Liu, Qiang Liu, Shu Wu, Liang Wang

Modality-Balanced Learning for Multimedia Recommendation

Overview

Introduces a novel technique called "Modality-Balanced Learning" to improve multimedia recommendation systems
Aims to address the problem of modal bias, where certain modalities (e.g. image, text) dominate the learning process and lead to suboptimal performance
Proposes a knowledge distillation approach to transfer knowledge from well-performing modalities to weaker ones, balancing the importance of different modalities

Plain English Explanation

The paper presents a new way to train multimedia recommendation systems that struggle with modal bias. This happens when certain data types, like images or text, are more influential in the model's learning process than others. The researchers introduce "Modality-Balanced Learning" to address this issue.

The key idea is to use knowledge distillation to transfer knowledge from well-performing modalities to weaker ones. This helps balance the importance of different data types, ensuring the model learns from all available information equally.

For example, imagine a movie recommendation system that primarily learns from movie posters (images) rather than plot summaries (text). The Modality-Balanced approach would distill knowledge from the image-based learning to improve the text-based learning, creating a more balanced and robust recommendation model.

Technical Explanation

The paper first defines the problem of modal bias in multimedia recommendation systems, where certain data modalities (e.g., image, text, audio) dominate the learning process and lead to suboptimal performance. To address this, they propose a Modality-Balanced Learning framework that utilizes knowledge distillation to transfer knowledge from well-performing modalities to weaker ones.

The key components of their approach are:

Modality-Specific Encoders: The model learns separate encoders for each data modality, allowing them to capture unique characteristics of different input types.
Knowledge Distillation: The well-performing modality encoders are used as "teachers" to guide the learning of weaker modality encoders through a knowledge distillation process. This helps balance the importance of different modalities.
Modality-Balanced Loss: The training objective incorporates a modality-balanced loss function that encourages the model to learn from all modalities equally, further promoting the balance between them.

The researchers evaluate their approach on several multimedia recommendation datasets and show that it outperforms state-of-the-art methods in terms of recommendation accuracy, while also improving the balance between modalities.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a well-designed and comprehensive solution to the problem of modal bias in multimedia recommendation systems. The key strengths of the approach include:

Modality-Specific Encoders: Treating each modality separately allows the model to learn their unique characteristics, which is an important consideration for multimedia data.
Knowledge Distillation: The use of knowledge distillation is a clever way to transfer knowledge between modalities, helping to address imbalances in the learning process.
Modality-Balanced Loss: This additional loss term directly encourages the model to learn from all modalities equally, further reinforcing the modality balance.

However, the paper does not discuss potential limitations or areas for future research. For example, it would be interesting to explore the performance of the approach on datasets with more diverse or noisy modalities, or to investigate how the technique scales as the number of modalities increases.

Additionally, the researchers could have provided more insights into the relative importance of the different components of their approach (e.g., the individual contributions of knowledge distillation and the modality-balanced loss) to help readers better understand the key drivers of the performance improvements.

Conclusion

The Modality-Balanced Learning approach presented in this paper is a valuable contribution to the field of multimedia recommendation systems. By addressing the problem of modal bias, the researchers have developed a technique that can lead to more accurate and balanced recommendations, drawing equally from the available data modalities.

The paper provides a solid technical foundation and a clear-cut solution to a common issue in multimodal learning. While there are opportunities for further research and refinement, the Modality-Balanced Learning framework represents an important step forward in creating more robust and effective multimedia recommendation systems.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Modality-Balanced Learning for Multimedia Recommendation

Jinghao Zhang, Guofan Liu, Qiang Liu, Shu Wu, Liang Wang

Many recommender models have been proposed to investigate how to incorporate multimodal content information into traditional collaborative filtering framework effectively. The use of multimodal information is expected to provide more comprehensive information and lead to superior performance. However, the integration of multiple modalities often encounters the modal imbalance problem: since the information in different modalities is unbalanced, optimizing the same objective across all modalities leads to the under-optimization problem of the weak modalities with a slower convergence rate or lower performance. Even worse, we find that in multimodal recommendation models, all modalities suffer from the problem of insufficient optimization. To address these issues, we propose a Counterfactual Knowledge Distillation method that could solve the imbalance problem and make the best use of all modalities. Through modality-specific knowledge distillation, it could guide the multimodal model to learn modality-specific knowledge from uni-modal teachers. We also design a novel generic-and-specific distillation loss to guide the multimodal student to learn wider-and-deeper knowledge from teachers. Additionally, to adaptively recalibrate the focus of the multimodal model towards weaker modalities during training, we estimate the causal effect of each modality on the training objective using counterfactual inference techniques, through which we could determine the weak modalities, quantify the imbalance degree and re-weight the distillation loss accordingly. Our method could serve as a plug-and-play module for both late-fusion and early-fusion backbones. Extensive experiments on six backbones show that our proposed method can improve the performance by a large margin. The source code will be released at url{https://github.com/CRIPAC-DIG/Balanced-Multimodal-Rec}

8/14/2024

Diagnosing and Re-learning for Balanced Multimodal Learning

Yake Wei, Siwei Li, Ruoxuan Feng, Di Hu

To overcome the imbalanced multimodal learning problem, where models prefer the training of specific modalities, existing methods propose to control the training of uni-modal encoders from different perspectives, taking the inter-modal performance discrepancy as the basis. However, the intrinsic limitation of modality capacity is ignored. The scarcely informative modalities can be recognized as ``worse-learnt'' ones, which could force the model to memorize more noise, counterproductively affecting the multimodal model ability. Moreover, the current modality modulation methods narrowly concentrate on selected worse-learnt modalities, even suppressing the training of others. Hence, it is essential to consider the intrinsic limitation of modality capacity and take all modalities into account during balancing. To this end, we propose the Diagnosing & Re-learning method. The learning state of each modality is firstly estimated based on the separability of its uni-modal representation space, and then used to softly re-initialize the corresponding uni-modal encoder. In this way, the over-emphasizing of scarcely informative modalities is avoided. In addition, encoders of worse-learnt modalities are enhanced, simultaneously avoiding the over-training of other modalities. Accordingly, multimodal learning is effectively balanced and enhanced. Experiments covering multiple types of modalities and multimodal frameworks demonstrate the superior performance of our simple-yet-effective method for balanced multimodal learning. The source code and dataset are available at url{https://github.com/GeWu-Lab/Diagnosing_Relearning_ECCV2024}.

7/16/2024

Boosting Multimedia Recommendation via Separate Generic and Unique Awareness

Zhuangzhuang He, Zihan Wang, Yonghui Yang, Haoyue Bai, Le Wu

Multimedia recommendation, which incorporates various modalities (e.g., images, texts, etc.) into user or item representation to improve recommendation quality, has received widespread attention. Recent methods mainly focus on cross-modal alignment with self-supervised learning to obtain higher quality representation. Despite remarkable performance, we argue that there is still a limitation: completely aligning representation undermines modality-unique information. We consider that cross-modal alignment is right, but it should not be the entirety, as different modalities contain generic information between them, and each modality also contains unique information. Simply aligning each modality may ignore modality-unique features, thus degrading the performance of multimedia recommendation. To tackle the above limitation, we propose a Separate Alignment aNd Distancing framework (SAND) for multimedia recommendation, which concurrently learns both modal-unique and -generic representation to achieve more comprehensive items representation. First, we split each modal feature into generic and unique part. Then, in the alignment module, for better integration of semantic information between different modalities , we design a SoloSimLoss to align generic modalities. Furthermore, in the distancing module, we aim to distance the unique modalities from the modal-generic so that each modality retains its unique and complementary information. In the light of the flexibility of our framework, we give two technical solutions, the more capable mutual information minimization and the simple negative l2 distance. Finally, extensive experimental results on three popular datasets demonstrate the effectiveness and generalization of our proposed framework.

6/13/2024

Multimodality Invariant Learning for Multimedia-Based New Item Recommendation

Haoyue Bai, Le Wu, Min Hou, Miaomiao Cai, Zhuangzhuang He, Yuyang Zhou, Richang Hong, Meng Wang

Multimedia-based recommendation provides personalized item suggestions by learning the content preferences of users. With the proliferation of digital devices and APPs, a huge number of new items are created rapidly over time. How to quickly provide recommendations for new items at the inference time is challenging. What's worse, real-world items exhibit varying degrees of modality missing(e.g., many short videos are uploaded without text descriptions). Though many efforts have been devoted to multimedia-based recommendations, they either could not deal with new multimedia items or assumed the modality completeness in the modeling process. In this paper, we highlight the necessity of tackling the modality missing issue for new item recommendation. We argue that users' inherent content preference is stable and better kept invariant to arbitrary modality missing environments. Therefore, we approach this problem from a novel perspective of invariant learning. However, how to construct environments from finite user behavior training data to generalize any modality missing is challenging. To tackle this issue, we propose a novel Multimodality Invariant Learning reCommendation(a.k.a. MILK) framework. Specifically, MILK first designs a cross-modality alignment module to keep semantic consistency from pretrained multimedia item features. After that, MILK designs multi-modal heterogeneous environments with cyclic mixup to augment training data, in order to mimic any modality missing for invariant user preference learning. Extensive experiments on three real datasets verify the superiority of our proposed framework. The code is available at https://github.com/HaoyueBai98/MILK.

5/28/2024