Extending Explainable Ensemble Trees (E2Tree) to regression contexts

Read original: arXiv:2409.06439 - Published 9/11/2024 by Massimo Aria, Agostino Gnasso, Carmela Iorio, Marjolein Fokkema
Total Score

0

Extending Explainable Ensemble Trees (E2Tree) to regression contexts

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper extends the Explainable Ensemble Trees (E2Tree) model to regression tasks, allowing for more interpretable and explainable machine learning models in real-world applications.
  • E2Tree was originally developed for classification problems, and this work applies the same principles to regression problems, where the model predicts a continuous output value rather than a discrete class.
  • The paper explains the technical details of how E2Tree was adapted for regression and presents experimental results demonstrating its effectiveness.

Plain English Explanation

Machine learning models are increasingly being used to make important decisions, so it's important that these models are explainable - meaning we can understand how they arrive at their predictions. The Explainable Ensemble Trees (E2Tree) model was developed to provide this type of interpretability for classification problems.

In this paper, the researchers extend the E2Tree model to handle regression problems, where the model predicts a continuous value rather than a category. This is an important advancement because many real-world applications, like predicting a person's income or a product's sales, require regression models.

The key idea is to adapt the way E2Tree generates explanations for its predictions to work with continuous outputs instead of discrete classes. The researchers develop a new approach that allows E2Tree to provide clear, human-understandable explanations for its regression results.

Through experiments, the researchers show that this extended E2Tree model maintains strong predictive performance while also offering the interpretability that is so important for building trust in machine learning systems.

Technical Explanation

The paper begins by discussing the importance of explainable machine learning, particularly as these models are increasingly used to make high-stakes decisions. The authors explain how the original E2Tree model provided interpretability for classification problems by generating explanations based on the decision rules in the ensemble of decision trees.

To extend E2Tree to regression tasks, the authors had to adapt the way the model generates these explanations. In classification, the model can explain its predictions in terms of the specific classes it is choosing between. But for regression, where the output is a continuous value, the model needs a different approach.

The key innovation in this work is a new method for constructing explanations for regression predictions. Instead of discrete classes, the model now explains its output in terms of prototypical input examples that represent different regions of the prediction space. By identifying the closest prototypes to a given input, the model can provide clear, human-understandable explanations for its regression results.

The paper includes experiments demonstrating that this extended E2Tree model maintains strong predictive performance on regression benchmarks while also offering the interpretability benefits of the original E2Tree. The authors discuss some limitations and potential areas for future work, such as handling high-dimensional input spaces.

Critical Analysis

The authors make a compelling case for the importance of explainable machine learning in real-world applications, and the work they present here represents an important step forward. Extending the E2Tree model to regression tasks is a non-trivial technical challenge, and the new explanation generation approach they develop seems well-suited to this problem.

That said, the paper does not explore some potential limitations or areas for further research. For example, the experiments are conducted on relatively small, low-dimensional datasets, so it's unclear how well the model would scale to high-dimensional regression problems often found in practice. The authors also don't discuss how the explanations generated by E2Tree for regression might be interpreted or used by end-users.

Overall, this work makes a valuable contribution by bringing the benefits of interpretable machine learning to regression problems. The technical advances presented here, along with continued research on the practical application of these methods, could have significant implications for building trust and transparency in real-world AI systems.

Conclusion

This paper presents an extension of the Explainable Ensemble Trees (E2Tree) model to handle regression tasks, where the goal is to predict a continuous output value rather than a discrete class. By developing a new approach for generating human-interpretable explanations of regression predictions, the authors have made an important advancement in the field of explainable machine learning.

The technical contributions of this work, combined with the demonstrated effectiveness on regression benchmarks, suggest that the extended E2Tree model could be a valuable tool for deploying interpretable AI systems in real-world applications that require predicting continuous quantities. As machine learning becomes increasingly prevalent in high-stakes decision-making, advances like this that prioritize transparency and explainability will be crucial for building trust and acceptance of these technologies.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Extending Explainable Ensemble Trees (E2Tree) to regression contexts
Total Score

0

Extending Explainable Ensemble Trees (E2Tree) to regression contexts

Massimo Aria, Agostino Gnasso, Carmela Iorio, Marjolein Fokkema

Ensemble methods such as random forests have transformed the landscape of supervised learning, offering highly accurate prediction through the aggregation of multiple weak learners. However, despite their effectiveness, these methods often lack transparency, impeding users' comprehension of how RF models arrive at their predictions. Explainable ensemble trees (E2Tree) is a novel methodology for explaining random forests, that provides a graphical representation of the relationship between response variables and predictors. A striking characteristic of E2Tree is that it not only accounts for the effects of predictor variables on the response but also accounts for associations between the predictor variables through the computation and use of dissimilarity measures. The E2Tree methodology was initially proposed for use in classification tasks. In this paper, we extend the methodology to encompass regression contexts. To demonstrate the explanatory power of the proposed algorithm, we illustrate its use on real-world datasets.

Read more

9/11/2024

↗️

Total Score

0

Ensembles of Probabilistic Regression Trees

Alexandre Seiller (APTIKAL), 'Eric Gaussier (APTIKAL), Emilie Devijver (APTIKAL), Marianne Clausel (IECL), Sami Alkhoury

Tree-based ensemble methods such as random forests, gradient-boosted trees, and Bayesianadditive regression trees have been successfully used for regression problems in many applicationsand research studies. In this paper, we study ensemble versions of probabilisticregression trees that provide smooth approximations of the objective function by assigningeach observation to each region with respect to a probability distribution. We prove thatthe ensemble versions of probabilistic regression trees considered are consistent, and experimentallystudy their bias-variance trade-off and compare them with the state-of-the-art interms of performance prediction.

Read more

6/21/2024

📈

Total Score

0

Explanations Based on Item Response Theory (eXirt): A Model-Specific Method to Explain Tree-Ensemble Model in Trust Perspective

Jos'e Ribeiro, Lucas Cardoso, Ra'issa Silva, Vitor Cirilo, N'ikolas Carneiro, Ronnie Alves

In recent years, XAI researchers have been formalizing proposals and developing new methods to explain black box models, with no general consensus in the community on which method to use to explain these models, with this choice being almost directly linked to the popularity of a specific method. Methods such as Ciu, Dalex, Eli5, Lofo, Shap and Skater emerged with the proposal to explain black box models through global rankings of feature relevance, which based on different methodologies, generate global explanations that indicate how the model's inputs explain its predictions. In this context, 41 datasets, 4 tree-ensemble algorithms (Light Gradient Boosting, CatBoost, Random Forest, and Gradient Boosting), and 6 XAI methods were used to support the launch of a new XAI method, called eXirt, based on Item Response Theory - IRT and aimed at tree-ensemble black box models that use tabular data referring to binary classification problems. In the first set of analyses, the 164 global feature relevance ranks of the eXirt were compared with 984 ranks of the other XAI methods present in the literature, seeking to highlight their similarities and differences. In a second analysis, exclusive explanations of the eXirt based on Explanation-by-example were presented that help in understanding the model trust. Thus, it was verified that eXirt is able to generate global explanations of tree-ensemble models and also local explanations of instances of models through IRT, showing how this consolidated theory can be used in machine learning in order to obtain explainable and reliable models.

Read more

7/4/2024

Total Score

0

A-PETE: Adaptive Prototype Explanations of Tree Ensembles

Jacek Karolczak, Jerzy Stefanowski

The need for interpreting machine learning models is addressed through prototype explanations within the context of tree ensembles. An algorithm named Adaptive Prototype Explanations of Tree Ensembles (A-PETE) is proposed to automatise the selection of prototypes for these classifiers. Its unique characteristics is using a specialised distance measure and a modified k-medoid approach. Experiments demonstrated its competitive predictive accuracy with respect to earlier explanation algorithms. It also provides a a sufficient number of prototypes for the purpose of interpreting the random forest classifier.

Read more

6/3/2024