Fast Unsupervised Deep Outlier Model Selection with Hypernetworks
0
🤷
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper tackles the challenge of effectively tuning hyperparameters (HPs) for deep neural network-based outlier detection (DOD) models.
- Unsupervised DOD models have many HPs, and their performance is highly sensitive to these settings, making it critical to tune them properly.
- The paper introduces HYPER, a novel approach to address two key challenges: (1) validating DOD models without labeled anomaly data, and (2) efficiently searching the HP/model space.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on a important issue with deep learning-based outlier detection models. These models have many different settings, called hyperparameters, that need to be carefully tuned to get good performance. However, tuning these hyperparameters is challenging because outlier detection is an unsupervised problem, meaning there are no labeled examples of anomalies to use for validation.
To address this, the paper proposes a new system called HYPER. The key idea is to train a "hypernetwork" that can quickly generate the optimal weights for a DOD model given a set of hyperparameters. This allows HYPER to efficiently explore many different hyperparameter settings and find the best one.
HYPER also employs meta-learning on past outlier detection tasks with labeled data to train a proxy validation function. This helps evaluate DOD models without needing labeled anomalies.
Overall, HYPER aims to make it much easier to properly tune deep outlier detection models, which is crucial for getting high performance on real-world outlier detection problems. The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of HYPER through extensive experiments on 35 different outlier detection tasks.
Technical Explanation
The paper focuses on the critical challenge of hyperparameter tuning and model selection for unsupervised deep outlier detection (DOD) models. DOD models have shown promising results, but their performance is highly sensitive to their hyperparameter settings, which is a significant issue given the large number of hyperparameters involved.
To address this, the authors introduce HYPER, a novel approach with two key innovations:
-
Hypernetwork for Efficient HP Tuning: HYPER trains a "hypernetwork" that can quickly generate the optimal weights for a DOD model given a set of hyperparameters. This allows HYPER to efficiently explore the HP/model space to find the best configuration.
-
Proxy Validation Function via Meta-Learning: Since outlier detection is an unsupervised task without labeled anomaly data, HYPER employs meta-learning on past OD tasks with labels to train a proxy validation function. This helps evaluate DOD models without needing labeled anomalies.
The authors evaluate HYPER extensively on 35 outlier detection tasks, demonstrating significant performance improvements over 8 baseline methods, along with substantial efficiency gains.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes important contributions in addressing the critical challenge of hyperparameter tuning for deep outlier detection models. The authors' approach of using a hypernetwork to efficiently explore the HP/model space is a clever solution, and the proxy validation function trained via meta-learning is a thoughtful way to handle the lack of labeled anomaly data.
However, the paper does not discuss the potential limitations or downsides of the HYPER approach. For example, it's unclear how well the hypernetwork and proxy validation function would generalize to entirely new types of outlier detection tasks, beyond the 35 used in the evaluation.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the potential trade-offs between the efficiency gains of HYPER and the quality of the final hyperparameter tuning. It would be valuable to understand the scenarios where HYPER might make suboptimal choices compared to more exhaustive (but slower) hyperparameter search methods.
Overall, the paper makes a strong technical contribution, but could be strengthened by a more critical examination of the limitations and potential areas for future research.
Conclusion
This paper tackles the crucial challenge of hyperparameter tuning for deep outlier detection models, which is essential for achieving high performance on real-world outlier detection problems. The authors' HYPER approach, with its hypernetwork and proxy validation function, offers a clever and efficient solution to this problem.
While the paper demonstrates the effectiveness of HYPER through extensive experiments, a more critical analysis of the approach's limitations and potential trade-offs could further strengthen the work. Nonetheless, this research represents an important step forward in making deep outlier detection models more practical and accessible for a wide range of applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤷
0
Fast Unsupervised Deep Outlier Model Selection with Hypernetworks
Xueying Ding, Yue Zhao, Leman Akoglu
Outlier detection (OD) finds many applications with a rich literature of numerous techniques. Deep neural network based OD (DOD) has seen a recent surge of attention thanks to the many advances in deep learning. In this paper, we consider a critical-yet-understudied challenge with unsupervised DOD, that is, effective hyperparameter (HP) tuning/model selection. While several prior work report the sensitivity of OD models to HPs, it becomes ever so critical for the modern DOD models that exhibit a long list of HPs. We introduce HYPER for tuning DOD models, tackling two fundamental challenges: (1) validation without supervision (due to lack of labeled anomalies), and (2) efficient search of the HP/model space (due to exponential growth in the number of HPs). A key idea is to design and train a novel hypernetwork (HN) that maps HPs onto optimal weights of the main DOD model. In turn, HYPER capitalizes on a single HN that can dynamically generate weights for many DOD models (corresponding to varying HPs), which offers significant speed-up. In addition, it employs meta-learning on historical OD tasks with labels to train a proxy validation function, likewise trained with our proposed HN efficiently. Extensive experiments on 35 OD tasks show that HYPER achieves high performance against 8 baselines with significant efficiency gains.
Read more8/27/2024
🔎
0
Zero-shot Outlier Detection via Prior-data Fitted Networks: Model Selection Bygone!
Yuchen Shen, Haomin Wen, Leman Akoglu
Outlier detection (OD) has a vast literature as it finds numerous applications in environmental monitoring, cybersecurity, finance, and medicine to name a few. Being an inherently unsupervised task, model selection is a key bottleneck for OD (both algorithm and hyperparameter selection) without label supervision. There is a long list of techniques to choose from -- both classical algorithms and deep neural architectures -- and while several studies report their hyperparameter sensitivity, the literature is quite slim on unsupervised model selection -- limiting the effective use of OD in practice. In this paper we present FoMo-0D, for zero/0-shot OD exploring a transformative new direction that bypasses the hurdle of model selection altogether (!), thus breaking new ground. The fundamental idea behind FoMo-0D is the Prior-data Fitted Networks, recently introduced by Muller et al.(2022), which trains a Transformer model on a large body of synthetically generated data from a prior data distribution. In essence, FoMo-0D is a pretrained Foundation Model for zero/0-shot OD on tabular data, which can directly predict the (outlier/inlier) label of any test data at inference time, by merely a single forward pass -- making obsolete the need for choosing an algorithm/architecture, tuning its associated hyperparameters, and even training any model parameters when given a new OD dataset. Extensive experiments on 57 public benchmark datasets against 26 baseline methods show that FoMo-0D performs statistically no different from the top 2nd baseline, while significantly outperforming the majority of the baselines, with an average inference time of 7.7 ms per test sample.
Read more9/10/2024
🤷
0
EntropyStop: Unsupervised Deep Outlier Detection with Loss Entropy
Yihong Huang, Yuang Zhang, Liping Wang, Fan Zhang, Xuemin Lin
Unsupervised Outlier Detection (UOD) is an important data mining task. With the advance of deep learning, deep Outlier Detection (OD) has received broad interest. Most deep UOD models are trained exclusively on clean datasets to learn the distribution of the normal data, which requires huge manual efforts to clean the real-world data if possible. Instead of relying on clean datasets, some approaches directly train and detect on unlabeled contaminated datasets, leading to the need for methods that are robust to such conditions. Ensemble methods emerged as a superior solution to enhance model robustness against contaminated training sets. However, the training time is greatly increased by the ensemble. In this study, we investigate the impact of outliers on the training phase, aiming to halt training on unlabeled contaminated datasets before performance degradation. Initially, we noted that blending normal and anomalous data causes AUC fluctuations, a label-dependent measure of detection accuracy. To circumvent the need for labels, we propose a zero-label entropy metric named Loss Entropy for loss distribution, enabling us to infer optimal stopping points for training without labels. Meanwhile, we theoretically demonstrate negative correlation between entropy metric and the label-based AUC. Based on this, we develop an automated early-stopping algorithm, EntropyStop, which halts training when loss entropy suggests the maximum model detection capability. We conduct extensive experiments on ADBench (including 47 real datasets), and the overall results indicate that AutoEncoder (AE) enhanced by our approach not only achieves better performance than ensemble AEs but also requires under 2% of training time. Lastly, our proposed metric and early-stopping approach are evaluated on other deep OD models, exhibiting their broad potential applicability.
Read more7/2/2024
0
Can Dense Connectivity Benefit Outlier Detection? An Odyssey with NAS
Hao Fu, Tunhou Zhang, Hai Li, Yiran Chen
Recent advances in Out-of-Distribution (OOD) Detection is the driving force behind safe and reliable deployment of Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) in real world applications. However, existing studies focus on OOD detection through confidence score and deep generative model-based methods, without considering the impact of DNN structures, especially dense connectivity in architecture fabrications. In addition, existing outlier detection approaches exhibit high variance in generalization performance, lacking stability and confidence in evaluating and ranking different outlier detectors. In this work, we propose a novel paradigm, Dense Connectivity Search of Outlier Detector (DCSOD), that automatically explore the dense connectivity of CNN architectures on near-OOD detection task using Neural Architecture Search (NAS). We introduce a hierarchical search space containing versatile convolution operators and dense connectivity, allowing a flexible exploration of CNN architectures with diverse connectivity patterns. To improve the quality of evaluation on OOD detection during search, we propose evolving distillation based on our multi-view feature learning explanation. Evolving distillation stabilizes training for OOD detection evaluation, thus improves the quality of search. We thoroughly examine DCSOD on CIFAR benchmarks under OOD detection protocol. Experimental results show that DCSOD achieve remarkable performance over widely used architectures and previous NAS baselines. Notably, DCSOD achieves state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance on CIFAR benchmark, with AUROC improvement of $sim$1.0%.
Read more6/5/2024