Efficiency in Focus: LayerNorm as a Catalyst for Fine-tuning Medical Visual Language Pre-trained Models
0
💬
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper explores the use of Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) methods to adapt large-scale Medical Visual Language Models (Med-VLMs) for downstream tasks in the medical domain.
- Researchers often face challenges in the medical domain due to limited training data and significant domain-specific requirements, making the evaluation and adaptation of PEFT methods for Med-VLMs crucial.
- The paper investigates the impact of fine-tuning intrinsic model components, such as LayerNorm layers, FFNs, and Attention layers, on the performance of Med-VLMs across tasks like Medical Visual Question Answering and Medical Imaging Report Generation.
Plain English Explanation
Medical researchers often use powerful language models, called Medical Visual Language Models (Med-VLMs), to help with tasks like answering questions about medical images or generating reports on medical scans. However, these models can be challenging to adapt for specific medical applications, especially when there is limited training data available.
This paper explores a different approach, called Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT). The researchers wanted to see if they could fine-tune, or adjust, certain parts of the Med-VLMs, like the LayerNorm layers, in order to make them work better for medical tasks, while using fewer resources than traditional fine-tuning methods.
The team tested their PEFT approach on both small and large-scale Med-VLMs, and found that fine-tuning just the LayerNorm layers was actually better than other PEFT methods. It was more efficient, but also maintained the models' accuracy and ability to generalize, or apply what they've learned, to different medical tasks.
Technical Explanation
The paper explores the use of Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) methods to adapt large-scale Medical Visual Language Models (Med-VLMs) for downstream tasks in the medical domain. Given the unique challenges in the medical domain, such as limited data scope and significant domain-specific requirements, evaluating and adapting PEFT methods specifically for Med-VLMs is essential.
The researchers conducted comprehensive studies spanning both small-scale and large-scale Med-VLMs, evaluating their performance under various fine-tuning paradigms across tasks such as Medical Visual Question Answering and Medical Imaging Report Generation. The key focus was on the impact of fine-tuning intrinsic model components, including LayerNorm layers, FFNs, and Attention layers, on the performance of Med-VLMs.
The findings reveal that fine-tuning solely the LayerNorm layers not only surpasses the efficiency of traditional PEFT methods but also retains the model's accuracy and generalization capabilities across a spectrum of medical downstream tasks. The experiments show LayerNorm fine-tuning's superior adaptability and scalability, particularly in the context of large-scale Med-VLMs.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive analysis of PEFT methods for adapting Med-VLMs to downstream medical tasks. However, the researchers acknowledge that their experiments were limited to a specific set of tasks and datasets, and further evaluation on a wider range of medical applications would be beneficial to validate the generalizability of their findings.
Additionally, the paper does not delve into the underlying mechanisms or theoretical explanations for why fine-tuning the LayerNorm layers specifically leads to superior performance. Exploring the reasons behind this behavior could provide deeper insights and guide the development of even more effective PEFT strategies for Med-VLMs.
It would also be interesting to see the researchers investigate the impact of combining LayerNorm fine-tuning with other PEFT techniques, such as adapter modules or prompt tuning, to potentially further enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of the fine-tuning process.
Conclusion
This paper presents a compelling approach to adapting large-scale Medical Visual Language Models (Med-VLMs) for downstream medical tasks using Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) methods. The key finding is that fine-tuning solely the LayerNorm layers of Med-VLMs can outperform traditional PEFT methods in terms of efficiency and retention of model accuracy and generalization capabilities.
These insights have significant implications for medical researchers who often face challenges in accessing large-scale training datasets. The adaptability and scalability of the LayerNorm fine-tuning approach, particularly for large-scale Med-VLMs, could enable more efficient and effective utilization of these powerful language models in real-world medical applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
💬
0
Efficiency in Focus: LayerNorm as a Catalyst for Fine-tuning Medical Visual Language Pre-trained Models
Jiawei Chen, Dingkang Yang, Yue Jiang, Mingcheng Li, Jinjie Wei, Xiaolu Hou, Lihua Zhang
In the realm of Medical Visual Language Models (Med-VLMs), the quest for universal efficient fine-tuning mechanisms remains paramount, especially given researchers in interdisciplinary fields are often extremely short of training resources, yet largely unexplored. Given the unique challenges in the medical domain, such as limited data scope and significant domain-specific requirements, evaluating and adapting Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) methods specifically for Med-VLMs is essential. Most of the current PEFT methods on Med-VLMs have yet to be comprehensively investigated but mainly focus on adding some components to the model's structure or input. However, fine-tuning intrinsic model components often yields better generality and consistency, and its impact on the ultimate performance of Med-VLMs has been widely overlooked and remains understudied. In this paper, we endeavour to explore an alternative to traditional PEFT methods, especially the impact of fine-tuning LayerNorm layers, FFNs and Attention layers on the Med-VLMs. Our comprehensive studies span both small-scale and large-scale Med-VLMs, evaluating their performance under various fine-tuning paradigms across tasks such as Medical Visual Question Answering and Medical Imaging Report Generation. The findings reveal unique insights into the effects of intrinsic parameter fine-tuning methods on fine-tuning Med-VLMs to downstream tasks and expose fine-tuning solely the LayerNorm layers not only surpasses the efficiency of traditional PEFT methods but also retains the model's accuracy and generalization capabilities across a spectrum of medical downstream tasks. The experiments show LayerNorm fine-tuning's superior adaptability and scalability, particularly in the context of large-scale Med-VLMs.
Read more4/26/2024
0
Can LLMs' Tuning Methods Work in Medical Multimodal Domain?
Jiawei Chen, Yue Jiang, Dingkang Yang, Mingcheng Li, Jinjie Wei, Ziyun Qian, Lihua Zhang
While Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in world knowledge understanding, adapting them to specific subfields requires precise adjustments. Due to the model's vast scale, traditional global fine-tuning methods for large models can be computationally expensive and impact generalization. To address this challenge, a range of innovative Parameters-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) methods have emerged and achieved remarkable success in both LLMs and Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs). In the medical domain, fine-tuning a medical Vision-Language Pretrained (VLP) model is essential for adapting it to specific tasks. Can the fine-tuning methods for large models be transferred to the medical field to enhance transfer learning efficiency? In this paper, we delve into the fine-tuning methods of LLMs and conduct extensive experiments to investigate the impact of fine-tuning methods for large models on the existing multimodal model in the medical domain from the training data level and the model structure level. We show the different impacts of fine-tuning methods for large models on medical VLMs and develop the most efficient ways to fine-tune medical VLP models. We hope this research can guide medical domain researchers in optimizing VLMs' training costs, fostering the broader application of VLMs in healthcare fields. The code and dataset have been released at https://github.com/TIMMY-CHAN/MILE.
Read more7/9/2024
🖼️
0
Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning for Medical Image Analysis: The Missed Opportunity
Raman Dutt, Linus Ericsson, Pedro Sanchez, Sotirios A. Tsaftaris, Timothy Hospedales
Foundation models have significantly advanced medical image analysis through the pre-train fine-tune paradigm. Among various fine-tuning algorithms, Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) is increasingly utilized for knowledge transfer across diverse tasks, including vision-language and text-to-image generation. However, its application in medical image analysis is relatively unexplored due to the lack of a structured benchmark for evaluating PEFT methods. This study fills this gap by evaluating 17 distinct PEFT algorithms across convolutional and transformer-based networks on image classification and text-to-image generation tasks using six medical datasets of varying size, modality, and complexity. Through a battery of over 700 controlled experiments, our findings demonstrate PEFT's effectiveness, particularly in low data regimes common in medical imaging, with performance gains of up to 22% in discriminative and generative tasks. These recommendations can assist the community in incorporating PEFT into their workflows and facilitate fair comparisons of future PEFT methods, ensuring alignment with advancements in other areas of machine learning and AI.
Read more6/11/2024
0
Probing the Efficacy of Federated Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning of Vision Transformers for Medical Image Classification
Naif Alkhunaizi, Faris Almalik, Rouqaiah Al-Refai, Muzammal Naseer, Karthik Nandakumar
With the advent of large pre-trained transformer models, fine-tuning these models for various downstream tasks is a critical problem. Paucity of training data, the existence of data silos, and stringent privacy constraints exacerbate this fine-tuning problem in the medical imaging domain, creating a strong need for algorithms that enable collaborative fine-tuning of pre-trained models. Moreover, the large size of these models necessitates the use of parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) to reduce the communication burden in federated learning. In this work, we systematically investigate various federated PEFT strategies for adapting a Vision Transformer (ViT) model (pre-trained on a large natural image dataset) for medical image classification. Apart from evaluating known PEFT techniques, we introduce new federated variants of PEFT algorithms such as visual prompt tuning (VPT), low-rank decomposition of visual prompts, stochastic block attention fine-tuning, and hybrid PEFT methods like low-rank adaptation (LoRA)+VPT. Moreover, we perform a thorough empirical analysis to identify the optimal PEFT method for the federated setting and understand the impact of data distribution on federated PEFT, especially for out-of-domain (OOD) and non-IID data. The key insight of this study is that while most federated PEFT methods work well for in-domain transfer, there is a substantial accuracy vs. efficiency trade-off when dealing with OOD and non-IID scenarios, which is commonly the case in medical imaging. Specifically, every order of magnitude reduction in fine-tuned/exchanged parameters can lead to a 4% drop in accuracy. Thus, the initial model choice is crucial for federated PEFT. It is preferable to use medical foundation models learned from in-domain medical image data (if available) rather than general vision models.
Read more7/17/2024