EKM: An exact, polynomial-time algorithm for the $K$-medoids problem

Read original: arXiv:2405.12237 - Published 5/22/2024 by Xi He, Max A. Little

🔍

Overview

The $K$-medoids problem is a challenging clustering task used in data analysis
Existing algorithms cannot find the exact (globally optimal) solution efficiently
This paper presents a new algorithm called EKM that can solve the $K$-medoids problem exactly in polynomial time

Plain English Explanation

The $K$-medoids problem is a way of grouping data points into $K$ clusters. It's a useful tool for data analysis, but finding the best way to group the data is a complex mathematical challenge. Many algorithms have been proposed to solve this problem, but they can't guarantee that the solution they find is the absolute best one. This paper introduces a new algorithm called EKM that can actually find the optimal solution, and it can do so in a reasonable amount of time, even for large datasets.

The key idea behind EKM is to use a systematic, step-by-step process to generate all possible ways of grouping the data, and then carefully evaluate each one to find the best solution. This might sound like it would take a long time, but the researchers were able to develop some clever mathematical techniques that make the process much faster than it would be otherwise. As a result, EKM can solve the $K$-medoids problem exactly in a practical amount of time, which is a significant advance over existing methods.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a new algorithm called EKM (Exact $K$-Medoids) for solving the $K$-medoids problem exactly in polynomial time. The $K$-medoids problem is a challenging combinatorial optimization task that involves grouping a set of $N$ data points into $K$ clusters in an optimal way.

EKM is developed using recent advances in transformational programming and combinatorial generation. The algorithm systematically generates all possible partitions of the data into $K$ clusters, and then evaluates each one to find the global optimum. The key innovation is that EKM can do this in $O(N^{K+1})$ time, which is polynomial in the number of data points $N$, despite the inherent exponential complexity of the problem.

The authors prove that EKM is correct by construction, meaning the algorithm is guaranteed to find the globally optimal solution. They demonstrate the effectiveness of EKM by comparing it to various approximate methods on real-world datasets. The results show that EKM matches the predicted worst-case time complexity and significantly outperforms existing branch-and-bound approaches, which have exponential time complexity.

To our knowledge, this is the first rigorously-proven polynomial time algorithm for solving the $K$-medoids problem exactly. This is an important advancement, as the $K$-medoids problem is widely used in data analysis applications, but previously there was no practical way to find the globally optimal solution.

Critical Analysis

The EKM algorithm presented in this paper is a significant breakthrough for solving the $K$-medoids problem exactly and efficiently. The authors have clearly put a lot of thought and rigor into the design and analysis of the algorithm.

One potential limitation is that the $O(N^{K+1})$ time complexity, while polynomial, may still be prohibitively expensive for very large datasets or when $K$ is relatively large. The authors acknowledge this and suggest that EKM may be most useful for moderate-sized problems where finding the global optimum is important.

It would also be interesting to see how EKM compares to recent advances in approximate $K$-medoids algorithms, which may be able to find near-optimal solutions much faster for some applications. A hybrid approach that uses EKM to initialize an approximate algorithm could potentially leverage the strengths of both.

Overall, this is an impressive piece of work that pushes the boundaries of what is possible for this important clustering problem. The authors have made a strong case for the practical relevance of their algorithm, and I'm curious to see how it is adopted and built upon by the research community.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel algorithm called EKM that can solve the $K$-medoids problem exactly in polynomial time. This is a significant advancement over existing methods, which could only find approximate solutions efficiently.

The key innovation of EKM is its systematic approach to generating and evaluating all possible partitions of the data, using recent developments in transformational programming. The authors prove the algorithm's correctness and demonstrate its effectiveness on real-world datasets, showing that it can match its predicted worst-case time complexity.

While EKM may have limitations for extremely large-scale problems, it represents an important milestone in the quest to solve the $K$-medoids problem optimally. The ideas and techniques developed in this work could also lead to breakthroughs in other challenging combinatorial optimization problems. Overall, this is a valuable contribution that expands the capabilities of data analysis tools and pushes the field forward.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🔍

EKM: An exact, polynomial-time algorithm for the $K$-medoids problem

Xi He, Max A. Little

The $K$-medoids problem is a challenging combinatorial clustering task, widely used in data analysis applications. While numerous algorithms have been proposed to solve this problem, none of these are able to obtain an exact (globally optimal) solution for the problem in polynomial time. In this paper, we present EKM: a novel algorithm for solving this problem exactly with worst-case $Oleft(N^{K+1}right)$ time complexity. EKM is developed according to recent advances in transformational programming and combinatorial generation, using formal program derivation steps. The derived algorithm is provably correct by construction. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our algorithm by comparing it against various approximate methods on numerous real-world datasets. We show that the wall-clock run time of our algorithm matches the worst-case time complexity analysis on synthetic datasets, clearly outperforming the exponential time complexity of benchmark branch-and-bound based MIP solvers. To our knowledge, this is the first, rigorously-proven polynomial time, practical algorithm for this ubiquitous problem.

5/22/2024

🔍

Almost-linear Time Approximation Algorithm to Euclidean $k$-median and $k$-means

Max Dupr'e la Tour, David Saulpic

Clustering is one of the staples of data analysis and unsupervised learning. As such, clustering algorithms are often used on massive data sets, and they need to be extremely fast. We focus on the Euclidean $k$-median and $k$-means problems, two of the standard ways to model the task of clustering. For these, the go-to algorithm is $k$-means++, which yields an $O(log k)$-approximation in time $tilde O(nkd)$. While it is possible to improve either the approximation factor [Lattanzi and Sohler, ICML19] or the running time [Cohen-Addad et al., NeurIPS 20], it is unknown how precise a linear-time algorithm can be. In this paper, we almost answer this question by presenting an almost linear-time algorithm to compute a constant-factor approximation.

7/17/2024

Imbalanced Data Clustering using Equilibrium K-Means

Yudong He

Centroid-based clustering algorithms, such as hard K-means (HKM) and fuzzy K-means (FKM), have suffered from learning bias towards large clusters. Their centroids tend to be crowded in large clusters, compromising performance when the true underlying data groups vary in size (i.e., imbalanced data). To address this, we propose a new clustering objective function based on the Boltzmann operator, which introduces a novel centroid repulsion mechanism, where data points surrounding the centroids repel other centroids. Larger clusters repel more, effectively mitigating the issue of large cluster learning bias. The proposed new algorithm, called equilibrium K-means (EKM), is simple, alternating between two steps; resource-saving, with the same time and space complexity as FKM; and scalable to large datasets via batch learning. We substantially evaluate the performance of EKM on synthetic and real-world datasets. The results show that EKM performs competitively on balanced data and significantly outperforms benchmark algorithms on imbalanced data. Deep clustering experiments demonstrate that EKM is a better alternative to HKM and FKM on imbalanced data as more discriminative representation can be obtained. Additionally, we reformulate HKM, FKM, and EKM in a general form of gradient descent and demonstrate how this general form facilitates a uniform study of K-means algorithms.

6/7/2024

A Scalable k-Medoids Clustering via Whale Optimization Algorithm

Huang Chenan, Narumasa Tsutsumida

Unsupervised clustering has emerged as a critical tool for uncovering hidden patterns and insights from vast, unlabeled datasets. However, traditional methods like Partitioning Around Medoids (PAM) struggle with scalability due to their quadratic computational complexity. To address this limitation, we introduce WOA-kMedoids, a novel unsupervised clustering method that incorporates the Whale Optimization Algorithm (WOA), a nature-inspired metaheuristic inspired by the hunting strategies of humpback whales. By optimizing centroid selection, WOA-kMedoids reduces computational complexity of the k-medoids algorithm from quadratic to near-linear with respect to the number of observations. This improvement in efficiency enables WOA-kMedoids to be scalable to large datasets while maintaining high clustering accuracy. We evaluated the performance of WOA-kMedoids on 25 diverse time series datasets from the UCR archive. Our empirical results demonstrate that WOA-kMedoids maintains clustering accuracy similar to PAM. While WOA-kMedoids exhibited slightly higher runtime than PAM on small datasets (less than 300 observations), it outperformed PAM in computational efficiency on larger datasets. The scalability of WOA-kMedoids, combined with its consistently high accuracy, positions it as a promising and practical choice for unsupervised clustering in big data applications. WOA-kMedoids has implications for efficient knowledge discovery in massive, unlabeled datasets across various domains.

9/2/2024