Explore until Confident: Efficient Exploration for Embodied Question Answering

Read original: arXiv:2403.15941 - Published 7/9/2024 by Allen Z. Ren, Jaden Clark, Anushri Dixit, Masha Itkina, Anirudha Majumdar, Dorsa Sadigh
Total Score

0

Explore until Confident: Efficient Exploration for Embodied Question Answering

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper introduces a new approach for efficient exploration in embodied question answering tasks.
  • The authors propose a method called "Explore until Confident" (EuC) that aims to intelligently explore the environment to answer questions with high confidence.
  • EuC leverages a map-based modular architecture to reason about the environment and plan exploration strategies.
  • The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of EuC on several embodied question answering benchmarks.

Plain English Explanation

The paper tackles the challenge of efficiently exploring virtual environments to answer questions. In these tasks, an AI agent is placed in a 3D environment and must navigate around to gather information needed to answer a specific question.

The key idea behind the "Explore until Confident" (EuC) approach is to have the agent explore the environment in a strategic way, rather than randomly wandering around. EuC uses a map-based system to build an understanding of the environment and plan efficient exploration paths. This allows the agent to focus its exploration on areas that are most likely to contain the information needed to answer the question, rather than wasting time in irrelevant parts of the environment.

By intelligently exploring the environment, EuC is able to answer questions more accurately and with greater confidence compared to previous methods. This is important because in real-world applications, we often want AI systems that can provide reliable and trustworthy answers, rather than guessing blindly.

The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of EuC on several standard benchmarks for embodied question answering. The results show that EuC outperforms other exploration strategies, highlighting the value of this more strategic and informed approach to exploration.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces a new method called "Explore until Confident" (EuC) for efficient exploration in embodied question answering tasks. EuC leverages a map-based modular approach to reason about the environment and plan exploration strategies.

The key components of EuC are:

  1. Spatial Reasoning Module: This module builds and maintains a spatial map of the environment to represent the agent's understanding of its surroundings.
  2. Exploration Policy: The exploration policy decides where the agent should navigate to gather more information to answer the question. It uses the spatial map to identify promising areas to explore.
  3. Question Answering Module: This module takes in the agent's observations and the question to predict an answer. The exploration policy is guided by the confidence of this module.

The core idea of EuC is to intelligently explore the environment, focusing on areas that are most likely to contain the information needed to answer the question. This is in contrast to previous approaches that relied on more random or heuristic exploration strategies, such as S-EQA or Embodied Agents.

The paper evaluates EuC on several embodied question answering benchmarks, including ALFRED and LOVA3. The results demonstrate that EuC outperforms previous exploration strategies, achieving higher answer accuracy and confidence.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling approach to efficient exploration for embodied question answering, but there are a few potential limitations and areas for future research:

  1. Scalability to larger environments: The paper evaluates EuC on relatively small-scale environments. It would be valuable to see how the method scales to larger, more complex environments that may require more sophisticated spatial reasoning and exploration strategies.

  2. Generalization to unseen environments: The paper focuses on performance within the training environments. It would be important to assess how well EuC can generalize to novel environments that the agent has not encountered during training.

  3. Incorporation of additional modalities: The current implementation of EuC relies primarily on visual information. Expanding the system to incorporate other sensory modalities, such as audio or tactile feedback, could further improve its ability to understand the environment and answer questions.

  4. Interpretability and transparency: While the map-based modular approach provides a degree of interpretability, it would be valuable to further investigate ways to make the agent's exploration and reasoning process more transparent and explainable to human users.

Overall, the "Explore until Confident" method presents a promising step towards more efficient and effective exploration in embodied question answering tasks. Addressing the above limitations could lead to even more robust and versatile systems for this important problem.

Conclusion

The "Explore until Confident" (EuC) approach introduced in this paper represents an important advancement in the field of embodied question answering. By leveraging a map-based modular architecture to reason about the environment and plan strategic exploration, EuC is able to outperform previous exploration strategies and answer questions with higher accuracy and confidence.

The key contribution of this work is the insight that intelligent, targeted exploration is crucial for achieving reliable and trustworthy answers in these types of embodied tasks. By focusing exploration on the most relevant areas of the environment, EuC demonstrates the potential for AI systems to engage in more efficient and effective information gathering, ultimately leading to better decision-making and problem-solving capabilities.

As the field of embodied AI continues to evolve, approaches like EuC will be increasingly important for developing agents that can robustly navigate and interact with complex, real-world environments. The insights and techniques presented in this paper represent an important step towards realizing the full potential of embodied AI systems.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Explore until Confident: Efficient Exploration for Embodied Question Answering
Total Score

0

Explore until Confident: Efficient Exploration for Embodied Question Answering

Allen Z. Ren, Jaden Clark, Anushri Dixit, Masha Itkina, Anirudha Majumdar, Dorsa Sadigh

We consider the problem of Embodied Question Answering (EQA), which refers to settings where an embodied agent such as a robot needs to actively explore an environment to gather information until it is confident about the answer to a question. In this work, we leverage the strong semantic reasoning capabilities of large vision-language models (VLMs) to efficiently explore and answer such questions. However, there are two main challenges when using VLMs in EQA: they do not have an internal memory for mapping the scene to be able to plan how to explore over time, and their confidence can be miscalibrated and can cause the robot to prematurely stop exploration or over-explore. We propose a method that first builds a semantic map of the scene based on depth information and via visual prompting of a VLM - leveraging its vast knowledge of relevant regions of the scene for exploration. Next, we use conformal prediction to calibrate the VLM's question answering confidence, allowing the robot to know when to stop exploration - leading to a more calibrated and efficient exploration strategy. To test our framework in simulation, we also contribute a new EQA dataset with diverse, realistic human-robot scenarios and scenes built upon the Habitat-Matterport 3D Research Dataset (HM3D). Both simulated and real robot experiments show our proposed approach improves the performance and efficiency over baselines that do no leverage VLM for exploration or do not calibrate its confidence. Webpage with experiment videos and code: https://explore-eqa.github.io/

Read more

7/9/2024

🧠

Total Score

0

Map-based Modular Approach for Zero-shot Embodied Question Answering

Koya Sakamoto, Daichi Azuma, Taiki Miyanishi, Shuhei Kurita, Motoaki Kawanabe

Building robots capable of interacting with humans through natural language in the visual world presents a significant challenge in the field of robotics. To overcome this challenge, Embodied Question Answering (EQA) has been proposed as a benchmark task to measure the ability to identify an object navigating through a previously unseen environment in response to human-posed questions. Although some methods have been proposed, their evaluations have been limited to simulations, without experiments in real-world scenarios. Furthermore, all of these methods are constrained by a limited vocabulary for question-and-answer interactions, making them unsuitable for practical applications. In this work, we propose a map-based modular EQA method that enables real robots to navigate unknown environments through frontier-based map creation and address unknown QA pairs using foundation models that support open vocabulary. Unlike the questions of the previous EQA dataset on Matterport 3D (MP3D), questions in our real-world experiments contain various question formats and vocabularies not included in the training data. We conduct comprehensive experiments on virtual environments (MP3D-EQA) and two real-world house environments and demonstrate that our method can perform EQA even in the real world.

Read more

5/28/2024

Embodied Question Answering via Multi-LLM Systems
Total Score

0

Embodied Question Answering via Multi-LLM Systems

Bhrij Patel, Vishnu Sashank Dorbala, Amrit Singh Bedi, Dinesh Manocha

Embodied Question Answering (EQA) is an important problem, which involves an agent exploring the environment to answer user queries. In the existing literature, EQA has exclusively been studied in single-agent scenarios, where exploration can be time-consuming and costly. In this work, we consider EQA in a multi-agent framework involving multiple large language models (LLM) based agents independently answering queries about a household environment. To generate one answer for each query, we use the individual responses to train a Central Answer Model (CAM) that aggregates responses for a robust answer. While prior Question Answering (QA) work has used a central module based on answers from multiple LLM-based experts, we specifically look at applying this framework to embodied LLM-based agents that must physically explore the environment first to become experts on their given environment to answer questions. Our work is the first to utilize a central answer model framework with embodied agents that must rely on exploring an unknown environment. We set up a variation of EQA where instead of the agents exploring the environment after the question is asked, the agents first explore the environment for a set amount of time and then answer a set of queries. Using CAM, we observe a $46%$ higher EQA accuracy when compared against aggregation methods for ensemble LLM, such as voting schemes and debates. CAM does not require any form of agent communication, alleviating it from the associated costs. We ablate CAM with various nonlinear (neural network, random forest, decision tree, XGBoost) and linear (logistic regression classifier, SVM) algorithms. We experiment in various topological graph environments and examine the case where one of the agents is malicious and purposes contribute responses it believes to be wrong.

Read more

9/17/2024

🏅

Total Score

0

S-EQA: Tackling Situational Queries in Embodied Question Answering

Vishnu Sashank Dorbala, Prasoon Goyal, Robinson Piramuthu, Michael Johnston, Dinesh Manocha, Reza Ghanadhan

We present and tackle the problem of Embodied Question Answering (EQA) with Situational Queries (S-EQA) in a household environment. Unlike prior EQA work tackling simple queries that directly reference target objects and quantifiable properties pertaining them, EQA with situational queries (such as Is the bathroom clean and dry?) is more challenging, as the agent needs to figure out not just what the target objects pertaining to the query are, but also requires a consensus on their states to be answerable. Towards this objective, we first introduce a novel Prompt-Generate-Evaluate (PGE) scheme that wraps around an LLM's output to create a dataset of unique situational queries, corresponding consensus object information, and predicted answers. PGE maintains uniqueness among the generated queries, using multiple forms of semantic similarity. We validate the generated dataset via a large scale user-study conducted on M-Turk, and introduce it as S-EQA, the first dataset tackling EQA with situational queries. Our user study establishes the authenticity of S-EQA with a high 97.26% of the generated queries being deemed answerable, given the consensus object data. Conversely, we observe a low correlation of 46.2% on the LLM-predicted answers to human-evaluated ones; indicating the LLM's poor capability in directly answering situational queries, while establishing S-EQA's usability in providing a human-validated consensus for an indirect solution. We evaluate S-EQA via Visual Question Answering (VQA) on VirtualHome, which unlike other simulators, contains several objects with modifiable states that also visually appear different upon modification -- enabling us to set a quantitative benchmark for S-EQA. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work to introduce EQA with situational queries, and also the first to use a generative approach for query creation.

Read more

5/9/2024