Improving Multimodal Learning with Multi-Loss Gradient Modulation
2405.07930
0
0
📈
Abstract
Learning from multiple modalities, such as audio and video, offers opportunities for leveraging complementary information, enhancing robustness, and improving contextual understanding and performance. However, combining such modalities presents challenges, especially when modalities differ in data structure, predictive contribution, and the complexity of their learning processes. It has been observed that one modality can potentially dominate the learning process, hindering the effective utilization of information from other modalities and leading to sub-optimal model performance. To address this issue the vast majority of previous works suggest to assess the unimodal contributions and dynamically adjust the training to equalize them. We improve upon previous work by introducing a multi-loss objective and further refining the balancing process, allowing it to dynamically adjust the learning pace of each modality in both directions, acceleration and deceleration, with the ability to phase out balancing effects upon convergence. We achieve superior results across three audio-video datasets: on CREMA-D, models with ResNet backbone encoders surpass the previous best by 1.9% to 12.4%, and Conformer backbone models deliver improvements ranging from 2.8% to 14.1% across different fusion methods. On AVE, improvements range from 2.7% to 7.7%, while on UCF101, gains reach up to 6.1%.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the challenges of combining multiple modalities, such as audio and video, for enhanced performance in machine learning tasks.
- The authors identify an issue where one modality can dominate the learning process, hindering the effective use of information from other modalities.
- To address this, the authors propose a novel multi-loss objective and a refined balancing process that dynamically adjusts the learning pace of each modality.
- The proposed approach is evaluated on three audio-video datasets, demonstrating significant performance improvements over previous methods.
Plain English Explanation
Machine learning models can often benefit from using multiple types of data, such as audio and video. This allows them to leverage complementary information, become more robust, and better understand the context. However, combining these different modalities can also be challenging, as the data structures, predictive contributions, and learning complexities may vary.
One common problem is that one modality can end up dominating the learning process, essentially crowding out the other modalities and leading to suboptimal model performance. Previous work has tried to address this by assessing the individual contributions of each modality and then adjusting the training to balance them out.
The authors of this paper have built on this idea, introducing a more advanced multi-loss objective and a refined balancing process. Their approach can not only speed up the learning of a weaker modality, but also slow down a dominant one, helping to achieve a better balance. Importantly, the balancing effect can also be gradually reduced as the model converges, allowing each modality to contribute to the final predictions in the most effective way.
When tested on three different audio-video datasets, the authors' models significantly outperformed previous state-of-the-art approaches, with improvements ranging from 1.9% to 14.1%. This suggests their method is quite effective at leveraging the strengths of multiple modalities while overcoming the challenges of modal imbalance.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a novel approach to multimodal fusion, which aims to address the issue of one modality dominating the learning process and hindering the effective utilization of information from other modalities.
The authors introduce a multi-loss objective that combines the individual losses of each modality with a balancing term. This balancing term dynamically adjusts the learning pace of each modality, allowing it to be accelerated or decelerated as needed. Crucially, the balancing effect is also designed to be gradually phased out upon convergence, enabling the model to ultimately leverage the strengths of each modality in the most appropriate way.
The proposed method is evaluated on three audio-video datasets: CREMA-D, AVE, and UCF101. The authors experiment with both ResNet and Conformer backbone encoders, and compare their approach to various fusion methods, including concatenation, attention, and gating.
On the CREMA-D dataset, the authors' models with ResNet backbones surpass the previous best results by 1.9% to 12.4%, while the Conformer-based models deliver improvements ranging from 2.8% to 14.1%. On the AVE dataset, the gains range from 2.7% to 7.7%, and on UCF101, the improvements reach up to 6.1%.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a thoughtful and well-designed solution to the challenge of multimodal imbalance. The authors' multi-loss objective and dynamic balancing approach appear to be effective at ensuring each modality can contribute to the final predictions in an optimal way.
That said, the paper does not delve into the potential limitations or caveats of their approach. For example, it would be interesting to understand how the method might perform on datasets with more than two modalities, or how sensitive it is to the initial imbalance between the modalities.
Additionally, the paper focuses primarily on improving classification accuracy, but does not explore other potential benefits of their approach, such as enhanced multimodal robustness or improved contextual understanding. These aspects could be interesting avenues for further research.
Overall, the paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of multimodal learning, and the authors' techniques could have widespread applicability in a variety of domains where leveraging multiple data sources is crucial.
Conclusion
This paper presents an innovative approach to addressing the challenge of modal imbalance in multimodal machine learning. By introducing a multi-loss objective and a dynamic balancing process, the authors have developed a method that can effectively leverage complementary information from different modalities, such as audio and video, leading to significant performance improvements across multiple datasets.
The proposed techniques demonstrate the potential of combining multiple data sources to enhance machine learning models, with implications for a wide range of applications, from enhanced content moderation to improved contextual understanding. As multimodal learning continues to advance, this work offers valuable insights and a useful tool for researchers and practitioners alike.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🌀
Data-Efficient Multimodal Fusion on a Single GPU
Noel Vouitsis, Zhaoyan Liu, Satya Krishna Gorti, Valentin Villecroze, Jesse C. Cresswell, Guangwei Yu, Gabriel Loaiza-Ganem, Maksims Volkovs
0
0
The goal of multimodal alignment is to learn a single latent space that is shared between multimodal inputs. The most powerful models in this space have been trained using massive datasets of paired inputs and large-scale computational resources, making them prohibitively expensive to train in many practical scenarios. We surmise that existing unimodal encoders pre-trained on large amounts of unimodal data should provide an effective bootstrap to create multimodal models from unimodal ones at much lower costs. We therefore propose FuseMix, a multimodal augmentation scheme that operates on the latent spaces of arbitrary pre-trained unimodal encoders. Using FuseMix for multimodal alignment, we achieve competitive performance -- and in certain cases outperform state-of-the art methods -- in both image-text and audio-text retrieval, with orders of magnitude less compute and data: for example, we outperform CLIP on the Flickr30K text-to-image retrieval task with $sim ! 600times$ fewer GPU days and $sim ! 80times$ fewer image-text pairs. Additionally, we show how our method can be applied to convert pre-trained text-to-image generative models into audio-to-image ones. Code is available at: https://github.com/layer6ai-labs/fusemix.
4/11/2024
🌐
Towards Multi-Task Multi-Modal Models: A Video Generative Perspective
Lijun Yu
0
0
Advancements in language foundation models have primarily fueled the recent surge in artificial intelligence. In contrast, generative learning of non-textual modalities, especially videos, significantly trails behind language modeling. This thesis chronicles our endeavor to build multi-task models for generating videos and other modalities under diverse conditions, as well as for understanding and compression applications. Given the high dimensionality of visual data, we pursue concise and accurate latent representations. Our video-native spatial-temporal tokenizers preserve high fidelity. We unveil a novel approach to mapping bidirectionally between visual observation and interpretable lexical terms. Furthermore, our scalable visual token representation proves beneficial across generation, compression, and understanding tasks. This achievement marks the first instances of language models surpassing diffusion models in visual synthesis and a video tokenizer outperforming industry-standard codecs. Within these multi-modal latent spaces, we study the design of multi-task generative models. Our masked multi-task transformer excels at the quality, efficiency, and flexibility of video generation. We enable a frozen language model, trained solely on text, to generate visual content. Finally, we build a scalable generative multi-modal transformer trained from scratch, enabling the generation of videos containing high-fidelity motion with the corresponding audio given diverse conditions. Throughout the course, we have shown the effectiveness of integrating multiple tasks, crafting high-fidelity latent representation, and generating multiple modalities. This work suggests intriguing potential for future exploration in generating non-textual data and enabling real-time, interactive experiences across various media forms.
5/28/2024
🔄
Beyond Unimodal Learning: The Importance of Integrating Multiple Modalities for Lifelong Learning
Fahad Sarfraz, Bahram Zonooz, Elahe Arani
0
0
While humans excel at continual learning (CL), deep neural networks (DNNs) exhibit catastrophic forgetting. A salient feature of the brain that allows effective CL is that it utilizes multiple modalities for learning and inference, which is underexplored in DNNs. Therefore, we study the role and interactions of multiple modalities in mitigating forgetting and introduce a benchmark for multimodal continual learning. Our findings demonstrate that leveraging multiple views and complementary information from multiple modalities enables the model to learn more accurate and robust representations. This makes the model less vulnerable to modality-specific regularities and considerably mitigates forgetting. Furthermore, we observe that individual modalities exhibit varying degrees of robustness to distribution shift. Finally, we propose a method for integrating and aligning the information from different modalities by utilizing the relational structural similarities between the data points in each modality. Our method sets a strong baseline that enables both single- and multimodal inference. Our study provides a promising case for further exploring the role of multiple modalities in enabling CL and provides a standard benchmark for future research.
5/7/2024
ReconBoost: Boosting Can Achieve Modality Reconcilement
Cong Hua, Qianqian Xu, Shilong Bao, Zhiyong Yang, Qingming Huang
0
0
This paper explores a novel multi-modal alternating learning paradigm pursuing a reconciliation between the exploitation of uni-modal features and the exploration of cross-modal interactions. This is motivated by the fact that current paradigms of multi-modal learning tend to explore multi-modal features simultaneously. The resulting gradient prohibits further exploitation of the features in the weak modality, leading to modality competition, where the dominant modality overpowers the learning process. To address this issue, we study the modality-alternating learning paradigm to achieve reconcilement. Specifically, we propose a new method called ReconBoost to update a fixed modality each time. Herein, the learning objective is dynamically adjusted with a reconcilement regularization against competition with the historical models. By choosing a KL-based reconcilement, we show that the proposed method resembles Friedman's Gradient-Boosting (GB) algorithm, where the updated learner can correct errors made by others and help enhance the overall performance. The major difference with the classic GB is that we only preserve the newest model for each modality to avoid overfitting caused by ensembling strong learners. Furthermore, we propose a memory consolidation scheme and a global rectification scheme to make this strategy more effective. Experiments over six multi-modal benchmarks speak to the efficacy of the method. We release the code at https://github.com/huacong/ReconBoost.
5/16/2024