Efficient End-to-End Visual Document Understanding with Rationale Distillation

Overview

• Understanding visual documents with textual and visual elements requires complex processing
• Current methods using optical character recognition (OCR) and large language models have high computational and engineering complexity
• The paper proposes an alternative approach using a small image-to-text model trained with rationale distillation

Plain English Explanation

Interpreting visual documents, like infographics or figures, can be challenging because they combine text, images, and other visual elements in complex layouts. Current approaches often use optical character recognition (OCR) to extract text, then feed that into large language models to understand the content. However, these methods are computationally intensive and require a lot of engineering effort.

The researchers in this paper propose a simpler solution - training a small image-to-text model to directly understand the visual documents. Their key insight is to have this small model learn from the outputs of the more complex OCR and language models, rather than trying to replicate their full capabilities. This "rationale distillation" approach allows the small model to efficiently capture the essential information needed to interpret the visual documents.

On benchmarks of different types of visual documents, the researchers' small Pix2Struct model outperformed the base model by 4-5% in accuracy, while only increasing computational cost by 1%. This suggests their approach can achieve high performance with much lower complexity compared to the current state-of-the-art methods.

Technical Explanation

The paper addresses the challenge of understanding visually situated language, where textual and visual elements are combined in complex layouts. Current approaches use OCR to extract text, then feed that into large language models (LLMs) to reason about the content. However, the authors note that these methods have high computational and engineering complexity.

To address this, the researchers propose Rationale Distillation (RD), which trains a small image-to-text model, called Pix2Struct, to predict both the outputs of OCR tools and LLMs, as well as the final answers. By learning from these "rationales" provided by the more complex models, the small Pix2Struct model can efficiently capture the essential information needed for visual document understanding.

The authors evaluate Pix2Struct on three benchmarks covering infographics, scanned documents, and figures. They find that the Pix2Struct model finetuned with RD outperforms the base model by 4-5% absolute accuracy, while only increasing computational cost by 1%. This suggests their approach can achieve high performance with much lower complexity compared to current state-of-the-art methods.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a promising approach to visual document understanding that could significantly reduce the computational and engineering complexity compared to existing methods. The use of rationale distillation to train the small Pix2Struct model is a clever way to leverage the capabilities of more complex models without replicating their full functionality.

However, the paper does not delve deeply into the potential limitations or caveats of this approach. For example, it's unclear how well the Pix2Struct model would generalize to completely new types of visual documents beyond the specific benchmarks used in the evaluation. Additionally, the paper does not discuss the potential for bias or errors to be introduced by the OCR and LLM models whose outputs are used as rationales.

Further research could explore the robustness of the Pix2Struct model, as well as investigate ways to make the rationale distillation process more transparent and controllable. Incorporating uncertainty estimates or explainability mechanisms into the model could also help users understand its decision-making processes and potential failure modes.

Conclusion

The proposed Rationale Distillation approach offers a compelling alternative to the computationally-intensive methods currently used for visual document understanding. By training a small image-to-text model to learn from the outputs of OCR tools and large language models, the researchers demonstrate significant gains in performance while substantially reducing the complexity.

This work has the potential to make visual document understanding more accessible and practical for a wide range of applications, from assistive technologies to automated document processing. As the field continues to evolve, further research on the limitations and robustness of this approach will be crucial to ensuring its long-term impact.