Distributed Traffic Signal Control via Coordinated Maximum Pressure-plus-Penalty
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a new distributed traffic signal control algorithm called "Coordinated Maximum Pressure-plus-Penalty" (CMP+).
- The algorithm aims to optimize traffic flows at signalized intersections in a decentralized manner, without requiring a centralized controller.
- It builds upon the well-known Maximum Pressure (MP) control strategy, adding a penalty term to improve coordination between neighboring intersections.
Plain English Explanation
Traffic signals play a crucial role in managing the flow of vehicles at intersections. Traditionally, these signals have been controlled by centralized systems that coordinate the timing of lights across multiple intersections. However, centralized traffic control systems can be complex and difficult to maintain, especially in large-scale urban networks.
The Coordinated Maximum Pressure-plus-Penalty (CMP+) algorithm introduced in this paper offers a decentralized alternative. Rather than relying on a central controller, each intersection manages its own traffic signals independently, based on the current queue lengths and waiting times of vehicles. The algorithm uses a "maximum pressure" principle, which aims to minimize the total waiting time of vehicles passing through the intersection.
To improve coordination between neighboring intersections, the CMP+ algorithm adds a "penalty" term. This penalty encourages intersections to consider the impact of their decisions on upstream and downstream traffic, helping to smooth out the flow of vehicles across the network. By incorporating this penalty, the algorithm can achieve better overall traffic efficiency without sacrificing the benefits of a decentralized approach.
Technical Explanation
The Coordinated Maximum Pressure-plus-Penalty (CMP+) algorithm builds upon the well-established Maximum Pressure (MP) control strategy. In the MP approach, each intersection independently sets its signal timings to minimize the total waiting time of vehicles passing through, based on the current queue lengths.
The CMP+ algorithm adds a "penalty" term to the MP objective function, which encourages intersections to consider the impact of their decisions on neighboring intersections. This penalty is designed to promote better coordination and reduce the formation of "spillback" queues, where vehicles waiting at one intersection block the flow of traffic at upstream intersections.
The authors demonstrate the performance of CMP+ through simulations on a variety of traffic network scenarios, including both grid-like and arterial road configurations. They compare the results to both centralized and decentralized control strategies, showing that CMP+ can achieve significant improvements in terms of average vehicle delay and network-wide travel time.
Critical Analysis
The Coordinated Maximum Pressure-plus-Penalty (CMP+) algorithm represents an interesting approach to the challenge of distributed traffic signal control. By building upon the well-understood Maximum Pressure (MP) control strategy and incorporating a penalty term to encourage coordination, the authors have developed a decentralized solution that can outperform more centralized alternatives.
One potential limitation of the CMP+ approach is that it relies on accurate information about queue lengths and waiting times at each intersection. In real-world scenarios, obtaining this data in a reliable and timely manner may be challenging, especially in large, dynamic traffic networks. The authors acknowledge this issue and suggest that approximate methods could be explored to address it.
Additionally, the paper focuses on the overall performance of the CMP+ algorithm in terms of average vehicle delay and network travel time. While these metrics are important, it would also be valuable to consider other factors, such as fairness, environmental impact (e.g., fuel consumption, emissions), and the robustness of the algorithm to changes in traffic patterns or network conditions.
Conclusion
The Coordinated Maximum Pressure-plus-Penalty (CMP+) algorithm presented in this paper offers a promising approach to the challenge of distributed traffic signal control. By building upon the well-established Maximum Pressure (MP) strategy and incorporating a coordination-promoting penalty term, the authors have developed a decentralized solution that can outperform more centralized control strategies in terms of overall traffic efficiency.
While the algorithm shows strong performance in simulation-based experiments, further research is needed to address practical implementation challenges, such as the reliance on accurate real-time data. Exploring ways to make the CMP+ algorithm more robust and adaptable to changing traffic conditions could also be a fruitful area for future work. Overall, this research contributes valuable insights to the ongoing efforts to develop more efficient and scalable traffic management systems for the growing challenges of urban mobility.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Distributed Traffic Signal Control via Coordinated Maximum Pressure-plus-Penalty
Vinzenz Tutsch, Zhiyu He, Florian Dorfler, Kenan Zhang
This paper develops an adaptive traffic control policy inspired by Maximum Pressure (MP) while imposing coordination across intersections. The proposed Coordinated Maximum Pressure-plus-Penalty (CMPP) control policy features a local objective for each intersection that consists of the total pressure within the neighborhood and a penalty accounting for the queue capacities and continuous green time for certain movements. The corresponding control task is reformulated as a distributed optimization problem and solved via two customized algorithms: one based on the alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM) and the other follows a greedy heuristic augmented with a majority vote. CMPP not only provides a theoretical guarantee of queuing network stability but also outperforms several benchmark controllers in simulations on a large-scale real traffic network with lower average travel and waiting time per vehicle, as well as less network congestion. Furthermore, CPMM with the greedy algorithm enjoys comparable computational efficiency as fully decentralized controllers without significantly compromising the control performance, which highlights its great potential for real-world deployment.
Read more5/1/2024
0
AMPIC: Adaptive Model Predictive Ising Controller for large-scale urban traffic signals
Daisuke Inoue, Hiroshi Yamashita, Kazuyuki Aihara, Hiroaki Yoshida
Realizing smooth traffic flow is important for achieving carbon neutrality. Adaptive traffic signal control, which considers traffic conditions, has thus attracted attention. However, it is difficult to ensure optimal vehicle flow throughout a large city using existing control methods because of their heavy computational load. Here, we propose a control method called AMPIC (Adaptive Model Predictive Ising Controller) that guarantees both scalability and optimality. The proposed method employs model predictive control to solve an optimal control problem at each control interval with explicit consideration of a predictive model of vehicle flow. This optimal control problem is transformed into a combinatorial optimization problem with binary variables that is equivalent to the so-called Ising problem. This transformation allows us to use an Ising solver, which has been widely studied and is expected to have fast and efficient optimization performance. We performed numerical experiments using a microscopic traffic simulator for a realistic city road network. The results show that AMPIC enables faster vehicle cruising speed with less waiting time than that achieved by classical control methods, resulting in lower CO2 emissions. The model predictive approach with a long prediction horizon thus effectively improves control performance. Systematic parametric studies on model cities indicate that the proposed method realizes smoother traffic flows for large city road networks. Among Ising solvers, D-Wave's quantum annealing is shown to find near-optimal solutions at a reasonable computational cost.
Read more7/15/2024
0
Generalized Multi-hop Traffic Pressure for Heterogeneous Traffic Perimeter Control
Xiaocan Li, Xiaoyu Wang, Ilia Smirnov, Scott Sanner, Baher Abdulhai
Perimeter control prevents loss of traffic network capacity due to congestion in urban areas. Homogeneous perimeter control allows all access points to a protected region to have the same maximal permitted inflow. However, homogeneous perimeter control performs poorly when the congestion in the protected region is heterogeneous (e.g., imbalanced demand) since the homogeneous perimeter control does not consider location-specific traffic conditions around the perimeter. When the protected region has spatially heterogeneous congestion, it can often make sense to modulate the perimeter inflow rate to be higher near low-density regions and vice versa for high-density regions. To assist with this modulation, we can leverage the concept of 1-hop traffic pressure to measure intersection-level traffic congestion. However, as we show, 1-hop pressure turns out to be too spatially myopic for perimeter control and hence we formulate multi-hop generalizations of pressure that look ``deeper'' inside the perimeter beyond the entry intersection. In addition, we formulate a simple heterogeneous perimeter control methodology that can leverage this novel multi-hop pressure to redistribute the total permitted inflow provided by the homogeneous perimeter controller. Experimental results show that our heterogeneous perimeter control policies leveraging multi-hop pressure significantly outperform homogeneous perimeter control in scenarios where the origin-destination flows are highly imbalanced with high spatial heterogeneity.
Read more9/4/2024
0
Differentiable Predictive Control for Large-Scale Urban Road Networks
Renukanandan Tumu, Wenceslao Shaw Cortez, J'an Drgov{n}a, Draguna L. Vrabie, Sonja Glavaski
Transportation is a major contributor to CO2 emissions, making it essential to optimize traffic networks to reduce energy-related emissions. This paper presents a novel approach to traffic network control using Differentiable Predictive Control (DPC), a physics-informed machine learning methodology. We base our model on the Macroscopic Fundamental Diagram (MFD) and the Networked Macroscopic Fundamental Diagram (NMFD), offering a simplified representation of citywide traffic networks. Our approach ensures compliance with system constraints by construction. In empirical comparisons with existing state-of-the-art Model Predictive Control (MPC) methods, our approach demonstrates a 4 order of magnitude reduction in computation time and an up to 37% improvement in traffic performance. Furthermore, we assess the robustness of our controller to scenario shifts and find that it adapts well to changes in traffic patterns. This work proposes more efficient traffic control methods, particularly in large-scale urban networks, and aims to mitigate emissions and alleviate congestion in the future.
Read more6/18/2024