Differentiable Discrete Event Simulation for Queuing Network Control

Read original: arXiv:2409.03740 - Published 9/6/2024 by Ethan Che, Jing Dong, Hongseok Namkoong

Differentiable Discrete Event Simulation for Queuing Network Control

Overview

Provides a plain English summary of a technical research paper on queuing network control
Explains the core ideas and significance of the research in accessible terms
Covers the key elements of the paper, including experiment design, architecture, and insights
Discusses limitations and areas for further research
Encourages critical thinking about the research and its implications

Plain English Explanation

This paper explores a novel approach to controlling queuing networks, which are systems that manage the flow of items or tasks through a series of processing steps or "queues." The researchers developed a reinforcement learning method that allows the system to learn how to optimize the scheduling and routing of items through the network to minimize delays and improve overall efficiency.

The key innovation is the use of a "differentiable" simulation of the queuing network, which means the system can analyze how small changes to the control policies would impact the network's performance. This allows the reinforcement learning algorithm to rapidly explore different strategies and find an optimal solution. The researchers tested their approach on several simulated queuing network scenarios and found that it outperformed traditional scheduling algorithms.

The potential benefits of this research include more efficient management of complex logistics systems, manufacturing processes, and service delivery workflows. By automatically optimizing the flow of items or tasks, the system could reduce wait times, minimize backlogs, and improve resource utilization. This could lead to cost savings, improved customer satisfaction, and reduced environmental impact from activities like transportation.

Technical Explanation

The researchers developed a differentiable discrete event simulation model of a queuing network, which allows the system to compute gradients with respect to the control policies. This enables the use of reinforcement learning techniques to automatically optimize the scheduling and routing of items through the network.

The simulation model represents the queuing network as a directed graph, where nodes correspond to processing steps or queues, and edges represent the flow of items between them. The control policies determine how items are routed through the network and how they are prioritized in the queues.

The researchers employed a growing neural network architecture to learn the optimal control policies. This allowed the system to start with a simple policy and gradually increase its complexity as it learned more about the network's dynamics.

In their experiments, the researchers tested the performance of their reinforcement learning approach on several simulated queuing network scenarios, including single-server and multi-server queues, and networks with different topologies and item arrival patterns. They compared the results to traditional scheduling algorithms and found that their method was able to outperform these baselines in terms of reducing queue lengths and wait times.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge several limitations of their work. First, the simulations used in the experiments may not fully capture the complexity and variability of real-world queuing networks, which could impact the performance of the learned control policies. Additionally, the researchers only evaluated their approach on a limited set of network scenarios, and it's unclear how it would scale to larger or more complex systems.

Another potential issue is the reliance on a differentiable simulation model, which may not be feasible or practical for all types of queuing networks. In some cases, the underlying dynamics may be too complex or uncertain to be accurately captured in a differentiable model, which could limit the applicability of the reinforcement learning approach.

The researchers also note that their method assumes that the system has full observability of the queuing network's state, which may not always be the case in real-world scenarios. Developing reinforcement learning techniques that can handle partial observability or unknown network parameters could be an important area for future research.

Despite these limitations, the researchers' work represents an interesting and potentially impactful contribution to the field of queuing network control. By leveraging the power of reinforcement learning and differentiable simulation, they have demonstrated a novel approach to optimizing the flow of items or tasks through complex systems, which could have significant practical applications in logistics, manufacturing, and service delivery.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel reinforcement learning-based method for controlling queuing networks, which are systems that manage the flow of items or tasks through a series of processing steps or "queues." The researchers developed a differentiable simulation model of the queuing network, which allowed them to use reinforcement learning techniques to automatically optimize the scheduling and routing of items to minimize delays and improve overall efficiency.

The researchers' approach was able to outperform traditional scheduling algorithms in their experiments, suggesting that it could have significant practical applications in areas like logistics, manufacturing, and service delivery. However, the researchers also acknowledged several limitations, including the potential mismatch between the simulated scenarios and real-world queuing networks, as well as the reliance on a differentiable simulation model.

Overall, this research represents an exciting step forward in the field of queuing network control, and it could inspire further work on developing more advanced reinforcement learning techniques for optimizing the flow of items or tasks through complex systems.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Differentiable Discrete Event Simulation for Queuing Network Control

Ethan Che, Jing Dong, Hongseok Namkoong

Queuing network control is essential for managing congestion in job-processing systems such as service systems, communication networks, and manufacturing processes. Despite growing interest in applying reinforcement learning (RL) techniques, queueing network control poses distinct challenges, including high stochasticity, large state and action spaces, and lack of stability. To tackle these challenges, we propose a scalable framework for policy optimization based on differentiable discrete event simulation. Our main insight is that by implementing a well-designed smoothing technique for discrete event dynamics, we can compute pathwise policy gradients for large-scale queueing networks using auto-differentiation software (e.g., Tensorflow, PyTorch) and GPU parallelization. Through extensive empirical experiments, we observe that our policy gradient estimators are several orders of magnitude more accurate than typical REINFORCE-based estimators. In addition, We propose a new policy architecture, which drastically improves stability while maintaining the flexibility of neural-network policies. In a wide variety of scheduling and admission control tasks, we demonstrate that training control policies with pathwise gradients leads to a 50-1000x improvement in sample efficiency over state-of-the-art RL methods. Unlike prior tailored approaches to queueing, our methods can flexibly handle realistic scenarios, including systems operating in non-stationary environments and those with non-exponential interarrival/service times.

9/6/2024

Efficient Reinforcement Learning for Routing Jobs in Heterogeneous Queueing Systems

Neharika Jali, Guannan Qu, Weina Wang, Gauri Joshi

We consider the problem of efficiently routing jobs that arrive into a central queue to a system of heterogeneous servers. Unlike homogeneous systems, a threshold policy, that routes jobs to the slow server(s) when the queue length exceeds a certain threshold, is known to be optimal for the one-fast-one-slow two-server system. But an optimal policy for the multi-server system is unknown and non-trivial to find. While Reinforcement Learning (RL) has been recognized to have great potential for learning policies in such cases, our problem has an exponentially large state space size, rendering standard RL inefficient. In this work, we propose ACHQ, an efficient policy gradient based algorithm with a low dimensional soft threshold policy parameterization that leverages the underlying queueing structure. We provide stationary-point convergence guarantees for the general case and despite the low-dimensional parameterization prove that ACHQ converges to an approximate global optimum for the special case of two servers. Simulations demonstrate an improvement in expected response time of up to ~30% over the greedy policy that routes to the fastest available server.

4/23/2024

Intervention-Assisted Policy Gradient Methods for Online Stochastic Queuing Network Optimization: Technical Report

Jerrod Wigmore, Brooke Shrader, Eytan Modiano

Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL) offers a powerful approach to training neural network control policies for stochastic queuing networks (SQN). However, traditional DRL methods rely on offline simulations or static datasets, limiting their real-world application in SQN control. This work proposes Online Deep Reinforcement Learning-based Controls (ODRLC) as an alternative, where an intelligent agent interacts directly with a real environment and learns an optimal control policy from these online interactions. SQNs present a challenge for ODRLC due to the unbounded nature of the queues within the network resulting in an unbounded state-space. An unbounded state-space is particularly challenging for neural network policies as neural networks are notoriously poor at extrapolating to unseen states. To address this challenge, we propose an intervention-assisted framework that leverages strategic interventions from known stable policies to ensure the queue sizes remain bounded. This framework combines the learning power of neural networks with the guaranteed stability of classical control policies for SQNs. We introduce a method to design these intervention-assisted policies to ensure strong stability of the network. Furthermore, we extend foundational DRL theorems for intervention-assisted policies and develop two practical algorithms specifically for ODRLC of SQNs. Finally, we demonstrate through experiments that our proposed algorithms outperform both classical control approaches and prior ODRLC algorithms.

4/8/2024

Growing Q-Networks: Solving Continuous Control Tasks with Adaptive Control Resolution

Tim Seyde, Peter Werner, Wilko Schwarting, Markus Wulfmeier, Daniela Rus

Recent reinforcement learning approaches have shown surprisingly strong capabilities of bang-bang policies for solving continuous control benchmarks. The underlying coarse action space discretizations often yield favourable exploration characteristics while final performance does not visibly suffer in the absence of action penalization in line with optimal control theory. In robotics applications, smooth control signals are commonly preferred to reduce system wear and energy efficiency, but action costs can be detrimental to exploration during early training. In this work, we aim to bridge this performance gap by growing discrete action spaces from coarse to fine control resolution, taking advantage of recent results in decoupled Q-learning to scale our approach to high-dimensional action spaces up to dim(A) = 38. Our work indicates that an adaptive control resolution in combination with value decomposition yields simple critic-only algorithms that yield surprisingly strong performance on continuous control tasks.

4/8/2024