Efficient Online Set-valued Classification with Bandit Feedback
2405.04393
0
0
🏷️
Abstract
Conformal prediction is a distribution-free method that wraps a given machine learning model and returns a set of plausible labels that contain the true label with a prescribed coverage rate. In practice, the empirical coverage achieved highly relies on fully observed label information from data both in the training phase for model fitting and the calibration phase for quantile estimation. This dependency poses a challenge in the context of online learning with bandit feedback, where a learner only has access to the correctness of actions (i.e., pulled an arm) but not the full information of the true label. In particular, when the pulled arm is incorrect, the learner only knows that the pulled one is not the true class label, but does not know which label is true. Additionally, bandit feedback further results in a smaller labeled dataset for calibration, limited to instances with correct actions, thereby affecting the accuracy of quantile estimation. To address these limitations, we propose Bandit Class-specific Conformal Prediction (BCCP), offering coverage guarantees on a class-specific granularity. Using an unbiased estimation of an estimand involving the true label, BCCP trains the model and makes set-valued inferences through stochastic gradient descent. Our approach overcomes the challenges of sparsely labeled data in each iteration and generalizes the reliability and applicability of conformal prediction to online decision-making environments.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Conformal prediction is a distribution-free method that wraps a given machine learning model and returns a set of plausible labels that contain the true label with a prescribed coverage rate.
- In online learning with bandit feedback, the learner only has access to the correctness of actions (i.e., pulled an arm) but not the full information of the true label, posing challenges for conformal prediction.
- The paper proposes Bandit Class-specific Conformal Prediction (BCCP) to offer coverage guarantees on a class-specific granularity, overcoming the limitations of sparsely labeled data in each iteration.
Plain English Explanation
Conformal prediction is a technique that can be used to improve the reliability of machine learning models. It works by adding internal link a "safety net" around the model's predictions, returning a set of plausible labels rather than a single prediction. This set is designed to contain the true label a certain percentage of the time, even if the model itself is not perfectly accurate.
However, conformal prediction typically relies on having access to the full set of true labels in the training and calibration data. This can be a challenge in real-world scenarios, such as online learning with "bandit feedback." In these cases, the learner only knows whether the chosen action was correct, but not the true label of the entire set of possible actions. Additionally, the limited feedback results in a smaller dataset for calibrating the conformal prediction.
To address these issues, the researchers propose a new method called Bandit Class-specific Conformal Prediction (BCCP). BCCP uses an unbiased estimate of the true label information to train the model and make set-valued predictions, overcoming the sparsity of labeled data in each iteration. This allows BCCP to provide coverage guarantees at the level of individual classes, rather than just overall.
By adding internal link generalizing conformal prediction to work with limited feedback, BCCP can make these reliable predictions useful in a broader range of real-world applications.
Technical Explanation
The key innovation of the proposed BCCP method is the way it handles the limited feedback available in online learning with bandit feedback. Typically, conformal prediction requires fully observed label information from the data, both during the model training phase and the calibration phase for quantile estimation.
In the bandit feedback setting, the learner only knows whether the chosen action (i.e., "pulled arm") was correct, but not the true label of the entire set of possible actions. Additionally, the limited feedback results in a smaller labeled dataset for calibration, which can negatively impact the accuracy of the quantile estimation.
To address these challenges, BCCP uses an unbiased estimation of an estimand involving the true label. This allows the method to add internal link train the model and make set-valued inferences through stochastic gradient descent, even with the sparse label information available in each iteration.
The key benefit of this approach is that it can provide add internal link coverage guarantees on a class-specific granularity, rather than just overall. This is important because it allows the method to be more reliable and applicable in online decision-making environments.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling solution to the challenges of applying conformal prediction in online learning with bandit feedback. By using an unbiased estimate of the true label information, BCCP is able to overcome the limitations of sparse labeled data and provide class-specific coverage guarantees.
One potential caveat is the reliance on the accuracy of the unbiased estimator. If there are biases or other issues with the estimator, this could impact the reliability of the BCCP method. The paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the estimator's properties and its behavior in various scenarios.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the computational complexity and scalability of the BCCP approach. As the number of classes or the size of the dataset grows, the performance and efficiency of the method may become a concern, especially in real-time applications.
It would also be valuable to see the BCCP method add internal link evaluated on a wider range of real-world bandit feedback scenarios, beyond the synthetic experiments presented in the paper. This could help uncover any additional challenges or limitations in practical deployments.
Conclusion
The Bandit Class-specific Conformal Prediction (BCCP) method proposed in this paper represents an important advancement in the field of conformal prediction. By addressing the challenges of limited label information in online learning with bandit feedback, BCCP can provide reliable, class-specific coverage guarantees that are crucial for practical decision-making applications.
The innovative use of unbiased estimation to train the model and make set-valued predictions is a key technical contribution that could inspire further research in this area. As the use of machine learning models becomes more widespread, methods like BCCP that can quantify and improve the reliability of these models will become increasingly valuable.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔮
Stochastic Online Conformal Prediction with Semi-Bandit Feedback
Haosen Ge, Hamsa Bastani, Osbert Bastani
0
0
Conformal prediction has emerged as an effective strategy for uncertainty quantification by modifying a model to output sets of labels instead of a single label. These prediction sets come with the guarantee that they contain the true label with high probability. However, conformal prediction typically requires a large calibration dataset of i.i.d. examples. We consider the online learning setting, where examples arrive over time, and the goal is to construct prediction sets dynamically. Departing from existing work, we assume semi-bandit feedback, where we only observe the true label if it is contained in the prediction set. For instance, consider calibrating a document retrieval model to a new domain; in this setting, a user would only be able to provide the true label if the target document is in the prediction set of retrieved documents. We propose a novel conformal prediction algorithm targeted at this setting, and prove that it obtains sublinear regret compared to the optimal conformal predictor. We evaluate our algorithm on a retrieval task and an image classification task, and demonstrate that it empirically achieves good performance.
5/24/2024
Conformal online model aggregation
Matteo Gasparin, Aaditya Ramdas
0
0
Conformal prediction equips machine learning models with a reasonable notion of uncertainty quantification without making strong distributional assumptions. It wraps around any black-box prediction model and converts point predictions into set predictions that have a predefined marginal coverage guarantee. However, conformal prediction only works if we fix the underlying machine learning model in advance. A relatively unaddressed issue in conformal prediction is that of model selection and/or aggregation: for a given problem, which of the plethora of prediction methods (random forests, neural nets, regularized linear models, etc.) should we conformalize? This paper proposes a new approach towards conformal model aggregation in online settings that is based on combining the prediction sets from several algorithms by voting, where weights on the models are adapted over time based on past performance.
5/3/2024
Robust Conformal Prediction Using Privileged Information
Shai Feldman, Yaniv Romano
0
0
We develop a method to generate prediction sets with a guaranteed coverage rate that is robust to corruptions in the training data, such as missing or noisy variables. Our approach builds on conformal prediction, a powerful framework to construct prediction sets that are valid under the i.i.d assumption. Importantly, naively applying conformal prediction does not provide reliable predictions in this setting, due to the distribution shift induced by the corruptions. To account for the distribution shift, we assume access to privileged information (PI). The PI is formulated as additional features that explain the distribution shift, however, they are only available during training and absent at test time. We approach this problem by introducing a novel generalization of weighted conformal prediction and support our method with theoretical coverage guarantees. Empirical experiments on both real and synthetic datasets indicate that our approach achieves a valid coverage rate and constructs more informative predictions compared to existing methods, which are not supported by theoretical guarantees.
6/11/2024
🔮
Conformal Prediction with Learned Features
Shayan Kiyani, George Pappas, Hamed Hassani
0
0
In this paper, we focus on the problem of conformal prediction with conditional guarantees. Prior work has shown that it is impossible to construct nontrivial prediction sets with full conditional coverage guarantees. A wealth of research has considered relaxations of full conditional guarantees, relying on some predefined uncertainty structures. Departing from this line of thinking, we propose Partition Learning Conformal Prediction (PLCP), a framework to improve conditional validity of prediction sets through learning uncertainty-guided features from the calibration data. We implement PLCP efficiently with alternating gradient descent, utilizing off-the-shelf machine learning models. We further analyze PLCP theoretically and provide conditional guarantees for infinite and finite sample sizes. Finally, our experimental results over four real-world and synthetic datasets show the superior performance of PLCP compared to state-of-the-art methods in terms of coverage and length in both classification and regression scenarios.
4/29/2024