ERR@HRI 2024 Challenge: Multimodal Detection of Errors and Failures in Human-Robot Interactions

Read original: arXiv:2407.06094 - Published 7/9/2024 by Micol Spitale, Maria Teresa Parreira, Maia Stiber, Minja Axelsson, Neval Kara, Garima Kankariya, Chien-Ming Huang, Malte Jung, Wendy Ju, Hatice Gunes

🔎

Overview

The ERR@HRI 2024 Challenge focuses on the multimodal detection of errors and failures in human-robot interactions.
The challenge aims to advance research in areas like affective computing, human-robot interaction, and robot failure detection.
Participants will work with a dataset containing multimodal data (e.g., audio, video, sensor data) captured during human-robot interactions.
The goal is to develop models that can accurately identify when an interaction has gone awry, whether due to human error, robot malfunction, or other issues.

Plain English Explanation

The ERR@HRI 2024 Challenge is a research competition that focuses on helping robots better understand when something has gone wrong during their interactions with humans. By using data from multiple sources, like audio, video, and sensors, the challenge participants will work to create AI models that can detect when an interaction is not going smoothly - whether it's because a human made a mistake, the robot malfunctioned, or some other problem occurred.

This is an important area of research for human-robot interaction and affective computing. If robots can better understand the emotional state and intentions of the humans they interact with, as well as identify potential issues or errors, they can respond more appropriately and safely. This could lead to more effective and robust human-robot interactions in a variety of settings, from homes to workplaces.

The challenge participants will have access to a dataset containing rich, multimodal data captured during real human-robot interactions. By analyzing this data, they can train their multimodal AI models to recognize the signs of an interaction going wrong. This could include things like changes in a person's tone of voice, facial expressions, body language, or the sensor readings from the robot itself.

Technical Explanation

The ERR@HRI 2024 Challenge is focused on the task of multimodal detection of errors and failures in human-robot interactions. Participants will work with a dataset containing multimodal data, including audio, video, and sensor readings, captured during real interactions between people and robots.

The goal is to develop AI models that can accurately identify when an interaction has encountered issues, whether due to human error, robot malfunction, or other problems. This requires integrating and analyzing signals from multiple modalities to build a comprehensive understanding of the interaction dynamics.

Some of the key technical approaches that may be explored by participants include:

Using social cues to recognize task failures: Analyzing human behaviors like facial expressions, gestures, and language to detect when an interaction is not going as planned.
Learning multimodal confidence and intention recognition: Developing models that can jointly process audio, visual, and other sensor data to infer the human's emotional state and intended actions.
Combining multiple modalities to communicate: Exploring how robots can leverage different communication channels, like speech and body language, to better convey information and respond to humans.
Robustness testing of multimodal models: Ensuring that the developed models can handle the diversity and variability of real-world human-robot interactions.
Leveraging large language models and multimodal architectures to tackle the challenge's complex, multifaceted requirements.

Critical Analysis

The ERR@HRI 2024 Challenge addresses an important and challenging problem in the field of human-robot interaction. Accurately detecting errors and failures in these interactions is crucial for ensuring safe, effective, and trustworthy collaboration between humans and robots.

One potential limitation of the challenge is the scope and diversity of the dataset. While the organizers aim to provide a rich, multimodal dataset, it may not capture the full range of human-robot interactions and error scenarios that could occur in real-world settings. Careful consideration should be given to the dataset's representativeness and potential biases.

Additionally, the challenge focuses primarily on the detection of errors and failures, but does not explicitly address the equally important task of

recovering

from such situations. Developing robust error recovery mechanisms would be a valuable extension to this work, as it could help create more resilient and adaptable human-robot systems.

Further research could also explore ways to

prevent

errors and failures in the first place, through improved robot design, better task planning, or more effective human-robot communication and coordination. This proactive approach could complement the reactive error detection capabilities developed in the challenge.

Overall, the ERR@HRI 2024 Challenge is a valuable contribution to the field of human-robot interaction, and the insights and techniques developed by participants could have significant implications for the design and deployment of future robotic systems.

Conclusion

The ERR@HRI 2024 Challenge is an important research initiative that aims to advance the state-of-the-art in multimodal detection of errors and failures in human-robot interactions. By leveraging rich, multimodal datasets and innovative AI techniques, participants will work to create models that can accurately identify when something has gone wrong during an interaction, whether due to human error, robot malfunction, or other issues.

This research has the potential to lead to more robust, adaptive, and trustworthy human-robot collaborations across a variety of applications, from home assistance to industrial settings. By better understanding the dynamics of these interactions and the factors that can lead to problems, researchers can develop more effective strategies for ensuring safe and reliable human-robot teamwork.

While the challenge has some limitations in terms of dataset scope and error recovery, it represents a significant step forward in the field of human-robot interaction. The insights and techniques developed by participants could pave the way for the next generation of intelligent, adaptive, and intuitive robotic systems that can seamlessly integrate with and support human users.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🔎

ERR@HRI 2024 Challenge: Multimodal Detection of Errors and Failures in Human-Robot Interactions

Micol Spitale, Maria Teresa Parreira, Maia Stiber, Minja Axelsson, Neval Kara, Garima Kankariya, Chien-Ming Huang, Malte Jung, Wendy Ju, Hatice Gunes

Despite the recent advancements in robotics and machine learning (ML), the deployment of autonomous robots in our everyday lives is still an open challenge. This is due to multiple reasons among which are their frequent mistakes, such as interrupting people or having delayed responses, as well as their limited ability to understand human speech, i.e., failure in tasks like transcribing speech to text. These mistakes may disrupt interactions and negatively influence human perception of these robots. To address this problem, robots need to have the ability to detect human-robot interaction (HRI) failures. The ERR@HRI 2024 challenge tackles this by offering a benchmark multimodal dataset of robot failures during human-robot interactions (HRI), encouraging researchers to develop and benchmark multimodal machine learning models to detect these failures. We created a dataset featuring multimodal non-verbal interaction data, including facial, speech, and pose features from video clips of interactions with a robotic coach, annotated with labels indicating the presence or absence of robot mistakes, user awkwardness, and interaction ruptures, allowing for the training and evaluation of predictive models. Challenge participants have been invited to submit their multimodal ML models for detection of robot errors and to be evaluated against various performance metrics such as accuracy, precision, recall, F1 score, with and without a margin of error reflecting the time-sensitivity of these metrics. The results of this challenge will help the research field in better understanding the robot failures in human-robot interactions and designing autonomous robots that can mitigate their own errors after successfully detecting them.

7/9/2024

👁️

Using Social Cues to Recognize Task Failures for HRI: Framework, Overview, State-of-the-Art, and Future Directions

Alexandra Bremers, Alexandria Pabst, Maria Teresa Parreira, Wendy Ju

Robots that carry out tasks and interact in complex environments will inevitably commit errors. Error detection is thus an essential ability for robots to master to work efficiently and productively. People can leverage social feedback to get an indication of whether an action was successful or not. With advances in computing and artificial intelligence (AI), it is increasingly possible for robots to achieve a similar capability of collecting social feedback. In this work, we take this one step further and propose a framework for how social cues can be used as feedback signals to recognize task failures for human-robot interaction (HRI). Our proposed framework sets out a research agenda based on insights from the literature on behavioral science, human-robot interaction, and machine learning to focus on three areas: 1) social cues as feedback (from behavioral science), 2) recognizing task failures in robots (from HRI), and 3) approaches for autonomous detection of HRI task failures based on social cues (from machine learning). We propose a taxonomy of error detection based on self-awareness and social feedback. Finally, we provide recommendations for HRI researchers and practitioners interested in developing robots that detect task errors using human social cues. This article is intended for interdisciplinary HRI researchers and practitioners, where the third theme of our analysis provides more technical details aiming toward the practical implementation of these systems.

5/30/2024

👁️

Learning Multimodal Confidence for Intention Recognition in Human-Robot Interaction

Xiyuan Zhao, Huijun Li, Tianyuan Miao, Xianyi Zhu, Zhikai Wei, Aiguo Song

The rapid development of collaborative robotics has provided a new possibility of helping the elderly who has difficulties in daily life, allowing robots to operate according to specific intentions. However, efficient human-robot cooperation requires natural, accurate and reliable intention recognition in shared environments. The current paramount challenge for this is reducing the uncertainty of multimodal fused intention to be recognized and reasoning adaptively a more reliable result despite current interactive condition. In this work we propose a novel learning-based multimodal fusion framework Batch Multimodal Confidence Learning for Opinion Pool (BMCLOP). Our approach combines Bayesian multimodal fusion method and batch confidence learning algorithm to improve accuracy, uncertainty reduction and success rate given the interactive condition. In particular, the generic and practical multimodal intention recognition framework can be easily extended further. Our desired assistive scenarios consider three modalities gestures, speech and gaze, all of which produce categorical distributions over all the finite intentions. The proposed method is validated with a six-DoF robot through extensive experiments and exhibits high performance compared to baselines.

5/24/2024

Detection of Unknown Errors in Human-Centered Systems

Aranyak Maity, Ayan Banerjee, Sandeep Gupta

Artificial Intelligence-enabled systems are increasingly being deployed in real-world safety-critical settings involving human participants. It is vital to ensure the safety of such systems and stop the evolution of the system with error before causing harm to human participants. We propose a model-agnostic approach to detecting unknown errors in such human-centered systems without requiring any knowledge about the error signatures. Our approach employs dynamics-induced hybrid recurrent neural networks (DiH-RNN) for constructing physics-based models from operational data, coupled with conformal inference for assessing errors in the underlying model caused by violations of physical laws, thereby facilitating early detection of unknown errors before unsafe shifts in operational data distribution occur. We evaluate our framework on multiple real-world safety critical systems and show that our technique outperforms the existing state-of-the-art in detecting unknown errors.

7/30/2024