DistilDoc: Knowledge Distillation for Visually-Rich Document Applications

Overview

• This paper explores the use of knowledge distillation (KD) for improving the efficiency of visually-rich document (VRD) applications, such as document layout analysis (DLA) and document image classification (DIC).
• The researchers designed a KD experimentation methodology to create more lean and performant models for document understanding (DU) tasks, which are crucial components within larger task pipelines.
• The study investigates different KD strategies, including response-based and feature-based approaches, for distilling knowledge between backbone models with varying architectures (ResNet, ViT, DiT) and capacities (base, small, tiny).
• The paper examines factors that affect the teacher-student knowledge gap and finds that some KD methods can outperform supervised student training.
• The researchers also evaluate the robustness of distilled DLA models on a downstream task, zero-shot layout-aware document visual question answering (DocVQA), to assess covariate shift.

Plain English Explanation

The paper focuses on making document-related AI models more efficient and easier to use. Many of these models are becoming increasingly complex and cumbersome, which can make them difficult to deploy in real-world applications. The researchers investigate a technique called knowledge distillation to address this issue.

Knowledge distillation involves training a smaller, more efficient "student" model to mimic the behavior of a larger, more sophisticated "teacher" model. The researchers experimented with different strategies for transferring knowledge from the teacher to the student, such as matching the outputs or internal features of the models.

They found that some of these knowledge distillation methods can produce student models that outperform those trained from scratch, even though the student models are much smaller and simpler. This suggests that knowledge distillation can be an effective way to create more efficient document understanding models without sacrificing too much performance.

The researchers also looked at how well the distilled models perform on a specific downstream task, document visual question answering. This allowed them to assess the models' ability to maintain their understanding of document layout and structure, even when applied to new situations.

Overall, this work highlights the potential of knowledge distillation to make visually-rich document AI systems more practical and accessible, by developing smaller and more efficient models without losing critical capabilities.

Technical Explanation

The paper explores the use of knowledge distillation (KD) to improve the efficiency of visually-rich document (VRD) applications, such as document layout analysis (DLA) and document image classification (DIC). While VRD research has increasingly relied on sophisticated and complex models, the field has not adequately studied model compression techniques to improve efficiency.

The researchers designed a KD experimentation methodology to create more lean and performant models for document understanding (DU) tasks, which are integral components within larger task pipelines. They carefully selected KD strategies, including response-based (e.g., vanilla KD, knowledge distillation for LLMs and automatic scoring) and feature-based (e.g., SimKD with an appropriate projector) approaches, for distilling knowledge between backbone models with different architectures (ResNet, ViT, DiT) and capacities (base, small, tiny).

The study investigates factors that affect the teacher-student knowledge gap and finds that some KD methods, such as tuned vanilla KD, MSE, and SimKD with an apt projector, can consistently outperform supervised student training. Furthermore, the researchers designed downstream task setups to evaluate covariate shift and the robustness of distilled DLA models on zero-shot layout-aware document visual question answering (DocVQA). The DLA-KD experiments resulted in a large mAP knowledge gap, which unpredictably translates to downstream robustness, highlighting the need for further exploration on how to efficiently obtain more semantic document layout awareness.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a thorough exploration of knowledge distillation techniques for improving the efficiency of visually-rich document AI models. The researchers' design of a KD experimentation methodology and their careful selection of KD strategies are commendable. The finding that some KD methods can outperform supervised student training is a promising result, suggesting that knowledge distillation can be an effective way to create more efficient document understanding models without sacrificing too much performance.

However, the paper also highlights the challenges in translating the improvements in the primary task (DLA) to downstream robustness, as seen in the unpredictable results on the zero-shot layout-aware DocVQA task. This accentuates the need for further research on how to ensure that the distilled models maintain a more comprehensive and semantic understanding of document layout, which is crucial for their application in larger task pipelines.

Additionally, the paper does not provide much detail on the specific architectural choices and hyperparameter tuning for the various KD strategies explored. More information on these aspects could help researchers and practitioners better understand the factors that contribute to the observed performance differences.

Overall, this work makes a valuable contribution to the field of visually-rich document AI by demonstrating the potential of knowledge distillation to improve model efficiency. The insights and lessons learned from this study can inform future research aimed at developing more robust and practical document understanding systems.

Conclusion

This paper explores the use of knowledge distillation to improve the efficiency of visually-rich document (VRD) AI models, such as those used for document layout analysis and document image classification. The researchers designed a KD experimentation methodology to create more lean and performant models for document understanding tasks, which are crucial components within larger task pipelines.

The study investigates various KD strategies, including response-based and feature-based approaches, for distilling knowledge between backbone models with different architectures and capacities. The findings indicate that some KD methods can consistently outperform supervised student training, suggesting that knowledge distillation can be an effective way to develop more efficient document understanding models without significant performance degradation.

However, the paper also highlights the challenge of maintaining the models' semantic understanding of document layout when applying them to downstream tasks, which is an area that requires further exploration. Addressing this issue could lead to the development of more robust and practical visually-rich document AI systems that can be more easily deployed in real-world applications.