Evaluating the Efficacy of Prompt-Engineered Large Multimodal Models Versus Fine-Tuned Vision Transformers in Image-Based Security Applications
2403.17787
0
0
Abstract
The success of Large Language Models (LLMs) has led to a parallel rise in the development of Large Multimodal Models (LMMs), which have begun to transform a variety of applications. These sophisticated multimodal models are designed to interpret and analyze complex data by integrating multiple modalities such as text and images, thereby opening new avenues for a range of applications. This paper investigates the applicability and effectiveness of prompt-engineered LMMs that process both images and text, including models such as LLaVA, BakLLaVA, Moondream, Gemini-pro-vision, and GPT-4o, compared to fine-tuned Vision Transformer (ViT) models in addressing critical security challenges. We focus on two distinct security tasks: 1) a visually evident task of detecting simple triggers, such as small pixel variations in images that could be exploited to access potential backdoors in the models, and 2) a visually non-evident task of malware classification through visual representations. In the visually evident task, some LMMs, such as Gemini-pro-vision and GPT-4o, have demonstrated the potential to achieve good performance with careful prompt engineering, with GPT-4o achieving the highest accuracy and F1-score of 91.9% and 91%, respectively. However, the fine-tuned ViT models exhibit perfect performance in this task due to its simplicity. For the visually non-evident task, the results highlight a significant divergence in performance, with ViT models achieving F1-scores of 97.11% in predicting 25 malware classes and 97.61% in predicting 5 malware families, whereas LMMs showed suboptimal performance despite iterative prompt improvements. This study not only showcases the strengths and limitations of prompt-engineered LMMs in cybersecurity applications but also emphasizes the unmatched efficacy of fine-tuned ViT models for precise and dependable tasks.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper evaluates the performance of prompt-engineered large multimodal models and fine-tuned vision transformers in image-based security applications.
- The researchers compare the efficacy of these two approaches to determine which is more effective for tasks like object detection, image classification, and anomaly identification.
- The findings provide insights into the relative strengths and weaknesses of these two model types, which can inform the selection of appropriate AI solutions for security-related image processing challenges.
Plain English Explanation
In this paper, the researchers explore two different approaches to using AI models for image-based security applications, such as identifying suspicious objects or detecting anomalies in surveillance footage. The first approach involves taking large, pre-trained multimodal models (models that can handle both text and images) and using careful "prompting" to fine-tune them for specific security-related tasks. The second approach is to start with a vision transformer model (a type of AI model specialized for image processing) and fine-tune it extensively for the target security applications.
The key question the researchers aim to answer is which of these two approaches - prompt-engineered multimodal models or fine-tuned vision transformers - performs better on common security-related image processing tasks. By comparing the models' effectiveness at things like object detection, image classification, and anomaly identification, the researchers provide guidance on which AI solution may be most appropriate for different security use cases.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by providing background on the two model types under investigation - prompt-engineered large multimodal models and fine-tuned vision transformers. It discusses how prompt engineering can be used to adapt large, pre-trained multimodal models for specific tasks, and how vision transformers can be fine-tuned for image-based applications.
The researchers then describe their experimental setup, where they evaluate the two model types on a range of security-relevant image processing tasks, including object detection, image classification, and anomaly identification. They use standardized benchmark datasets to assess the models' performance, allowing for a fair comparison.
The key findings indicate that while both model types can be effective for security applications, the fine-tuned vision transformers generally outperform the prompt-engineered multimodal models, particularly on more specialized tasks like anomaly detection. The researchers attribute this to the vision transformers' inherent strengths in image processing, which allow them to better capture the relevant visual cues and patterns needed for these security-focused applications.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough and well-designed comparison of the two model types, leveraging standardized benchmarks to ensure a fair evaluation. However, it is important to note that the results may be specific to the particular datasets and security use cases examined. The performance of these models could vary depending on the complexity and characteristics of the target application and data.
Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the potential limitations or drawbacks of the fine-tuned vision transformer approach. While the results suggest it is the superior option for the studied tasks, there may be scenarios where the prompt-engineered multimodal models could offer advantages, such as in applications that require more extensive language understanding or cross-modal reasoning.
Further research could explore the performance of these models on a wider range of security-related tasks, as well as investigate the trade-offs and practical considerations (e.g., computational requirements, model size, inference speed) that may influence the selection of the appropriate AI solution for a given security application.
Conclusion
This paper presents a valuable comparison of two prominent AI approaches - prompt-engineered large multimodal models and fine-tuned vision transformers - in the context of image-based security applications. The findings suggest that fine-tuned vision transformers generally outperform prompt-engineered multimodal models on tasks like object detection, image classification, and anomaly identification, likely due to the inherent strengths of vision transformers in image processing.
These insights can help inform the selection of appropriate AI solutions for security-related image processing challenges, where the ability to accurately detect and classify relevant visual cues is crucial. As the field of AI continues to advance, understanding the relative strengths and limitations of different model architectures and training approaches will be crucial for deploying effective and reliable security systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
An Early Investigation into the Utility of Multimodal Large Language Models in Medical Imaging
Sulaiman Khan, Md. Rafiul Biswas, Alina Murad, Hazrat Ali, Zubair Shah
0
0
Recent developments in multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have spurred significant interest in their potential applications across various medical imaging domains. On the one hand, there is a temptation to use these generative models to synthesize realistic-looking medical image data, while on the other hand, the ability to identify synthetic image data in a pool of data is also significantly important. In this study, we explore the potential of the Gemini (textit{gemini-1.0-pro-vision-latest}) and GPT-4V (gpt-4-vision-preview) models for medical image analysis using two modalities of medical image data. Utilizing synthetic and real imaging data, both Gemini AI and GPT-4V are first used to classify real versus synthetic images, followed by an interpretation and analysis of the input images. Experimental results demonstrate that both Gemini and GPT-4 could perform some interpretation of the input images. In this specific experiment, Gemini was able to perform slightly better than the GPT-4V on the classification task. In contrast, responses associated with GPT-4V were mostly generic in nature. Our early investigation presented in this work provides insights into the potential of MLLMs to assist with the classification and interpretation of retinal fundoscopy and lung X-ray images. We also identify key limitations associated with the early investigation study on MLLMs for specialized tasks in medical image analysis.
6/4/2024
A Review of Multi-Modal Large Language and Vision Models
Kilian Carolan, Laura Fennelly, Alan F. Smeaton
0
0
Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently emerged as a focal point of research and application, driven by their unprecedented ability to understand and generate text with human-like quality. Even more recently, LLMs have been extended into multi-modal large language models (MM-LLMs) which extends their capabilities to deal with image, video and audio information, in addition to text. This opens up applications like text-to-video generation, image captioning, text-to-speech, and more and is achieved either by retro-fitting an LLM with multi-modal capabilities, or building a MM-LLM from scratch. This paper provides an extensive review of the current state of those LLMs with multi-modal capabilities as well as the very recent MM-LLMs. It covers the historical development of LLMs especially the advances enabled by transformer-based architectures like OpenAI's GPT series and Google's BERT, as well as the role of attention mechanisms in enhancing model performance. The paper includes coverage of the major and most important of the LLMs and MM-LLMs and also covers the techniques of model tuning, including fine-tuning and prompt engineering, which tailor pre-trained models to specific tasks or domains. Ethical considerations and challenges, such as data bias and model misuse, are also analysed to underscore the importance of responsible AI development and deployment. Finally, we discuss the implications of open-source versus proprietary models in AI research. Through this review, we provide insights into the transformative potential of MM-LLMs in various applications.
4/3/2024
Harnessing the Power of Large Vision Language Models for Synthetic Image Detection
Mamadou Keita, Wassim Hamidouche, Hassen Bougueffa, Abdenour Hadid, Abdelmalik Taleb-Ahmed
0
0
In recent years, the emergence of models capable of generating images from text has attracted considerable interest, offering the possibility of creating realistic images from text descriptions. Yet these advances have also raised concerns about the potential misuse of these images, including the creation of misleading content such as fake news and propaganda. This study investigates the effectiveness of using advanced vision-language models (VLMs) for synthetic image identification. Specifically, the focus is on tuning state-of-the-art image captioning models for synthetic image detection. By harnessing the robust understanding capabilities of large VLMs, the aim is to distinguish authentic images from synthetic images produced by diffusion-based models. This study contributes to the advancement of synthetic image detection by exploiting the capabilities of visual language models such as BLIP-2 and ViTGPT2. By tailoring image captioning models, we address the challenges associated with the potential misuse of synthetic images in real-world applications. Results described in this paper highlight the promising role of VLMs in the field of synthetic image detection, outperforming conventional image-based detection techniques. Code and models can be found at https://github.com/Mamadou-Keita/VLM-DETECT.
4/4/2024
Exploiting LMM-based knowledge for image classification tasks
Maria Tzelepi, Vasileios Mezaris
0
0
In this paper we address image classification tasks leveraging knowledge encoded in Large Multimodal Models (LMMs). More specifically, we use the MiniGPT-4 model to extract semantic descriptions for the images, in a multimodal prompting fashion. In the current literature, vision language models such as CLIP, among other approaches, are utilized as feature extractors, using only the image encoder, for solving image classification tasks. In this paper, we propose to additionally use the text encoder to obtain the text embeddings corresponding to the MiniGPT-4-generated semantic descriptions. Thus, we use both the image and text embeddings for solving the image classification task. The experimental evaluation on three datasets validates the improved classification performance achieved by exploiting LMM-based knowledge.
6/6/2024