An Economic Solution to Copyright Challenges of Generative AI
2404.13964
0
0
Abstract
Generative artificial intelligence (AI) systems are trained on large data corpora to generate new pieces of text, images, videos, and other media. There is growing concern that such systems may infringe on the copyright interests of training data contributors. To address the copyright challenges of generative AI, we propose a framework that compensates copyright owners proportionally to their contributions to the creation of AI-generated content. The metric for contributions is quantitatively determined by leveraging the probabilistic nature of modern generative AI models and using techniques from cooperative game theory in economics. This framework enables a platform where AI developers benefit from access to high-quality training data, thus improving model performance. Meanwhile, copyright owners receive fair compensation, driving the continued provision of relevant data for generative model training. Experiments demonstrate that our framework successfully identifies the most relevant data sources used in artwork generation, ensuring a fair and interpretable distribution of revenues among copyright owners.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Proposes an economic framework called "Shapley Royalty Share" to address copyright challenges posed by generative AI systems
- Outlines a method for fairly distributing royalties among data sources used to train AI models
- Aims to provide a practical solution to ensure creators are compensated for their contributions
Plain English Explanation
The paper presents an economic solution to the copyright challenges posed by generative AI systems. As these models become more advanced, they can be used to create content that may infringe on the intellectual property rights of various creators. The authors propose a framework called the "Shapley Royalty Share" that aims to fairly distribute royalties among the different data sources used to train the AI models.
The key idea is to use the Shapley value, a concept from cooperative game theory, to determine the relative contribution of each data source to the overall value of the trained model. By calculating the Shapley value for each data source, the framework can then allocate royalties proportionally, ensuring that creators are compensated for their contributions.
This approach is designed to be practical and scalable, addressing the complex copyright issues that arise as generative AI systems become more prevalent in various industries. By providing a transparent and equitable method for distributing royalties, the authors hope to incentivize the responsible development and use of these powerful AI technologies.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents the "Shapley Royalty Share" framework as a solution to the copyright challenges posed by generative AI systems. The framework is based on the Shapley value, a concept from cooperative game theory that calculates the relative contribution of each player (in this case, data source) to the overall value of the game (the trained AI model).
The authors outline a process for determining the Shapley value of each data source used to train the AI model. This involves calculating the marginal contribution of each data source by considering all possible combinations of data sources and how they impact the model's performance. The Shapley value is then used to determine the royalty share that should be allocated to each data source, ensuring fair compensation for their contributions.
The paper also discusses the practical implementation of the Shapley Royalty Share framework, including the use of efficient algorithms to compute the Shapley values and the potential for incorporating other factors, such as data quality and exclusivity, into the royalty distribution scheme.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed economic framework that aims to address a significant challenge in the era of generative AI – the fair distribution of royalties among various data sources used to train these models. The Shapley Royalty Share approach is a thoughtful and theoretically sound solution that builds upon established concepts in cooperative game theory.
One potential limitation of the proposed framework is the computational complexity involved in calculating the Shapley values, especially as the number of data sources scales. The authors acknowledge this challenge and discuss the use of efficient algorithms to mitigate the computational burden. However, the practical implementation of the framework may still require careful consideration and optimization.
Additionally, the paper does not delve into the specific legal and regulatory implications of the Shapley Royalty Share framework. It would be valuable to explore how this approach might be integrated with existing copyright laws and industry practices, as well as any potential legal hurdles or policy considerations that need to be addressed.
Overall, the Shapley Royalty Share framework presents a promising and well-reasoned solution to the copyright challenges posed by generative AI. The paper's contribution lies in its ability to provide a practical and equitable mechanism for balancing the interests of AI developers, data providers, and content creators. As the field of generative AI continues to evolve, further research and exploration of this and other approaches to address copyright issues will be crucial.
Conclusion
The paper proposes the "Shapley Royalty Share" framework as an economic solution to the copyright challenges posed by generative AI systems. By using the Shapley value to determine the relative contribution of each data source used to train an AI model, the framework aims to allocate royalties in a fair and transparent manner, ensuring that creators are compensated for their contributions.
This approach addresses a critical issue that has arisen with the rapid advancements in generative AI, where the ability to create content that may infringe on intellectual property rights has become a growing concern. The Shapley Royalty Share framework offers a practical and scalable solution that could help incentivize the responsible development and use of these powerful AI technologies, while also protecting the rights of content creators.
As the field of generative AI continues to evolve, the insights and framework presented in this paper could have significant implications for various industries and stakeholders. By providing a fair and equitable mechanism for distributing royalties, the Shapley Royalty Share framework has the potential to foster a more sustainable and collaborative ecosystem for the creation and distribution of digital content.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Data Shapley in One Training Run
Jiachen T. Wang, Prateek Mittal, Dawn Song, Ruoxi Jia
0
0
Generative artificial intelligence (AI) systems are trained on large data corpora to generate new pieces of text, images, videos, and other media. There is growing concern that such systems may infringe on the copyright interests of training data contributors. To address the copyright challenges of generative AI, we propose a framework that compensates copyright owners proportionally to their contributions to the creation of AI-generated content. The metric for contributions is quantitatively determined by leveraging the probabilistic nature of modern generative AI models and using techniques from cooperative game theory in economics. This framework enables a platform where AI developers benefit from access to high-quality training data, thus improving model performance. Meanwhile, copyright owners receive fair compensation, driving the continued provision of relevant data for generative model training. Experiments demonstrate that our framework successfully identifies the most relevant data sources used in artwork generation, ensuring a fair and interpretable distribution of revenues among copyright owners.
6/18/2024
🤖
Uncertain Boundaries: Multidisciplinary Approaches to Copyright Issues in Generative AI
Jocelyn Dzuong, Zichong Wang, Wenbin Zhang
0
0
In the rapidly evolving landscape of generative artificial intelligence (AI), the increasingly pertinent issue of copyright infringement arises as AI advances to generate content from scraped copyrighted data, prompting questions about ownership and protection that impact professionals across various careers. With this in mind, this survey provides an extensive examination of copyright infringement as it pertains to generative AI, aiming to stay abreast of the latest developments and open problems. Specifically, it will first outline methods of detecting copyright infringement in mediums such as text, image, and video. Next, it will delve an exploration of existing techniques aimed at safeguarding copyrighted works from generative models. Furthermore, this survey will discuss resources and tools for users to evaluate copyright violations. Finally, insights into ongoing regulations and proposals for AI will be explored and compared. Through combining these disciplines, the implications of AI-driven content and copyright are thoroughly illustrated and brought into question.
4/15/2024
🤖
AI Royalties -- an IP Framework to Compensate Artists & IP Holders for AI-Generated Content
Pablo Ducru, Jonathan Raiman, Ronaldo Lemos, Clay Garner, George He, Hanna Balcha, Gabriel Souto, Sergio Branco, Celina Bottino
0
0
This article investigates how AI-generated content can disrupt central revenue streams of the creative industries, in particular the collection of dividends from intellectual property (IP) rights. It reviews the IP and copyright questions related to the input and output of generative AI systems. A systematic method is proposed to assess whether AI-generated outputs, especially images, infringe previous copyrights, using a similarity metric (CLIP) between images against historical copyright rulings. An examination (economic and technical feasibility) of previously proposed compensation frameworks reveals their financial implications for creatives and IP holders. Lastly, we propose a novel IP framework for compensation of artists and IP holders based on their published licensed AIs as a new medium and asset from which to collect AI royalties.
6/19/2024
🌀
Tackling GenAI Copyright Issues: Originality Estimation and Genericization
Hiroaki Chiba-Okabe, Weijie J. Su
0
0
The rapid progress of generative AI technology has sparked significant copyright concerns, leading to numerous lawsuits filed against AI developers. While some studies explore methods to mitigate copyright risks by steering the outputs of generative models away from those resembling copyrighted data, little attention has been paid to the question of how much of a resemblance is undesirable; more original or unique data are afforded stronger protection, and the threshold level of resemblance for constituting infringement correspondingly lower. Here, leveraging this principle, we propose a genericization method that modifies the outputs of a generative model to make them more generic and less likely to infringe copyright. To achieve this, we introduce a metric for quantifying the level of originality of data in a manner that is consistent with the legal framework. This metric can be practically estimated by drawing samples from a generative model, which is then used for the genericization process. Experiments demonstrate that our genericization method successfully modifies the output of a text-to-image generative model so that it produces more generic, copyright-compliant images.
6/24/2024