Fast Diffusion-Based Counterfactuals for Shortcut Removal and Generation
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a fast diffusion-based approach to generate counterfactual images that can help remove unwanted shortcuts learned by image classifiers.
- The method leverages latent diffusion models to efficiently generate counterfactual samples that can be used to uncover and address shortcut learning in image classification tasks, including medical image segmentation.
- The approach also enables the generation of counterfactual trajectories to guide latent diffusion models towards desired concepts.
Plain English Explanation
This research paper presents a new way to generate counterfactual images - images that are slightly different from the original but lead to a different output from an AI model. The key idea is to use a special type of AI model called a "diffusion model" to quickly create these counterfactual images.
Counterfactual images are useful for understanding why AI models make certain decisions. Sometimes AI models can learn "shortcuts" - they focus on irrelevant details in the image rather than the important information. By generating counterfactual images, researchers can expose these shortcuts and help improve the AI models.
The paper shows how this fast counterfactual generation approach can be applied to various image classification and segmentation tasks, including in the medical field. It also demonstrates how the counterfactual images can be used to guide the AI models towards learning more meaningful concepts, rather than relying on shortcuts.
Overall, this research provides a powerful new tool for debugging and improving AI models, ensuring they focus on the right details and make decisions for the right reasons.
Technical Explanation
The key technical innovation in this paper is the use of latent diffusion models to efficiently generate counterfactual images. Diffusion models are a type of generative AI that can create new images by gradually adding noise to an input image and then reversing the process.
The authors leverage this diffusion process to generate counterfactual images that are just slightly different from the original, but lead to a different output from the target classifier. This is achieved by guiding the diffusion process towards regions of the latent space that correspond to the desired counterfactual concept.
Importantly, the paper demonstrates that this approach is significantly faster than previous methods for generating counterfactual images, making it more practical for large-scale analysis and debugging of AI models, including for tasks like medical image segmentation.
The authors also show how the generated counterfactual trajectories can be used to guide latent diffusion models towards desired concepts, enabling more interpretable and controllable image generation.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a compelling case for the value of fast, diffusion-based counterfactual generation, demonstrating its effectiveness across multiple image classification and segmentation tasks. However, it is important to note that the method relies on the availability of a pre-trained classifier, which may not always be the case in real-world scenarios.
Additionally, while the paper discusses the ability to guide latent diffusion models towards desired concepts, it does not provide a thorough exploration of the potential limitations or biases that could arise from this approach. Further research may be needed to understand the broader implications of using counterfactual generation to steer generative models.
Another area for potential improvement is the handling of highly complex or nuanced visual concepts, where the current approach may struggle to generate meaningful counterfactual examples. Exploring ways to make the method more robust to these challenges could enhance its practical applicability.
Overall, this paper presents an important step forward in the field of counterfactual image generation, with promising implications for improving the interpretability and reliability of AI systems. However, as with any emerging technology, continued critical examination and refinement will be necessary to fully realize its potential.
Conclusion
This research paper introduces a fast, diffusion-based approach to generating counterfactual images that can be used to uncover and address shortcut learning in image classification tasks. The method leverages latent diffusion models to efficiently create counterfactual samples, enabling more practical large-scale analysis and debugging of AI systems, including in the medical domain.
The paper also demonstrates how the generated counterfactual trajectories can be used to guide latent diffusion models towards desired concepts, opening up new possibilities for more interpretable and controllable image generation. While the approach shows promise, further research is needed to address potential limitations and ensure the responsible development of these powerful techniques.
Overall, this work represents an important advancement in the field of counterfactual image generation, with the potential to significantly improve the transparency and robustness of AI-powered decision-making across a wide range of applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Fast Diffusion-Based Counterfactuals for Shortcut Removal and Generation
Nina Weng, Paraskevas Pegios, Eike Petersen, Aasa Feragen, Siavash Bigdeli
Shortcut learning is when a model -- e.g. a cardiac disease classifier -- exploits correlations between the target label and a spurious shortcut feature, e.g. a pacemaker, to predict the target label based on the shortcut rather than real discriminative features. This is common in medical imaging, where treatment and clinical annotations correlate with disease labels, making them easy shortcuts to predict disease. We propose a novel detection and quantification of the impact of potential shortcut features via a fast diffusion-based counterfactual image generation that can synthetically remove or add shortcuts. Via a novel inpainting-based modification we spatially limit the changes made with no extra inference step, encouraging the removal of spatially constrained shortcut features while ensuring that the shortcut-free counterfactuals preserve their remaining image features to a high degree. Using these, we assess how shortcut features influence model predictions. This is enabled by our second contribution: An efficient diffusion-based counterfactual explanation method with significant inference speed-up at comparable image quality as state-of-the-art. We confirm this on two large chest X-ray datasets, a skin lesion dataset, and CelebA. Our code is publicly available at fastdime.compute.dtu.dk.
Read more7/18/2024
0
Exposing Image Classifier Shortcuts with Counterfactual Frequency (CoF) Tables
James Hinns, David Martens
The rise of deep learning in image classification has brought unprecedented accuracy but also highlighted a key issue: the use of 'shortcuts' by models. Such shortcuts are easy-to-learn patterns from the training data that fail to generalise to new data. Examples include the use of a copyright watermark to recognise horses, snowy background to recognise huskies, or ink markings to detect malignant skin lesions. The explainable AI (XAI) community has suggested using instance-level explanations to detect shortcuts without external data, but this requires the examination of many explanations to confirm the presence of such shortcuts, making it a labour-intensive process. To address these challenges, we introduce Counterfactual Frequency (CoF) tables, a novel approach that aggregates instance-based explanations into global insights, and exposes shortcuts. The aggregation implies the need for some semantic concepts to be used in the explanations, which we solve by labelling the segments of an image. We demonstrate the utility of CoF tables across several datasets, revealing the shortcuts learned from them.
Read more5/27/2024
0
MedEdit: Counterfactual Diffusion-based Image Editing on Brain MRI
Malek Ben Alaya, Daniel M. Lang, Benedikt Wiestler, Julia A. Schnabel, Cosmin I. Bercea
Denoising diffusion probabilistic models enable high-fidelity image synthesis and editing. In biomedicine, these models facilitate counterfactual image editing, producing pairs of images where one is edited to simulate hypothetical conditions. For example, they can model the progression of specific diseases, such as stroke lesions. However, current image editing techniques often fail to generate realistic biomedical counterfactuals, either by inadequately modeling indirect pathological effects like brain atrophy or by excessively altering the scan, which disrupts correspondence to the original images. Here, we propose MedEdit, a conditional diffusion model for medical image editing. MedEdit induces pathology in specific areas while balancing the modeling of disease effects and preserving the integrity of the original scan. We evaluated MedEdit on the Atlas v2.0 stroke dataset using Frechet Inception Distance and Dice scores, outperforming state-of-the-art diffusion-based methods such as Palette (by 45%) and SDEdit (by 61%). Additionally, clinical evaluations by a board-certified neuroradiologist confirmed that MedEdit generated realistic stroke scans indistinguishable from real ones. We believe this work will enable counterfactual image editing research to further advance the development of realistic and clinically useful imaging tools.
Read more7/23/2024
0
Investigating and Defending Shortcut Learning in Personalized Diffusion Models
Yixin Liu, Ruoxi Chen, Lichao Sun
Personalized diffusion models have gained popularity for adapting pre-trained text-to-image models to generate images of specific topics with minimal training data. However, these models are vulnerable to minor adversarial perturbations, leading to degraded performance on corrupted datasets. Such vulnerabilities are further exploited to craft protective perturbations on sensitive images like portraits that prevent unauthorized generation. In response, diffusion-based purification methods have been proposed to remove these perturbations and retain generation performance. However, existing works turn to over-purifying the images, which causes information loss. In this paper, we take a closer look at the fine-tuning process of personalized diffusion models through the lens of shortcut learning. And we propose a hypothesis explaining the manipulation mechanisms of existing perturbation methods, demonstrating that perturbed images significantly deviate from their original prompts in the CLIP-based latent space. This misalignment during fine-tuning causes models to associate noisy patterns with identifiers, resulting in performance degradation. Based on these insights, we introduce a systematic approach to maintain training performance through purification. Our method first purifies the images to realign them with their original semantic meanings in latent space. Then, we introduce contrastive learning with negative tokens to decouple the learning of clean identities from noisy patterns, which shows a strong potential capacity against adaptive perturbation. Our study uncovers shortcut learning vulnerabilities in personalized diffusion models and provides a firm evaluation framework for future protective perturbation research. Code is available at https://github.com/liuyixin-louis/DiffShortcut.
Read more8/9/2024