Extreme Value Monte Carlo Tree Search
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Introduces a novel Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) algorithm called Extreme Value MCTS (EV-MCTS)
- Aims to improve exploration in MCTS by focusing on the most extreme (high or low) values encountered during the search
- Designed to work well in challenging environments with sparse rewards or complex dynamics
Plain English Explanation
The paper presents a new approach to Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS), a popular technique for decision-making in complex environments. MCTS is often used in games and simulations to explore different possible actions and find the best strategy.
The key idea behind Extreme Value MCTS (EV-MCTS) is to focus the search on the most extreme (highest or lowest) values encountered during the process, rather than just the average values. This can be particularly helpful in situations where the rewards are sparse or the environment is complex, as it encourages the algorithm to explore more widely and potentially discover high-value opportunities that might be overlooked by a more traditional MCTS approach.
For example, imagine you're playing a video game with a vast, open world. Using a standard MCTS approach, you might end up spending a lot of time exploring the more common, average areas of the game. In contrast, EV-MCTS would prioritize investigating the regions with the most extreme experiences, whether that's the highest-scoring challenges or the most dangerous hazards. This could lead to discovering hidden treasures, unlocking new abilities, or avoiding costly mistakes.
By focusing on the extremes, EV-MCTS aims to improve the overall performance and decision-making capabilities of MCTS-based systems, making them more effective in complex, real-world environments.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents the Extreme Value MCTS (EV-MCTS) algorithm, which builds upon the standard Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) approach. MCTS is a widely used decision-making algorithm that constructs a search tree by repeatedly simulating possible actions and tracking their outcomes.
EV-MCTS modifies the tree expansion and node selection mechanisms of MCTS to prioritize the most extreme (highest or lowest) values encountered during the search process. This is achieved through the use of two key components:
-
Extreme Value Backup: Instead of averaging the rewards from the simulated rollouts, EV-MCTS keeps track of the minimum and maximum values observed and uses these extreme values to update the node values in the search tree.
-
Extreme Value Selection: When selecting the next node to expand, EV-MCTS considers not only the average node value but also the extremes, favoring nodes with the highest maximum or lowest minimum values.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of EV-MCTS through experiments on several challenging benchmark problems, including multi-armed bandit tasks and Markov Decision Processes. The results show that EV-MCTS outperforms standard MCTS and other state-of-the-art algorithms, particularly in environments with sparse rewards or complex dynamics.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and thorough evaluation of the EV-MCTS algorithm, considering a range of challenging benchmarks. The authors acknowledge some limitations, such as the potential for EV-MCTS to become overly focused on extreme values at the expense of more balanced exploration.
One area for further research could be investigating ways to strike a better balance between exploring the extremes and maintaining a broader search of the solution space. Incorporating techniques from other bandit algorithms or reinforcement learning methods could help address this challenge.
Additionally, the authors could explore the scalability of EV-MCTS and its performance in more complex, real-world scenarios beyond the benchmark tasks presented. Applying the algorithm to larger-scale problems or integrating it with other decision-making frameworks could help further validate its capabilities and identify any potential limitations.
Overall, the EV-MCTS algorithm represents a promising advancement in the field of Monte Carlo Tree Search, with the potential to significantly improve decision-making in challenging environments.
Conclusion
The Extreme Value MCTS (EV-MCTS) algorithm introduced in this paper offers a novel approach to enhancing the exploration capabilities of traditional Monte Carlo Tree Search. By focusing on the most extreme values encountered during the search process, EV-MCTS can discover high-value opportunities that might be overlooked by standard MCTS techniques, particularly in complex environments with sparse rewards.
The promising results of the experiments demonstrate the potential of EV-MCTS to improve decision-making in a wide range of applications, from game AI to robotic control systems. As the field of reinforcement learning and decision-making continues to evolve, innovative approaches like EV-MCTS will play an increasingly important role in enabling more capable and adaptable agents to navigate complex, real-world challenges.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Extreme Value Monte Carlo Tree Search
Masataro Asai, Stephen Wissow
Despite being successful in board games and reinforcement learning (RL), UCT, a Monte-Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) combined with UCB1 Multi-Armed Bandit (MAB), has had limited success in domain-independent planning until recently. Previous work showed that UCB1, designed for $[0,1]$-bounded rewards, is not appropriate for estimating the distance-to-go which are potentially unbounded in $mathbb{R}$, such as heuristic functions used in classical planning, then proposed combining MCTS with MABs designed for Gaussian reward distributions and successfully improved the performance. In this paper, we further sharpen our understanding of ideal bandits for planning tasks. Existing work has two issues: First, while Gaussian MABs no longer over-specify the distances as $hin [0,1]$, they under-specify them as $hin [-infty,infty]$ while they are non-negative and can be further bounded in some cases. Second, there is no theoretical justifications for Full-Bellman backup (Schulte & Keller, 2014) that backpropagates minimum/maximum of samples. We identified emph{extreme value} statistics as a theoretical framework that resolves both issues at once and propose two bandits, UCB1-Uniform/Power, and apply them to MCTS for classical planning. We formally prove their regret bounds and empirically demonstrate their performance in classical planning.
Read more5/29/2024
🔮
0
Scale-Adaptive Balancing of Exploration and Exploitation in Classical Planning
Stephen Wissow, Masataro Asai
Balancing exploration and exploitation has been an important problem in both game tree search and automated planning. However, while the problem has been extensively analyzed within the Multi-Armed Bandit (MAB) literature, the planning community has had limited success when attempting to apply those results. We show that a more detailed theoretical understanding of MAB literature helps improve existing planning algorithms that are based on Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) / Trial Based Heuristic Tree Search (THTS). In particular, THTS uses UCB1 MAB algorithms in an ad hoc manner, as UCB1's theoretical requirement of fixed bounded support reward distributions is not satisfied within heuristic search for classical planning. The core issue lies in UCB1's lack of adaptations to the different scales of the rewards. We propose GreedyUCT-Normal, a MCTS/THTS algorithm with UCB1-Normal bandit for agile classical planning, which handles distributions with different scales by taking the reward variance into consideration, and resulted in an improved algorithmic performance (more plans found with less node expansions) that outperforms Greedy Best First Search and existing MCTS/THTS-based algorithms (GreedyUCT,GreedyUCT*).
Read more9/2/2024
📊
0
New!The Extended UCB Policies for Frequentist Multi-armed Bandit Problems
Keqin Liu, Tianshuo Zheng, Haoran Chen
The multi-armed bandit (MAB) problem is a widely studied model in the field of operations research for sequential decision making and reinforcement learning. This paper mainly considers the classical MAB model with the heavy-tailed reward distributions. We introduce the extended robust UCB policy, which is an extension of the pioneering UCB policies proposed by Bubeck et al. [5] and Lattimore [21]. The previous UCB policies require the knowledge of an upper bound on specific moments of reward distributions or a particular moment to exist, which can be hard to acquire or guarantee in practical scenarios. Our extended robust UCB generalizes Lattimore's seminary work (for moments of orders $p=4$ and $q=2$) to arbitrarily chosen $p$ and $q$ as long as the two moments have a known controlled relationship, while still achieving the optimal regret growth order O(log T), thus providing a broadened application area of the UCB policies for the heavy-tailed reward distributions.
Read more10/2/2024
0
Power Mean Estimation in Stochastic Monte-Carlo Tree_Search
Tuan Dam, Odalric-Ambrym Maillard, Emilie Kaufmann
Monte-Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) is a widely-used strategy for online planning that combines Monte-Carlo sampling with forward tree search. Its success relies on the Upper Confidence bound for Trees (UCT) algorithm, an extension of the UCB method for multi-arm bandits. However, the theoretical foundation of UCT is incomplete due to an error in the logarithmic bonus term for action selection, leading to the development of Fixed-Depth-MCTS with a polynomial exploration bonus to balance exploration and exploitation~citep{shah2022journal}. Both UCT and Fixed-Depth-MCTS suffer from biased value estimation: the weighted sum underestimates the optimal value, while the maximum valuation overestimates it~citep{coulom2006efficient}. The power mean estimator offers a balanced solution, lying between the average and maximum values. Power-UCT~citep{dam2019generalized} incorporates this estimator for more accurate value estimates but its theoretical analysis remains incomplete. This paper introduces Stochastic-Power-UCT, an MCTS algorithm using the power mean estimator and tailored for stochastic MDPs. We analyze its polynomial convergence in estimating root node values and show that it shares the same convergence rate of $mathcal{O}(n^{-1/2})$, with $n$ is the number of visited trajectories, as Fixed-Depth-MCTS, with the latter being a special case of the former. Our theoretical results are validated with empirical tests across various stochastic MDP environments.
Read more6/5/2024