Exploring the Practicality of Generative Retrieval on Dynamic Corpora

Overview

• Information retrieval (IR) systems are often evaluated using fixed document collections, but in real-world scenarios, documents are constantly updated and added.
• This paper focuses on Generative Retrievals (GR), which use autoregressive language models for IR, and explores their adaptability and robustness in dynamic environments.
• The paper also evaluates the computational and memory efficiency of GR compared to commonly used Dual Encoders (DE) in retrieval systems.

Plain English Explanation

Generative Retrieval for Dynamic Corpora addresses a common issue in information retrieval (IR) systems. Most IR research is done using fixed document collections, but in reality, the documents that need to be retrieved are constantly changing as new information is added and updated.

The paper looks at a type of IR system called Generative Retrieval (GR), which uses powerful language models to generate relevant documents in response to queries. The researchers explore how well GR systems can adapt and stay robust when the available information is constantly evolving.

They also compare the computational and memory efficiency of GR systems to another common type of IR system called Dual Encoders (DE). Efficiency is crucial for real-world IR systems that need to handle large and ever-changing document collections.

The results show that GR systems are more adaptable to changing knowledge, better at learning from information with timestamps, and more computationally and memory-efficient than DE systems. This suggests GR could be very useful for practical IR systems that need to work with dynamic document collections.

Technical Explanation

The paper focuses on Generative Retrievals (GR), which apply autoregressive language models to information retrieval (IR) problems. The researchers explore the adaptability and robustness of GR systems in dynamic scenarios where documents are constantly updated and added.

They conduct an extensive evaluation comparing GR to Dual Encoders (DE), a commonly used approach in retrieval systems. The key metrics examined are computational and memory efficiency, which are crucial for real-world deployment of IR systems handling large and ever-changing document collections.

The experiments use the StreamingQA benchmark, which simulates a dynamic document collection. The results show that GR is 4-11% more adaptable to evolving knowledge and more robust in learning from temporal information compared to DE. Additionally, GR is significantly more efficient, with 2x fewer inference FLOPs, 6x faster indexing time, and 4x smaller storage footprint.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thorough and well-designed study of the performance of Generative Retrievals (GR) in dynamic document collection scenarios. The use of the StreamingQA benchmark is a strength, as it realistically simulates the challenges of real-world IR systems.

However, the paper does not directly address some potential limitations of GR. For example, the authors do not discuss the quality or coherence of the generated documents compared to retrieved documents from a traditional IR system. There may be tradeoffs between adaptability/efficiency and output quality that warrant further investigation.

Additionally, the paper focuses on overall system-level metrics but does not dive into the internal mechanics and behavior of the GR models. Examining things like attention patterns, hallucination tendencies, or other model-specific characteristics could yield additional insights.

Further research could also explore the interaction between GR and other IR system components, such as query understanding, user feedback, or knowledge integration. Holistic system-level evaluations in real-world settings would strengthen the practical implications of this work.

Conclusion

This paper demonstrates the strong potential of Generative Retrievals (GR) for information retrieval systems that need to handle dynamic document collections. GR systems show greater adaptability to evolving knowledge and improved computational/memory efficiency compared to commonly used Dual Encoder approaches.

The results suggest GR could be a valuable tool for building practical IR systems that can keep up with the constant flow of new and changing information. By leveraging the capabilities of large language models, GR may enable more robust and efficient retrieval in scenarios where documents are continuously updated and added.

Further research exploring the tradeoffs and interactions of GR within complete IR pipelines could solidify its role as a key technology for the next generation of real-world information retrieval systems.