Fast Long-Term Multi-Scenario Prediction for Maneuver Planning at Unsignalized Intersections

Read original: arXiv:2401.14879 - Published 9/18/2024 by Max Bastian Mertens, Jona Ruof, Jan Strohbeck, Michael Buchholz

Fast Long-Term Multi-Scenario Prediction for Maneuver Planning at Unsignalized Intersections

Overview

This paper presents a fast long-term multi-scenario prediction approach for maneuver planning at unsignalized intersections.
The method can predict vehicle trajectories over a long time horizon and account for multiple possible scenarios.
It is designed to be computationally efficient for real-time planning in autonomous vehicles.

Plain English Explanation

The paper describes a new way for self-driving cars to plan their movements when approaching an unsignalized intersection, where there are no traffic lights to coordinate vehicles. The key idea is to predict the future paths of nearby vehicles over a long time period, rather than just the immediate next few seconds. This allows the self-driving car to anticipate potential conflicts and plan its maneuver accordingly.

The approach works by generating multiple possible scenarios for how other vehicles might behave, rather than just assuming they will follow a single predicted path. This makes the planning more robust to uncertain or unexpected actions by human drivers. The method is also designed to be computationally efficient, so it can run quickly enough to enable real-time decision-making in a self-driving car.

Overall, this research aims to improve the safety and capability of autonomous vehicles when navigating complex unsignalized intersections, which can be challenging scenarios for self-driving technology.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a long-term multi-scenario prediction framework for maneuver planning at unsignalized intersections. The approach generates a set of possible future trajectories for surrounding vehicles over a long time horizon (e.g. 10 seconds). This is done by learning a model to predict future vehicle states based on their current motion and the intersection geometry.

To enable efficient planning, the method abstracts the vehicle dynamics using a linear bicycle model and formulates the trajectory prediction as a mixed-integer quadratic program (MIQP). This allows the planner to consider multiple scenarios in real-time while satisfying constraints like collision avoidance.

The authors evaluate the approach on simulation data and show that it can accurately predict long-term vehicle trajectories and enable safe and efficient maneuver planning at unsignalized intersections. Compared to baseline methods, their approach demonstrates lower computational cost and better prediction accuracy.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thorough technical treatment of the proposed prediction and planning framework. However, it does not discuss certain limitations or potential issues in depth:

The evaluation is limited to simulation data, so the performance on real-world data is not demonstrated. Transferring the approach to the physical world may introduce additional challenges.
The prediction model is still based on a simplified vehicle dynamics model, which may not fully capture the complexity of real vehicle behavior, especially in edge cases.
The planning is performed in a centralized manner, which could raise scalability concerns as the number of vehicles increases. A decentralized approach may be more suitable for real-world deployment.

Further research could explore these areas to better understand the practical applicability and limitations of the proposed techniques.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel approach for long-term multi-scenario prediction and maneuver planning at unsignalized intersections. By anticipating a range of possible future vehicle trajectories, the method can enable safe and efficient autonomous navigation in complex traffic scenarios.

The key technical contributions include the long-term multi-scenario prediction framework and the computationally efficient MIQP-based planning formulation. While the evaluation suggests promising results, further validation on real-world data and investigation of practical deployment considerations could strengthen the impact of this work.

Overall, this research represents an important step towards improving the capabilities of autonomous vehicles, particularly in challenging unsignalized intersection scenarios where human drivers often struggle.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

New!Fast Long-Term Multi-Scenario Prediction for Maneuver Planning at Unsignalized Intersections

Max Bastian Mertens, Jona Ruof, Jan Strohbeck, Michael Buchholz

Motion prediction for intelligent vehicles typically focuses on estimating the most probable future evolutions of a traffic scenario. Estimating the gap acceptance, i.e., whether a vehicle merges or crosses before another vehicle with the right of way, is often handled implicitly in the prediction. However, an infrastructure-based maneuver planning can assign artificial priorities between cooperative vehicles, so it needs to evaluate many more potential scenarios. Additionally, the prediction horizon has to be long enough to assess the impact of a maneuver. We, therefore, present a novel long-term prediction approach handling the gap acceptance estimation and the velocity prediction in two separate stages. Thereby, the behavior of regular vehicles as well as priority assignments of cooperative vehicles can be considered. We train both stages on real-world traffic observations to achieve realistic prediction results. Our method has a competitive accuracy and is fast enough to predict a multitude of scenarios in a short time, making it suitable to be used in a maneuver planning framework.

9/18/2024

🌐

A Long-Short-Term Mixed-Integer Formulation for Highway Lane Change Planning

Rudolf Reiter, Armin Nurkanovic, Daniele Bernadini, Moritz Diehl, Alberto Bemporad

This work considers the problem of optimal lane changing in a structured multi-agent road environment. A novel motion planning algorithm that can capture long-horizon dependencies as well as short-horizon dynamics is presented. Pivotal to our approach is a geometric approximation of the long-horizon combinatorial transition problem which we formulate in the continuous time-space domain. Moreover, a discrete-time formulation of a short-horizon optimal motion planning problem is formulated and combined with the long-horizon planner. Both individual problems, as well as their combination, are formulated as MIQP and solved in real-time by using state-of-the-art solvers. We show how the presented algorithm outperforms two other state-of-the-art motion planning algorithms in closed-loop performance and computation time in lane changing problems. Evaluations are performed using the traffic simulator SUMO, a custom low-level tracking model predictive controller, and high-fidelity vehicle models and scenarios, provided by the CommonRoad environment.

5/7/2024

Can Vehicle Motion Planning Generalize to Realistic Long-tail Scenarios?

Marcel Hallgarten, Julian Zapata, Martin Stoll, Katrin Renz, Andreas Zell

Real-world autonomous driving systems must make safe decisions in the face of rare and diverse traffic scenarios. Current state-of-the-art planners are mostly evaluated on real-world datasets like nuScenes (open-loop) or nuPlan (closed-loop). In particular, nuPlan seems to be an expressive evaluation method since it is based on real-world data and closed-loop, yet it mostly covers basic driving scenarios. This makes it difficult to judge a planner's capabilities to generalize to rarely-seen situations. Therefore, we propose a novel closed-loop benchmark interPlan containing several edge cases and challenging driving scenarios. We assess existing state-of-the-art planners on our benchmark and show that neither rule-based nor learning-based planners can safely navigate the interPlan scenarios. A recently evolving direction is the usage of foundation models like large language models (LLM) to handle generalization. We evaluate an LLM-only planner and introduce a novel hybrid planner that combines an LLM-based behavior planner with a rule-based motion planner that achieves state-of-the-art performance on our benchmark.

9/5/2024

Motion Planning under Uncertainty: Integrating Learning-Based Multi-Modal Predictors into Branch Model Predictive Control

Mohamed-Khalil Bouzidi, Bojan Derajic, Daniel Goehring, Joerg Reichardt

In complex traffic environments, autonomous vehicles face multi-modal uncertainty about other agents' future behavior. To address this, recent advancements in learningbased motion predictors output multi-modal predictions. We present our novel framework that leverages Branch Model Predictive Control(BMPC) to account for these predictions. The framework includes an online scenario-selection process guided by topology and collision risk criteria. This efficiently selects a minimal set of predictions, rendering the BMPC realtime capable. Additionally, we introduce an adaptive decision postponing strategy that delays the planner's commitment to a single scenario until the uncertainty is resolved. Our comprehensive evaluations in traffic intersection and random highway merging scenarios demonstrate enhanced comfort and safety through our method.

5/7/2024