Faithful Path Language Modeling for Explainable Recommendation over Knowledge Graph
2310.16452
0
0
💬
Abstract
The integration of path reasoning with language modeling in recommender systems has shown promise for enhancing explainability but often struggles with the authenticity of the explanations provided. Traditional models modify their architecture to produce entities and relations alternately--for example, employing separate heads for each in the model--which does not ensure the authenticity of paths reflective of actual Knowledge Graph (KG) connections. This misalignment can lead to user distrust due to the generation of corrupted paths. Addressing this, we introduce PEARLM (Path-based Explainable-Accurate Recommender based on Language Modelling), which innovates with a Knowledge Graph Constraint Decoding (KGCD) mechanism. This mechanism ensures zero incidence of corrupted paths by enforcing adherence to valid KG connections at the decoding level, agnostic of the underlying model architecture. By integrating direct token embedding learning from KG paths, PEARLM not only guarantees the generation of plausible and verifiable explanations but also highly enhances recommendation accuracy. We validate the effectiveness of our approach through a rigorous empirical assessment, employing a newly proposed metric that quantifies the integrity of explanation paths. Our results demonstrate a significant improvement over existing methods, effectively eliminating the generation of inaccurate paths and advancing the state-of-the-art in explainable recommender systems.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a new approach called PEARLM (Path-based Explainable-Accurate Recommender based on Language Modelling) that aims to enhance the explainability and accuracy of recommender systems.
- Traditional recommender systems that integrate path reasoning with language modeling often struggle with the authenticity of the explanations provided, as their models may generate corrupted paths that do not accurately reflect the connections in the underlying knowledge graph.
- PEARLM addresses this issue by introducing a Knowledge Graph Constraint Decoding (KGCD) mechanism that ensures the generated paths are valid and aligned with the actual knowledge graph connections, regardless of the underlying model architecture.
- By integrating direct token embedding learning from knowledge graph paths, PEARLM not only guarantees plausible and verifiable explanations, but also significantly improves recommendation accuracy.
Plain English Explanation
Recommender systems are tools that suggest products, services, or content to users based on their preferences and behavior. To make these recommendations more understandable, some systems try to explain their decisions by showing the reasoning behind them, such as the connections between the user's interests and the recommended items.
However, the traditional methods for integrating this "path reasoning" with language models (which are used to process and generate text) often produce explanations that don't accurately reflect the real connections in the knowledge graph - the structured database of information that the system uses to make its recommendations. This can lead to users feeling that the explanations are not trustworthy.
To address this problem, the researchers developed PEARLM, a new approach that ensures the explanations generated by the system are always true to the actual knowledge graph connections. PEARLM does this by adding a special "knowledge graph constraint decoding" mechanism to the model, which checks that the generated paths are valid before presenting them to the user.
In addition to improving the authenticity of the explanations, PEARLM also enhances the overall accuracy of the recommendations by directly learning from the knowledge graph paths. This means the system can make better suggestions because it understands the relationships between items more deeply.
The researchers thoroughly tested PEARLM and found that it significantly outperforms existing methods, completely eliminating the generation of inaccurate explanatory paths. This represents an important advancement in the field of explainable recommender systems, helping to build trust between users and the AI-powered tools that make recommendations.
Technical Explanation
The key innovation in PEARLM is the Knowledge Graph Constraint Decoding (KGCD) mechanism, which ensures that the paths generated by the model to explain recommendations are always valid and aligned with the actual connections in the underlying knowledge graph.
Traditional models often employ separate neural network "heads" (output layers) to generate entities and relations independently, which can lead to the creation of corrupted paths that do not reflect the true structure of the knowledge graph. In contrast, PEARLM's KGCD approach enforces adherence to valid knowledge graph connections during the decoding process, regardless of the model's architecture.
By integrating direct token embedding learning from the knowledge graph paths, PEARLM not only guarantees the generation of plausible and verifiable explanations, but also significantly boosts the overall recommendation accuracy. This is because the model can better understand the relationships between items by directly learning from the structured knowledge in the graph.
The researchers conducted a rigorous empirical evaluation of PEARLM, employing a newly proposed metric that quantifies the integrity of the explanation paths generated by the model. Their results demonstrate a substantial improvement over existing explainable recommender systems, effectively eliminating the production of inaccurate paths and advancing the state-of-the-art in this area.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and thoughtfully executed approach to addressing a critical challenge in explainable recommender systems - the authenticity of the explanations provided to users. The introduction of the KGCD mechanism is a clever solution that effectively resolves the misalignment between model outputs and the actual knowledge graph connections.
One potential limitation of the research is that it focuses primarily on the path-based explanations and does not explore other forms of explainability, such as feature importance or counterfactual reasoning. While the authors demonstrate the effectiveness of PEARLM in generating trustworthy paths, there may be value in investigating how the approach could be extended to provide users with a more comprehensive understanding of the recommendation process.
Additionally, the paper does not delve into the computational efficiency or scalability of the KGCD mechanism, which could be an important consideration for real-world deployment of the system. Further research on the practical implications and deployment challenges would help strengthen the overall contribution of this work.
Despite these minor caveats, the researchers have made a significant advancement in the field of explainable recommender systems by addressing a fundamental issue with path-based explanations. The introduction of PEARLM and its rigorous evaluation represent an important step towards building more transparent and trustworthy AI-powered recommendation systems.
Conclusion
The PEARLM approach proposed in this paper represents a notable contribution to the field of explainable recommender systems. By introducing a Knowledge Graph Constraint Decoding mechanism, the researchers have successfully addressed the challenge of generating authentic, verifiable explanations for recommendations, a crucial aspect of building user trust in AI-driven decision-making.
The integration of direct token embedding learning from knowledge graph paths not only ensures the plausibility of the explanations but also significantly enhances the overall recommendation accuracy. This dual benefit showcases the power of leveraging structured knowledge to improve the performance and transparency of recommender systems.
The rigorous evaluation and the introduction of a new metric to quantify explanation integrity further strengthen the contributions of this work. While the paper suggests some potential avenues for future research, such as exploring additional forms of explainability, the PEARLM approach represents an important milestone in the ongoing efforts to develop more trustworthy and effective recommender systems powered by large language models and uncertainty-aware reasoning.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Knowledge Graph-Enhanced Large Language Models via Path Selection
Haochen Liu, Song Wang, Yaochen Zhu, Yushun Dong, Jundong Li
0
0
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown unprecedented performance in various real-world applications. However, they are known to generate factually inaccurate outputs, a.k.a. the hallucination problem. In recent years, incorporating external knowledge extracted from Knowledge Graphs (KGs) has become a promising strategy to improve the factual accuracy of LLM-generated outputs. Nevertheless, most existing explorations rely on LLMs themselves to perform KG knowledge extraction, which is highly inflexible as LLMs can only provide binary judgment on whether a certain knowledge (e.g., a knowledge path in KG) should be used. In addition, LLMs tend to pick only knowledge with direct semantic relationship with the input text, while potentially useful knowledge with indirect semantics can be ignored. In this work, we propose a principled framework KELP with three stages to handle the above problems. Specifically, KELP is able to achieve finer granularity of flexible knowledge extraction by generating scores for knowledge paths with input texts via latent semantic matching. Meanwhile, knowledge paths with indirect semantic relationships with the input text can also be considered via trained encoding between the selected paths in KG and the input text. Experiments on real-world datasets validate the effectiveness of KELP.
6/21/2024
LLM-Powered Explanations: Unraveling Recommendations Through Subgraph Reasoning
Guangsi Shi, Xiaofeng Deng, Linhao Luo, Lijuan Xia, Lei Bao, Bei Ye, Fei Du, Shirui Pan, Yuxiao Li
0
0
Recommender systems are pivotal in enhancing user experiences across various web applications by analyzing the complicated relationships between users and items. Knowledge graphs(KGs) have been widely used to enhance the performance of recommender systems. However, KGs are known to be noisy and incomplete, which are hard to provide reliable explanations for recommendation results. An explainable recommender system is crucial for the product development and subsequent decision-making. To address these challenges, we introduce a novel recommender that synergies Large Language Models (LLMs) and KGs to enhance the recommendation and provide interpretable results. Specifically, we first harness the power of LLMs to augment KG reconstruction. LLMs comprehend and decompose user reviews into new triples that are added into KG. In this way, we can enrich KGs with explainable paths that express user preferences. To enhance the recommendation on augmented KGs, we introduce a novel subgraph reasoning module that effectively measures the importance of nodes and discovers reasoning for recommendation. Finally, these reasoning paths are fed into the LLMs to generate interpretable explanations of the recommendation results. Our approach significantly enhances both the effectiveness and interpretability of recommender systems, especially in cross-selling scenarios where traditional methods falter. The effectiveness of our approach has been rigorously tested on four open real-world datasets, with our methods demonstrating a superior performance over contemporary state-of-the-art techniques by an average improvement of 12%. The application of our model in a multinational engineering and technology company cross-selling recommendation system further underscores its practical utility and potential to redefine recommendation practices through improved accuracy and user trust.
7/2/2024
📶
Faithful Knowledge Graph Explanations for Commonsense Reasoning
Weihe Zhai, Arkaitz Zubiaga
0
0
The fusion of language models (LMs) and knowledge graphs (KGs) is widely used in commonsense question answering, but generating faithful explanations remains challenging. Current methods often overlook path decoding faithfulness, leading to divergence between graph encoder outputs and model predictions. We identify confounding effects and LM-KG misalignment as key factors causing spurious explanations. To address this, we introduce the LM-KG Fidelity metric to assess KG representation reliability and propose the LM-KG Distribution-aware Alignment (textit{LKDA}) algorithm to improve explanation faithfulness. Without ground truth, we evaluate KG explanations using the proposed Fidelity-Sparsity Trade-off Curve. Experiments on CommonsenseQA and OpenBookQA show that LKDA significantly enhances explanation fidelity and model performance, highlighting the need to address distributional misalignment for reliable commonsense reasoning.
6/26/2024
New!LANE: Logic Alignment of Non-tuning Large Language Models and Online Recommendation Systems for Explainable Reason Generation
Hongke Zhao, Songming Zheng, Likang Wu, Bowen Yu, Jing Wang
0
0
The explainability of recommendation systems is crucial for enhancing user trust and satisfaction. Leveraging large language models (LLMs) offers new opportunities for comprehensive recommendation logic generation. However, in existing related studies, fine-tuning LLM models for recommendation tasks incurs high computational costs and alignment issues with existing systems, limiting the application potential of proven proprietary/closed-source LLM models, such as GPT-4. In this work, our proposed effective strategy LANE aligns LLMs with online recommendation systems without additional LLMs tuning, reducing costs and improving explainability. This innovative approach addresses key challenges in integrating language models with recommendation systems while fully utilizing the capabilities of powerful proprietary models. Specifically, our strategy operates through several key components: semantic embedding, user multi-preference extraction using zero-shot prompting, semantic alignment, and explainable recommendation generation using Chain of Thought (CoT) prompting. By embedding item titles instead of IDs and utilizing multi-head attention mechanisms, our approach aligns the semantic features of user preferences with those of candidate items, ensuring coherent and user-aligned recommendations. Sufficient experimental results including performance comparison, questionnaire voting, and visualization cases prove that our method can not only ensure recommendation performance, but also provide easy-to-understand and reasonable recommendation logic.
7/4/2024