An Efficient Approach for Studying Cross-Lingual Transfer in Multilingual Language Models
2403.20088
0
0
🔄
Abstract
The capacity and effectiveness of pre-trained multilingual models (MLMs) for zero-shot cross-lingual transfer is well established. However, phenomena of positive or negative transfer, and the effect of language choice still need to be fully understood, especially in the complex setting of massively multilingual LMs. We propose an textit{efficient} method to study transfer language influence in zero-shot performance on another target language. Unlike previous work, our approach disentangles downstream tasks from language, using dedicated adapter units. Our findings suggest that some languages do not largely affect others, while some languages, especially ones unseen during pre-training, can be extremely beneficial or detrimental for different target languages. We find that no transfer language is beneficial for all target languages. We do, curiously, observe languages previously unseen by MLMs consistently benefit from transfer from almost any language. We additionally use our modular approach to quantify negative interference efficiently and categorize languages accordingly. Furthermore, we provide a list of promising transfer-target language configurations that consistently lead to target language performance improvements. Code and data are publicly available: https://github.com/ffaisal93/neg_inf
Get summaries of the top AI research delivered straight to your inbox:
Overview
- Multilingual language models (MLMs) are well-established for performing tasks in different languages without additional training (zero-shot transfer).
- However, the factors influencing positive or negative transfer between languages are not fully understood, especially in complex multilingual settings.
- The researchers propose an efficient method to study the impact of transfer languages on zero-shot performance in target languages.
- Their approach separates the downstream task from the language, using dedicated adapter units.
Plain English Explanation
Language models are AI systems that can understand and generate human language. Multilingual models are trained on data from many languages, allowing them to work with multiple languages without needing to be retrained.
The researchers wanted to better understand how using one language as a "starting point" (a transfer language) can help or hurt the model's performance on another language (the target language). This is important because in the real world, we often need language models that can work well across many different languages.
The researchers developed a new, efficient way to test the impact of transfer languages. Unlike previous approaches, their method separates the task the model is trying to solve from the language it's working with. This allows them to isolate the language effects.
Their findings suggest that some languages don't have much impact on others, while some - especially languages the model wasn't trained on - can be extremely helpful or harmful for different target languages. Interestingly, they found that languages the model wasn't exposed to during training often benefit from transfer from almost any other language.
The researchers also used their approach to identify cases where using a transfer language actually hurts the model's performance on the target language. This helps categorize languages based on their potential for negative interference.
Overall, this work provides a better understanding of how multilingual language models behave and how to get the best performance when working across many languages.
Technical Explanation
The researchers proposed an efficient method to study the impact of transfer languages on zero-shot cross-lingual performance. Unlike previous approaches, their method uses dedicated adapter units to disentangle the downstream task from the language being used.
The core idea is to train the model on a source language, then use that trained model as a starting point (transfer language) for fine-tuning on a target language. By isolating the language component, the researchers can directly measure the effect of the transfer language on the target language's performance.
The experiments were conducted on a massively multilingual language model (M4) trained on 102 languages. The researchers tested various transfer-target language configurations and measured the zero-shot performance on the target language.
The key findings include:
- Some languages have little impact on others, while some - especially those unseen during pre-training - can be extremely beneficial or detrimental for different target languages.
- No single transfer language was found to be universally beneficial for all target languages.
- Interestingly, languages previously unseen by the MLM consistently benefited from transfer from almost any other language.
- The researchers also used their modular approach to efficiently quantify negative interference and categorize languages accordingly.
- Additionally, the paper provides a list of promising transfer-target language configurations that consistently lead to performance improvements on the target language.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge that their findings are specific to the particular multilingual model (M4) and tasks used in the experiments. The behavior of other multilingual models or different task types may differ.
The paper does not delve into the underlying reasons why certain language pairs exhibit positive or negative transfer. Further research would be needed to understand the linguistic and semantic factors that drive these phenomena.
Additionally, the experiments were conducted in a controlled, isolated setting. Real-world applications may involve more complex interactions between multiple languages and tasks, which could lead to different outcomes.
Future work could explore the generalization of these findings to other multilingual models, a wider range of tasks, and more realistic usage scenarios. Investigating the linguistic mechanisms behind the observed transfer effects could also provide valuable insights.
Conclusion
This research provides an efficient method and important insights into the complex dynamics of cross-lingual transfer in multilingual language models. The findings suggest that the choice of transfer language can have a significant and unpredictable impact on the performance of target languages, with some languages proving extremely beneficial or detrimental.
The researchers' modular approach allows for the systematic study of these effects, which is crucial for developing robust and effective multilingual AI systems. The identified cases of negative interference and promising transfer-target configurations offer practical guidance for leveraging multilingual models in real-world applications.
Overall, this work represents an important step towards a better understanding of multilingual language models and how to harness their capabilities across diverse linguistic settings.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
💬
Empirical study of pretrained multilingual language models for zero-shot cross-lingual knowledge transfer in generation
Nadezhda Chirkova, Sheng Liang, Vassilina Nikoulina
0
0
Zero-shot cross-lingual knowledge transfer enables the multilingual pretrained language model (mPLM), finetuned on a task in one language, make predictions for this task in other languages. While being broadly studied for natural language understanding tasks, the described setting is understudied for generation. Previous works notice a frequent problem of generation in a wrong language and propose approaches to address it, usually using mT5 as a backbone model. In this work, we test alternative mPLMs, such as mBART and NLLB-200, considering full finetuning and parameter-efficient finetuning with adapters. We find that mBART with adapters performs similarly to mT5 of the same size, and NLLB-200 can be competitive in some cases. We also underline the importance of tuning learning rate used for finetuning, which helps to alleviate the problem of generation in the wrong language.
4/23/2024
Cross-Lingual Transfer Robustness to Lower-Resource Languages on Adversarial Datasets
Shadi Manafi, Nikhil Krishnaswamy
0
0
Multilingual Language Models (MLLMs) exhibit robust cross-lingual transfer capabilities, or the ability to leverage information acquired in a source language and apply it to a target language. These capabilities find practical applications in well-established Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks such as Named Entity Recognition (NER). This study aims to investigate the effectiveness of a source language when applied to a target language, particularly in the context of perturbing the input test set. We evaluate on 13 pairs of languages, each including one high-resource language (HRL) and one low-resource language (LRL) with a geographic, genetic, or borrowing relationship. We evaluate two well-known MLLMs--MBERT and XLM-R--on these pairs, in native LRL and cross-lingual transfer settings, in two tasks, under a set of different perturbations. Our findings indicate that NER cross-lingual transfer depends largely on the overlap of entity chunks. If a source and target language have more entities in common, the transfer ability is stronger. Models using cross-lingual transfer also appear to be somewhat more robust to certain perturbations of the input, perhaps indicating an ability to leverage stronger representations derived from the HRL. Our research provides valuable insights into cross-lingual transfer and its implications for NLP applications, and underscores the need to consider linguistic nuances and potential limitations when employing MLLMs across distinct languages.
4/1/2024
🔄
Measuring Cross-lingual Transfer in Bytes
Leandro Rodrigues de Souza, Thales Sales Almeida, Roberto Lotufo, Rodrigo Nogueira
0
0
Multilingual pretraining has been a successful solution to the challenges posed by the lack of resources for languages. These models can transfer knowledge to target languages with minimal or no examples. Recent research suggests that monolingual models also have a similar capability, but the mechanisms behind this transfer remain unclear. Some studies have explored factors like language contamination and syntactic similarity. An emerging line of research suggests that the representations learned by language models contain two components: a language-specific and a language-agnostic component. The latter is responsible for transferring a more universal knowledge. However, there is a lack of comprehensive exploration of these properties across diverse target languages. To investigate this hypothesis, we conducted an experiment inspired by the work on the Scaling Laws for Transfer. We measured the amount of data transferred from a source language to a target language and found that models initialized from diverse languages perform similarly to a target language in a cross-lingual setting. This was surprising because the amount of data transferred to 10 diverse target languages, such as Spanish, Korean, and Finnish, was quite similar. We also found evidence that this transfer is not related to language contamination or language proximity, which strengthens the hypothesis that the model also relies on language-agnostic knowledge. Our experiments have opened up new possibilities for measuring how much data represents the language-agnostic representations learned during pretraining.
4/15/2024
🔄
Key ingredients for effective zero-shot cross-lingual knowledge transfer in generative tasks
Nadezhda Chirkova, Vassilina Nikoulina
0
0
Zero-shot cross-lingual knowledge transfer enables a multilingual pretrained language model, finetuned on a task in one language, make predictions for this task in other languages. While being broadly studied for natural language understanding tasks, the described setting is understudied for generation. Previous works notice a frequent problem of generation in a wrong language and propose approaches to address it, usually using mT5 as a backbone model. In this work we compare various approaches proposed from the literature in unified settings, also including alternative backbone models, namely mBART and NLLB-200. We first underline the importance of tuning learning rate used for finetuning, which helps to substantially alleviate the problem of generation in the wrong language. Then, we show that with careful learning rate tuning, the simple full finetuning of the model acts as a very strong baseline and alternative approaches bring only marginal improvements. Finally, we find that mBART performs similarly to mT5 of the same size, and NLLB-200 can be competitive in some cases. Our final zero-shot models reach the performance of the approach based on data translation which is usually considered as an upper baseline for zero-shot cross-lingual transfer in generation.
4/23/2024