Do Vision-Language Transformers Exhibit Visual Commonsense? An Empirical Study of VCR
2405.16934
0
0
Abstract
Visual Commonsense Reasoning (VCR) calls for explanatory reasoning behind question answering over visual scenes. To achieve this goal, a model is required to provide an acceptable rationale as the reason for the predicted answers. Progress on the benchmark dataset stems largely from the recent advancement of Vision-Language Transformers (VL Transformers). These models are first pre-trained on some generic large-scale vision-text datasets, and then the learned representations are transferred to the downstream VCR task. Despite their attractive performance, this paper posits that the VL Transformers do not exhibit visual commonsense, which is the key to VCR. In particular, our empirical results pinpoint several shortcomings of existing VL Transformers: small gains from pre-training, unexpected language bias, limited model architecture for the two inseparable sub-tasks, and neglect of the important object-tag correlation. With these findings, we tentatively suggest some future directions from the aspect of dataset, evaluation metric, and training tricks. We believe this work could make researchers revisit the intuition and goals of VCR, and thus help tackle the remaining challenges in visual reasoning.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates whether vision-language transformers exhibit visual commonsense reasoning by conducting an empirical study on the Visual Commonsense Reasoning (VCR) task.
- VCR tests a model's ability to answer questions and explain the rationale behind those answers given an image, evaluating its visual commonsense understanding.
- The researchers analyze the performance and behavior of several state-of-the-art vision-language models on VCR to gain insights into their visual commonsense reasoning capabilities.
Plain English Explanation
The paper examines whether advanced vision-language models that combine visual and textual information can truly understand the common sense reasoning behind images, not just recognize objects and scenes.
To test this, the researchers use the Visual Commonsense Reasoning (VCR) task, which requires models to not just answer questions about an image, but also explain the reasoning behind their answers. This taps into a deeper level of visual understanding beyond simple recognition.
By analyzing how well different vision-language models perform on VCR, the researchers aim to shed light on the extent to which these models have developed genuine visual commonsense - the ability to reason about the implicit meanings, relationships, and implications within visual scenes, similar to how humans understand the world around them.
Technical Explanation
The paper evaluates the visual commonsense reasoning capabilities of several state-of-the-art vision-language transformers on the Visual Commonsense Reasoning (VCR) task. VCR requires models to not only answer multiple-choice questions about an image, but also provide an explanation for their answer choices.
The researchers test models like LXMERT, ViLBERT, and UNITER on the VCR task and analyze their performance, probing into the models' internal representations and decision-making processes. They also compare the models' performance to that of humans on the task.
Through this empirical study, the authors aim to gain insights into the extent to which these vision-language transformers have developed true visual commonsense understanding, beyond just recognizing objects and scenes in the images.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a rigorous and thoughtful analysis of the visual commonsense reasoning capabilities of leading vision-language models. However, the authors acknowledge several caveats and limitations to their work.
First, the VCR task, while a valuable benchmark, may not fully capture the breadth and depth of visual commonsense reasoning required in real-world scenarios. There may be additional aspects of commonsense understanding that are not tested by VCR.
Additionally, the models examined in the study were not specifically fine-tuned or trained on the VCR dataset, which could potentially limit their performance. Approaches that leverage event-aware pretraining or distill vision-language models from large video datasets may exhibit stronger visual commonsense reasoning capabilities.
Further research is needed to more holistically assess the commonsense understanding of vision-language decoders and identify the limitations or biases that may be inherent in current approaches.
Conclusion
This paper provides a valuable empirical study on the visual commonsense reasoning abilities of state-of-the-art vision-language transformers. The findings suggest that while these models have made significant progress in combining visual and textual information, they still struggle to exhibit the depth of commonsense understanding that humans possess when reasoning about visual scenes.
The insights from this research can help guide the development of more robust and commonsense-aware vision-language models, which will be crucial for advancing applications such as visual question answering, image captioning, and multimodal reasoning. Continued progress in this area could lead to AI systems with a more human-like understanding of the world and the ability to engage in more meaningful and contextual interactions.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
ViCor: Bridging Visual Understanding and Commonsense Reasoning with Large Language Models
Kaiwen Zhou, Kwonjoon Lee, Teruhisa Misu, Xin Eric Wang
0
0
In our work, we explore the synergistic capabilities of pre-trained vision-and-language models (VLMs) and large language models (LLMs) on visual commonsense reasoning (VCR) problems. We find that VLMs and LLMs-based decision pipelines are good at different kinds of VCR problems. Pre-trained VLMs exhibit strong performance for problems involving understanding the literal visual content, which we noted as visual commonsense understanding (VCU). For problems where the goal is to infer conclusions beyond image content, which we noted as visual commonsense inference (VCI), VLMs face difficulties, while LLMs, given sufficient visual evidence, can use commonsense to infer the answer well. We empirically validate this by letting LLMs classify VCR problems into these two categories and show the significant difference between VLM and LLM with image caption decision pipelines on two subproblems. Moreover, we identify a challenge with VLMs' passive perception, which may miss crucial context information, leading to incorrect reasoning by LLMs. Based on these, we suggest a collaborative approach, named ViCor, where pre-trained LLMs serve as problem classifiers to analyze the problem category, then either use VLMs to answer the question directly or actively instruct VLMs to concentrate on and gather relevant visual elements to support potential commonsense inferences. We evaluate our framework on two VCR benchmark datasets and outperform all other methods that do not require in-domain fine-tuning.
5/20/2024
EventLens: Leveraging Event-Aware Pretraining and Cross-modal Linking Enhances Visual Commonsense Reasoning
Mingjie Ma, Zhihuan Yu, Yichao Ma, Guohui Li
0
0
Visual Commonsense Reasoning (VCR) is a cognitive task, challenging models to answer visual questions requiring human commonsense, and to provide rationales explaining why the answers are correct. With emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs), it is natural and imperative to explore their applicability to VCR. However, VCR task demands more external knowledge to tackle its challenging questions, necessitating special designs to activate LLMs' commonsense reasoning abilities. Also, most existing Multimodal LLMs adopted an abstraction of entire input image, which makes it difficult to comprehend VCR's unique co-reference tags between image regions and text, posing challenges for fine-grained alignment. To address these issues, we propose EventLens that leverages Event-Aware Pretraining and Cross-modal Linking and EnhanceS VCR. First, by emulating the cognitive process of human reasoning, an Event-Aware Pretraining auxiliary task is introduced to better activate LLM's global comprehension of intricate scenarios. Second, during fine-tuning, we further utilize reference tags to bridge RoI features with texts, while preserving both modality semantics. Finally, we use instruct-style prompts to narrow the gap between pretraining and fine-tuning, and task-specific adapters to better integrate LLM's inherent knowledge with new commonsense. Experimental results show the effectiveness of our proposed auxiliary task and fine-grained linking strategy.
4/23/2024
VCR: Visual Caption Restoration
Tianyu Zhang, Suyuchen Wang, Lu Li, Ge Zhang, Perouz Taslakian, Sai Rajeswar, Jie Fu, Bang Liu, Yoshua Bengio
0
0
We introduce Visual Caption Restoration (VCR), a novel vision-language task that challenges models to accurately restore partially obscured texts using pixel-level hints within images. This task stems from the observation that text embedded in images is intrinsically different from common visual elements and natural language due to the need to align the modalities of vision, text, and text embedded in images. While numerous works have integrated text embedded in images into visual question-answering tasks, approaches to these tasks generally rely on optical character recognition or masked language modeling, thus reducing the task to mainly text-based processing. However, text-based processing becomes ineffective in VCR as accurate text restoration depends on the combined information from provided images, context, and subtle cues from the tiny exposed areas of masked texts. We develop a pipeline to generate synthetic images for the VCR task using image-caption pairs, with adjustable caption visibility to control the task difficulty. With this pipeline, we construct a dataset for VCR called VCR-Wiki using images with captions from Wikipedia, comprising 2.11M English and 346K Chinese entities in both easy and hard split variants. Our results reveal that current vision language models significantly lag behind human performance in the VCR task, and merely fine-tuning the models on our dataset does not lead to notable improvements. We release VCR-Wiki and the data construction code to facilitate future research.
6/26/2024
Improving Visual Commonsense in Language Models via Multiple Image Generation
Guy Yariv, Idan Schwartz, Yossi Adi, Sagie Benaim
0
0
Commonsense reasoning is fundamentally based on multimodal knowledge. However, existing large language models (LLMs) are primarily trained using textual data only, limiting their ability to incorporate essential visual information. In contrast, Visual Language Models, which excel at visually-oriented tasks, often fail at non-visual tasks such as basic commonsense reasoning. This divergence highlights a critical challenge - the integration of robust visual understanding with foundational text-based language reasoning. To this end, we introduce a method aimed at enhancing LLMs' visual commonsense. Specifically, our method generates multiple images based on the input text prompt and integrates these into the model's decision-making process by mixing their prediction probabilities. To facilitate multimodal grounded language modeling, we employ a late-fusion layer that combines the projected visual features with the output of a pre-trained LLM conditioned on text only. This late-fusion layer enables predictions based on comprehensive image-text knowledge as well as text only when this is required. We evaluate our approach using several visual commonsense reasoning tasks together with traditional NLP tasks, including common sense reasoning and reading comprehension. Our experimental results demonstrate significant superiority over existing baselines. When applied to recent state-of-the-art LLMs (e.g., Llama3), we observe improvements not only in visual common sense but also in traditional NLP benchmarks. Code and models are available under https://github.com/guyyariv/vLMIG.
6/21/2024