ExIFFI and EIF+: Interpretability and Enhanced Generalizability to Extend the Extended Isolation Forest
2310.05468
0
0
๐งช
Abstract
Anomaly Detection involves identifying unusual behaviors within complex datasets and systems. While Machine Learning algorithms and Decision Support Systems (DSSs) offer effective solutions for this task, simply pinpointing anomalies may prove insufficient in real-world applications. Users require insights into the rationale behind these predictions to facilitate root cause analysis and foster trust in the model. However, the unsupervised nature of AD presents a challenge in developing interpretable tools. This paper addresses this challenge by introducing ExIFFI, a novel interpretability approach specifically designed to explain the predictions made by Extended Isolation Forest. ExIFFI leverages feature importance to provide explanations at both global and local levels. This work also introduces EIF+, an enhanced variant of Extended Isolation Forest, conceived to improve its generalization capabilities through a different splitting hyperplanes design strategy. A comprehensive comparative analysis is conducted, employing both synthetic and real-world datasets to evaluate various unsupervised AD approaches. The analysis demonstrates the effectiveness of ExIFFI in providing explanations for AD predictions. Furthermore, the paper explores the utility of ExIFFI as a feature selection technique in unsupervised settings. Finally, this work contributes to the research community by providing open-source code, facilitating further investigation and reproducibility.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Anomaly Detection (AD) is the process of identifying unusual patterns or behaviors in complex datasets and systems.
- While Machine Learning (ML) algorithms and Decision Support Systems (DSSs) can effectively detect anomalies, users often require insights into the reasoning behind these predictions to facilitate root cause analysis and build trust in the model.
- Unsupervised nature of AD presents a challenge in developing interpretable tools.
- This paper introduces ExIFFI, a novel interpretability approach designed to explain the predictions made by Extended Isolation Forest (EIF).
- The paper also introduces EIF+, an enhanced variant of EIF with improved generalization capabilities.
Plain English Explanation
Anomaly Detection (AD) is like finding a needle in a haystack - it's the process of identifying unusual or unexpected patterns in complex data. While advanced algorithms and decision support systems can effectively locate these anomalies, it's not enough for users to just know that something is unusual. They also need to understand
The challenge is that AD often uses unsupervised machine learning, where the system learns patterns on its own without being explicitly trained. This makes it harder to develop tools that can explain the reasoning behind the anomaly detections.
To address this, the researchers in this paper created a new interpretability approach called ExIFFI. ExIFFI is designed to provide explanations for the anomaly predictions made by a specific algorithm called Extended Isolation Forest (EIF). The paper also introduces an enhanced version of EIF, called EIF+, which is better at generalizing to different types of data.
The key idea is to use feature importance - understanding which data attributes most influenced the anomaly detection - to explain the model's reasoning at both a global level (across all predictions) and a local level (for individual predictions). This helps users understand why the system flagged certain data points as anomalies, which is crucial for trust and further investigation.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces ExIFFI, a novel interpretability approach specifically designed to explain the predictions made by Extended Isolation Forest (EIF), an unsupervised Anomaly Detection (AD) algorithm. ExIFFI leverages feature importance to provide explanations at both global and local levels, addressing the challenge of developing interpretable tools for unsupervised AD.
The paper also introduces EIF+, an enhanced variant of EIF, conceived to improve its generalization capabilities through a different splitting hyperplanes design strategy. A comprehensive comparative analysis is conducted, using both synthetic and real-world datasets, to evaluate the performance of various unsupervised AD approaches.
The analysis demonstrates the effectiveness of ExIFFI in providing explanations for AD predictions. Furthermore, the paper explores the utility of ExIFFI as a feature selection technique in unsupervised settings. The work contributes to the research community by providing open-source code, facilitating further investigation and reproducibility.
Critical Analysis
The paper addresses an important challenge in Anomaly Detection (AD) - the need for interpretable tools that can provide insights into the reasoning behind model predictions. By introducing ExIFFI, the researchers have developed a promising approach to explain the outputs of the Extended Isolation Forest (EIF) algorithm.
One potential limitation mentioned in the paper is the need to further investigate the scalability of ExIFFI as the dataset size and complexity increase. Additionally, the paper does not explore the impact of feature importance-based explanations on user trust and decision-making in real-world AD applications. Further research in this direction would be valuable.
Another paper has explored the trade-offs between model accuracy, interpretability, and privacy in AD systems, which could provide additional insights and considerations for the ExIFFI approach.
The paper also does not directly address the challenge of feature importance estimation faithfulness - ensuring that the feature importance values accurately reflect the true contribution of each feature to the model's predictions. This is an active area of research that could be explored in the context of ExIFFI and unsupervised AD.
Overall, the paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of Anomaly Detection by introducing a novel interpretability approach and an enhanced algorithm variant. Further research and real-world testing could help refine and strengthen the proposed solutions.
Conclusion
This paper addresses a crucial challenge in Anomaly Detection (AD) by introducing ExIFFI, a novel interpretability approach designed to explain the predictions made by the Extended Isolation Forest (EIF) algorithm. The paper also presents EIF+, an enhanced variant of EIF with improved generalization capabilities.
The key contribution of this work is the development of a tool that can provide insights into the reasoning behind AD model outputs, which is essential for facilitating root cause analysis, building user trust, and fostering the adoption of these systems in real-world applications. The comprehensive evaluation using synthetic and real-world datasets demonstrates the effectiveness of ExIFFI in delivering explanations for AD predictions.
Moreover, the paper explores the potential of ExIFFI as a feature selection technique in unsupervised settings, further expanding its utility. By providing open-source code, the researchers have enabled the research community to build upon this work, driving further advancements in interpretable Anomaly Detection.
As AI systems become increasingly prevalent in complex data analysis and decision-making, the need for transparent and explainable models will only grow. The innovations presented in this paper represent an important step towards bridging the gap between the powerful capabilities of Anomaly Detection and the human-centric requirements of real-world applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Interpretable Data-driven Anomaly Detection in Industrial Processes with ExIFFI
Davide Frizzo, Francesco Borsatti, Alessio Arcudi, Antonio De Moliner, Roberto Oboe, Gian Antonio Susto
0
0
Anomaly detection (AD) is a crucial process often required in industrial settings. Anomalies can signal underlying issues within a system, prompting further investigation. Industrial processes aim to streamline operations as much as possible, encompassing the production of the final product, making AD an essential mean to reach this goal.Conventional anomaly detection methodologies typically classify observations as either normal or anomalous without providing insight into the reasons behind these classifications.Consequently, in light of the emergence of Industry 5.0, a more desirable approach involves providing interpretable outcomes, enabling users to understand the rationale behind the results.This paper presents the first industrial application of ExIFFI, a recently developed approach focused on the production of fast and efficient explanations for the Extended Isolation Forest (EIF) Anomaly detection method. ExIFFI is tested on two publicly available industrial datasets demonstrating superior effectiveness in explanations and computational efficiency with the respect to other state-of-the-art explainable AD models.
5/3/2024
Explainable AI Integrated Feature Engineering for Wildfire Prediction
Di Fan, Ayan Biswas, James Paul Ahrens
0
0
Wildfires present intricate challenges for prediction, necessitating the use of sophisticated machine learning techniques for effective modelingcite{jain2020review}. In our research, we conducted a thorough assessment of various machine learning algorithms for both classification and regression tasks relevant to predicting wildfires. We found that for classifying different types or stages of wildfires, the XGBoost model outperformed others in terms of accuracy and robustness. Meanwhile, the Random Forest regression model showed superior results in predicting the extent of wildfire-affected areas, excelling in both prediction error and explained variance. Additionally, we developed a hybrid neural network model that integrates numerical data and image information for simultaneous classification and regression. To gain deeper insights into the decision-making processes of these models and identify key contributing features, we utilized eXplainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) techniques, including TreeSHAP, LIME, Partial Dependence Plots (PDP), and Gradient-weighted Class Activation Mapping (Grad-CAM). These interpretability tools shed light on the significance and interplay of various features, highlighting the complex factors influencing wildfire predictions. Our study not only demonstrates the effectiveness of specific machine learning models in wildfire-related tasks but also underscores the critical role of model transparency and interpretability in environmental science applications.
4/3/2024
Fiper: a Visual-based Explanation Combining Rules and Feature Importance
Eleonora Cappuccio, Daniele Fadda, Rosa Lanzilotti, Salvatore Rinzivillo
0
0
Artificial Intelligence algorithms have now become pervasive in multiple high-stakes domains. However, their internal logic can be obscure to humans. Explainable Artificial Intelligence aims to design tools and techniques to illustrate the predictions of the so-called black-box algorithms. The Human-Computer Interaction community has long stressed the need for a more user-centered approach to Explainable AI. This approach can benefit from research in user interface, user experience, and visual analytics. This paper proposes a visual-based method to illustrate rules paired with feature importance. A user study with 15 participants was conducted comparing our visual method with the original output of the algorithm and textual representation to test its effectiveness with users.
4/29/2024
โจ
Feature graphs for interpretable unsupervised tree ensembles: centrality, interaction, and application in disease subtyping
Christel Sirocchi, Martin Urschler, Bastian Pfeifer
0
0
Interpretable machine learning has emerged as central in leveraging artificial intelligence within high-stakes domains such as healthcare, where understanding the rationale behind model predictions is as critical as achieving high predictive accuracy. In this context, feature selection assumes a pivotal role in enhancing model interpretability by identifying the most important input features in black-box models. While random forests are frequently used in biomedicine for their remarkable performance on tabular datasets, the accuracy gained from aggregating decision trees comes at the expense of interpretability. Consequently, feature selection for enhancing interpretability in random forests has been extensively explored in supervised settings. However, its investigation in the unsupervised regime remains notably limited. To address this gap, the study introduces novel methods to construct feature graphs from unsupervised random forests and feature selection strategies to derive effective feature combinations from these graphs. Feature graphs are constructed for the entire dataset as well as individual clusters leveraging the parent-child node splits within the trees, such that feature centrality captures their relevance to the clustering task, while edge weights reflect the discriminating power of feature pairs. Graph-based feature selection methods are extensively evaluated on synthetic and benchmark datasets both in terms of their ability to reduce dimensionality while improving clustering performance, as well as to enhance model interpretability. An application on omics data for disease subtyping identifies the top features for each cluster, showcasing the potential of the proposed approach to enhance interpretability in clustering analyses and its utility in a real-world biomedical application.
4/30/2024