An Experimental Design for Anytime-Valid Causal Inference on Multi-Armed Bandits

Overview

• The paper introduces a new experimental design called the Mixture Adaptive Design (MAD) for multi-armed bandit (MAB) experiments.
• MAD allows for continuous inference on the average treatment effect (ATE) between arms as new data arrives, and can determine a data-driven stopping time for the experiment.
• MAD can be used with any bandit algorithm, even those without probabilistic treatment assignment.
• MAD is proven to generate anytime-valid asymptotic confidence sequences that shrink around the true ATE, and its regret approaches that of the underlying bandit algorithm over time.

Plain English Explanation

The paper presents a new approach for running multi-armed bandit (MAB) experiments, which are used to test the performance of different "arms" or options in a decision-making task. In these experiments, it's often useful to continuously monitor the average difference in performance between the arms (the average treatment effect or ATE) and decide when to stop the experiment based on the data.

The authors develop a technique called the Mixture Adaptive Design (MAD) that allows for this type of anytime inference on the ATE. MAD works by combining any bandit algorithm of the experimenter's choosing (e.g., a bandit algorithm from this paper) with a simpler "Bernoulli" design that ensures statistical validity.

The key idea is that MAD gradually reduces the influence of the Bernoulli design over time, so that the experiment's performance approaches that of the underlying bandit algorithm. Importantly, the authors prove that this approach provides guaranteed statistical guarantees - specifically, that the confidence intervals for the ATE will converge to the true value in the long run, and that any true non-zero treatment effect will be detected in finite time.

This is a powerful result, as it allows experimenters to use advanced bandit algorithms that may not have built-in statistical properties, while still obtaining reliable inferences. The authors also show through simulations that MAD achieves these inferential benefits without significant losses in the actual rewards collected during the experiment.

Technical Explanation

The key technical innovation of the paper is the Mixture Adaptive Design (MAD), a new experimental design for multi-armed bandit (MAB) problems. Traditionally, MAB experiments have focused on maximizing the cumulative reward (or minimizing regret) collected during the experiment, without providing guarantees on the statistical inference for the average treatment effect (ATE) between arms.

MAD addresses this gap by combining any bandit algorithm of the experimenter's choosing with a Bernoulli design that ensures anytime-valid statistical inference. Specifically, MAD uses a tuning parameter δ_t that gradually decreases the priority placed on the Bernoulli design as the sample size grows. The authors prove that for δ_t = Ω(t^(-1/4)), this approach generates anytime-valid asymptotic confidence sequences that are guaranteed to shrink around the true ATE.

This means that experimenters can use powerful bandit algorithms to maximize rewards, while also being able to continuously monitor and make reliable inferences about the underlying ATE. The authors further show that the regret of the MAD approach approaches that of the underlying bandit algorithm over time, incurring only a small loss in reward in exchange for the strong inferential guarantees.

The authors validate these theoretical results through an extensive simulation study, demonstrating that MAD achieves finite-sample anytime validity and high power without significant losses in finite-sample reward. This makes MAD a promising tool for multi-agent and combinatorial bandit problems where reliable inference is important alongside reward maximization.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a strong contribution by addressing the tension between reward maximization and statistical inference in multi-armed bandit experiments. The Mixture Adaptive Design (MAD) is a clever approach that allows experimenters to leverage advanced bandit algorithms while still obtaining reliable inferences about the average treatment effect (ATE).

One potential limitation is that the theoretical guarantees for MAD rely on the δ_t tuning parameter decreasing at a specific rate (Ω(t^(-1/4))). In practice, experimenters may need to carefully tune this parameter to balance the tradeoffs between inference and regret minimization. The authors acknowledge this as an area for future research, possibly exploring adaptive tuning approaches that could further improve the practical performance of MAD.

Additionally, the paper focuses on asymptotic guarantees, and the finite-sample performance of MAD, while shown to be promising in simulations, may depend on the specific problem context and the underlying bandit algorithm used. Exploring the robustness of MAD to different problem settings and algorithms could be a fruitful direction for further inquiry.

Overall, the Mixture Adaptive Design represents an important step forward in reconciling the competing objectives of reward maximization and statistical inference in multi-armed bandit experiments. The strong theoretical guarantees and simulation results suggest that MAD could be a valuable tool for researchers and practitioners working in this domain.

Conclusion

The paper introduces the Mixture Adaptive Design (MAD), a new experimental design for multi-armed bandit (MAB) problems that allows for continuous inference on the average treatment effect (ATE) between arms. MAD achieves this by combining any bandit algorithm of the experimenter's choice with a Bernoulli design, gradually reducing the influence of the Bernoulli component over time.

The authors prove that this approach generates anytime-valid asymptotic confidence sequences that converge to the true ATE, and that it incurs only a small loss in regret compared to the underlying bandit algorithm. These powerful theoretical guarantees, along with the simulation results showing strong finite-sample performance, make MAD a promising tool for researchers and practitioners working on multi-armed bandit problems where both reward maximization and reliable statistical inference are important.