Feature graphs for interpretable unsupervised tree ensembles: centrality, interaction, and application in disease subtyping

Overview

• Interpretable machine learning is crucial in high-stakes domains like healthcare, where understanding model reasoning is as important as predictive accuracy.
• Feature selection plays a pivotal role in enhancing the interpretability of black-box models like random forests, which are widely used in biomedicine.
• While feature selection for interpretability in supervised random forests has been extensively explored, its investigation in the unsupervised regime remains limited.

Plain English Explanation

Artificial intelligence (AI) is being used in more and more important areas like healthcare, where it makes decisions that can greatly impact people's lives. In these high-stakes domains, it's not enough for an AI model to just make accurate predictions - we also need to understand the reasons behind its decisions. This is where interpretable machine learning comes into play.

One key aspect of making AI models more interpretable is feature selection - identifying the most important input features that drive the model's predictions. This is particularly relevant for complex models like random forests, which are widely used in fields like biomedicine. While random forests are known for their excellent predictive performance, their inner workings can be hard to understand.

The researchers in this study wanted to address the challenge of making unsupervised random forests (where the model groups data without a known target variable) more interpretable. They developed new methods to analyze the structure of these unsupervised models and identify the most important features for the clustering task. This can help researchers better understand the patterns in their data and draw more meaningful insights, especially in real-world applications like disease subtyping using omics data.

Technical Explanation

The study introduces novel methods to construct feature graphs from unsupervised random forests and feature selection strategies to derive effective feature combinations from these graphs. Feature graphs are built for the entire dataset as well as individual clusters, leveraging the parent-child node splits within the trees. In these graphs, feature centrality captures a feature's relevance to the clustering task, while edge weights reflect the discriminating power of feature pairs.

The researchers extensively evaluate their graph-based feature selection methods on synthetic and benchmark datasets. They assess the methods' ability to reduce dimensionality while improving clustering performance, as well as their potential to enhance model interpretability. An application on omics data for disease subtyping showcases how the proposed approach can identify the top features driving the clustering, demonstrating its utility in a real-world biomedical setting.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and promising approach to enhancing the interpretability of unsupervised random forests, which are widely used in domains like healthcare and biomedicine. By constructing feature graphs and leveraging graph-based feature selection, the researchers have developed a systematic way to identify the most important input features underlying the clustering results.

One potential limitation is that the evaluation is primarily focused on clustering performance and dimensionality reduction, rather than directly assessing the interpretability of the models. While the case study on disease subtyping provides an example of how the method can be used to derive interpretable insights, a more comprehensive user study or comparison to other interpretability techniques such as VisRuler would further strengthen the claims about the approach's ability to improve model interpretability.

Additionally, the researchers mention that their method assumes the availability of a full dataset for graph construction. It would be valuable to explore how the approach could be adapted to federated learning settings, where data is distributed across multiple sites and a centralized model needs to be interpretable.

Conclusion

This study presents a novel and promising approach to enhancing the interpretability of unsupervised random forests, a widely used class of models in high-stakes domains like healthcare and biomedicine. By constructing feature graphs and leveraging graph-based feature selection, the researchers have developed a systematic way to identify the most important input features driving the clustering results.

The methods are extensively evaluated on synthetic and benchmark datasets, demonstrating their ability to improve clustering performance while also providing insights into the underlying model structure. The real-world application on disease subtyping using omics data further showcases the potential of the proposed approach to derive interpretable insights from complex data.

While the study focuses primarily on clustering performance and dimensionality reduction, the findings suggest that the graph-based feature selection techniques can be a valuable tool for improving the interpretability of unsupervised machine learning models, particularly in domains where understanding the rationale behind model predictions is of critical importance.