Evaluation of data inconsistency for multi-modal sentiment analysis
2406.03004
0
0
Abstract
Emotion semantic inconsistency is an ubiquitous challenge in multi-modal sentiment analysis (MSA). MSA involves analyzing sentiment expressed across various modalities like text, audio, and videos. Each modality may convey distinct aspects of sentiment, due to subtle and nuanced expression of human beings, leading to inconsistency, which may hinder the prediction of artificial agents. In this work, we introduce a modality conflicting test set and assess the performance of both traditional multi-modal sentiment analysis models and multi-modal large language models (MLLMs). Our findings reveal significant performance degradation across traditional models when confronted with semantically conflicting data and point out the drawbacks of MLLMs when handling multi-modal emotion analysis. Our research presents a new challenge and offer valuable insights for the future development of sentiment analysis systems.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper evaluates data inconsistency issues in multi-modal sentiment analysis, which involves analyzing a person's sentiment (positive, negative, or neutral) based on their words, tone of voice, facial expressions, and other signals.
- The researchers constructed a new dataset called DiffEmo to study these challenges, which includes text, audio, and video data annotated with sentiment labels.
- They analyzed the dataset to understand the extent of data inconsistency, where the different modalities (text, audio, video) convey conflicting sentiment information for the same input.
- The findings provide insights into the challenges of building reliable multi-modal sentiment analysis systems.
Plain English Explanation
The paper looks at a problem called "data inconsistency" in multi-modal sentiment analysis. This means that when you try to analyze a person's feelings (positive, negative, or neutral) using a combination of what they say, how they say it, and how they look, the different sources of information don't always agree.
For example, someone's words might express a positive sentiment, but their tone of voice or facial expressions could suggest a negative sentiment. This inconsistency makes it difficult to accurately determine the person's true feelings.
To study this issue, the researchers created a new dataset called DiffEmo, which contains text, audio, and video data labeled with sentiment information. They then analyzed this dataset to understand how often these inconsistencies occur and what factors might contribute to them.
The insights from this work can help researchers and developers build better multi-modal sentiment analysis systems that can reliably interpret a person's emotions across different communication channels.
Technical Explanation
The paper focuses on the challenge of data inconsistency in multi-modal sentiment analysis. The researchers constructed a new dataset called DiffEmo, which includes text, audio, and video data annotated with sentiment labels.
By analyzing the DiffEmo dataset, the researchers aimed to understand the extent of data inconsistency in multi-modal sentiment analysis. They examined cases where the different modalities (text, audio, video) conveyed conflicting sentiment information for the same input.
The findings provide valuable insights into the challenges of building robust multi-modal sentiment analysis systems that can reliably interpret a person's emotions across various communication channels. This aligns with ongoing research in multi-modal fusion for sentiment analysis and trustworthy multi-modal sentiment analysis.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough investigation of data inconsistency issues in multi-modal sentiment analysis, which is a critical challenge in this field. By constructing the DiffEmo dataset and analyzing the extent of inconsistencies, the researchers have generated valuable insights that can inform future research and development efforts.
However, the paper does not delve into the potential root causes of these inconsistencies, such as modality-specific biases or annotation quality. Further research could explore these factors in more depth to better understand and mitigate the data inconsistency problem.
Additionally, the paper does not provide concrete solutions or recommendations for addressing the data inconsistency issue. Future work could focus on developing multi-modal fusion techniques or knowledge distillation approaches that can effectively handle conflicting signals across modalities.
Conclusion
This paper presents a comprehensive study of data inconsistency in multi-modal sentiment analysis, a critical challenge in the field. By constructing the DiffEmo dataset and analyzing the extent of inconsistencies, the researchers have generated valuable insights that can inform future research and development efforts.
The findings highlight the need for more robust and trustworthy multi-modal sentiment analysis systems that can reliably interpret a person's emotions across various communication channels. Continued work in this area, addressing root causes and exploring mitigation strategies, can lead to significant advancements in the field and enable more accurate and reliable sentiment analysis applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Multimodal Sentiment Analysis with Missing Modality: A Knowledge-Transfer Approach
Weide Liu, Huijing Zhan, Hao Chen, Fengmao Lv
0
0
Multimodal sentiment analysis aims to identify the emotions expressed by individuals through visual, language, and acoustic cues. However, most of the existing research efforts assume that all modalities are available during both training and testing, making their algorithms susceptible to the missing modality scenario. In this paper, we propose a novel knowledge-transfer network to translate between different modalities to reconstruct the missing audio modalities. Moreover, we develop a cross-modality attention mechanism to retain the maximal information of the reconstructed and observed modalities for sentiment prediction. Extensive experiments on three publicly available datasets demonstrate significant improvements over baselines and achieve comparable results to the previous methods with complete multi-modality supervision.
6/21/2024
Large Language Models Meet Text-Centric Multimodal Sentiment Analysis: A Survey
Hao Yang, Yanyan Zhao, Yang Wu, Shilong Wang, Tian Zheng, Hongbo Zhang, Wanxiang Che, Bing Qin
0
0
Compared to traditional sentiment analysis, which only considers text, multimodal sentiment analysis needs to consider emotional signals from multimodal sources simultaneously and is therefore more consistent with the way how humans process sentiment in real-world scenarios. It involves processing emotional information from various sources such as natural language, images, videos, audio, physiological signals, etc. However, although other modalities also contain diverse emotional cues, natural language usually contains richer contextual information and therefore always occupies a crucial position in multimodal sentiment analysis. The emergence of ChatGPT has opened up immense potential for applying large language models (LLMs) to text-centric multimodal tasks. However, it is still unclear how existing LLMs can adapt better to text-centric multimodal sentiment analysis tasks. This survey aims to (1) present a comprehensive review of recent research in text-centric multimodal sentiment analysis tasks, (2) examine the potential of LLMs for text-centric multimodal sentiment analysis, outlining their approaches, advantages, and limitations, (3) summarize the application scenarios of LLM-based multimodal sentiment analysis technology, and (4) explore the challenges and potential research directions for multimodal sentiment analysis in the future.
6/13/2024
M2SA: Multimodal and Multilingual Model for Sentiment Analysis of Tweets
Gaurish Thakkar, Sherzod Hakimov, Marko Tadi'c
0
0
In recent years, multimodal natural language processing, aimed at learning from diverse data types, has garnered significant attention. However, there needs to be more clarity when it comes to analysing multimodal tasks in multi-lingual contexts. While prior studies on sentiment analysis of tweets have predominantly focused on the English language, this paper addresses this gap by transforming an existing textual Twitter sentiment dataset into a multimodal format through a straightforward curation process. Our work opens up new avenues for sentiment-related research within the research community. Additionally, we conduct baseline experiments utilising this augmented dataset and report the findings. Notably, our evaluations reveal that when comparing unimodal and multimodal configurations, using a sentiment-tuned large language model as a text encoder performs exceptionally well.
6/13/2024
Trustworthy Multimodal Fusion for Sentiment Analysis in Ordinal Sentiment Space
Zhuyang Xie, Yan Yang, Jie Wang, Xiaorong Liu, Xiaofan Li
0
0
Multimodal video sentiment analysis aims to integrate multiple modal information to analyze the opinions and attitudes of speakers. Most previous work focuses on exploring the semantic interactions of intra- and inter-modality. However, these works ignore the reliability of multimodality, i.e., modalities tend to contain noise, semantic ambiguity, missing modalities, etc. In addition, previous multimodal approaches treat different modalities equally, largely ignoring their different contributions. Furthermore, existing multimodal sentiment analysis methods directly regress sentiment scores without considering ordinal relationships within sentiment categories, with limited performance. To address the aforementioned problems, we propose a trustworthy multimodal sentiment ordinal network (TMSON) to improve performance in sentiment analysis. Specifically, we first devise a unimodal feature extractor for each modality to obtain modality-specific features. Then, an uncertainty distribution estimation network is customized, which estimates the unimodal uncertainty distributions. Next, Bayesian fusion is performed on the learned unimodal distributions to obtain multimodal distributions for sentiment prediction. Finally, an ordinal-aware sentiment space is constructed, where ordinal regression is used to constrain the multimodal distributions. Our proposed TMSON outperforms baselines on multimodal sentiment analysis tasks, and empirical results demonstrate that TMSON is capable of reducing uncertainty to obtain more robust predictions.
4/16/2024