Fast yet Safe: Early-Exiting with Risk Control
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Presents a method called "Early-Exiting with Risk Control" that allows machine learning models to make faster predictions while maintaining safety and performance.
- Focuses on improving the efficiency of deep neural networks by allowing them to exit early when they are confident in their predictions, rather than always running the full model.
- Introduces a risk control mechanism to ensure that early exits do not compromise the overall accuracy of the model.
Plain English Explanation
The paper introduces a new approach to making deep neural networks more efficient. Deep neural networks are powerful machine learning models that can be used for a variety of tasks, such as image recognition or language processing. However, running a full deep neural network can be computationally expensive and time-consuming.
The researchers propose a method called "Early-Exiting with Risk Control" that allows the model to make predictions more quickly by exiting early when it is confident in its output. This is similar to how a human might be able to answer a simple question quickly, but might need more time to answer a more complex one.
To ensure that the model doesn't make mistakes when exiting early, the researchers also introduce a "risk control" mechanism. This mechanism ensures that the model only exits early when it is truly confident, and not when it is just guessing. This helps to maintain the overall accuracy of the model, even when it is exiting early in some cases.
The researchers show that their method can significantly speed up the inference (or prediction) time of deep neural networks, while still maintaining high accuracy. This could be particularly useful in applications where speed is important, such as real-time decision-making or on-device processing.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a novel approach called "Early-Exiting with Risk Control" (EERC) that allows deep neural networks to exit early during inference, while still maintaining performance. The key idea is to train the model to make confident early predictions when possible, rather than always running the full model.
To achieve this, the authors introduce a set of "early-exit" branches that are attached to intermediate layers of the neural network. These early-exit branches are trained to make predictions based on the partial information available at that layer. During inference, the model can choose to exit early if the early-exit branch is confident in its prediction, rather than running the full model.
To ensure that the early exits do not compromise the overall accuracy of the model, the authors introduce a "risk control" mechanism. This mechanism calculates the risk associated with each early exit, and only allows the model to exit early if the risk is below a certain threshold. The risk is calculated based on factors such as the confidence of the early-exit prediction and the difficulty of the input sample.
The authors evaluate their approach on several benchmark datasets and tasks, including image classification, question answering, and natural language inference. They show that EERC can achieve significant speedups (up to 2.5x) while maintaining comparable or even better performance than the baseline models that always run the full network.
Critical Analysis
The authors provide a thorough experimental evaluation of their EERC method, demonstrating its effectiveness across a range of tasks and datasets. They also discuss potential limitations and future research directions, such as the need to further improve the risk control mechanism and investigate the transferability of the early-exit branches to different models and tasks.
One potential concern is the added complexity of the EERC architecture, which includes the early-exit branches and the risk control mechanism. This could make the model more difficult to train and deploy, especially in resource-constrained environments. The authors acknowledge this trade-off and suggest that future work could explore ways to simplify the architecture while maintaining the performance benefits.
Additionally, the authors focus mainly on the inference-time performance of the models, but do not provide a detailed analysis of the training time and computational overhead of the EERC approach. It would be useful to understand the impact of the EERC components on the overall training process and the potential trade-offs between training complexity and inference speedup.
Overall, the EERC method presented in this paper is a promising approach to improving the efficiency of deep neural networks, and the authors have made a valuable contribution to the field of machine learning. However, further research and refinement may be necessary to address the potential limitations and make the approach more practical for real-world applications.
Conclusion
The "Fast yet Safe: Early-Exiting with Risk Control" paper introduces a novel method for improving the efficiency of deep neural networks during inference. By allowing the model to exit early when it is confident in its predictions, while using a risk control mechanism to ensure overall performance, the authors demonstrate significant speedups without compromising accuracy.
This research has important implications for the deployment of deep learning models in applications where both speed and safety are critical, such as real-time decision-making, edge computing, and resource-constrained environments. The EERC approach represents a step forward in the ongoing effort to make deep learning models more efficient and practical for a wide range of use cases.
As the field of machine learning continues to advance, techniques like EERC that optimize the trade-off between speed and accuracy will become increasingly valuable. The insights and methods presented in this paper serve as a foundation for further research and development in this important area.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Fast yet Safe: Early-Exiting with Risk Control
Metod Jazbec, Alexander Timans, Tin Hadv{z}i Veljkovi'c, Kaspar Sakmann, Dan Zhang, Christian A. Naesseth, Eric Nalisnick
Scaling machine learning models significantly improves their performance. However, such gains come at the cost of inference being slow and resource-intensive. Early-exit neural networks (EENNs) offer a promising solution: they accelerate inference by allowing intermediate layers to exit and produce a prediction early. Yet a fundamental issue with EENNs is how to determine when to exit without severely degrading performance. In other words, when is it 'safe' for an EENN to go 'fast'? To address this issue, we investigate how to adapt frameworks of risk control to EENNs. Risk control offers a distribution-free, post-hoc solution that tunes the EENN's exiting mechanism so that exits only occur when the output is of sufficient quality. We empirically validate our insights on a range of vision and language tasks, demonstrating that risk control can produce substantial computational savings, all the while preserving user-specified performance goals.
Read more6/3/2024
0
Early-exit Convolutional Neural Networks
Edanur Demir, Emre Akbas
This paper is aimed at developing a method that reduces the computational cost of convolutional neural networks (CNN) during inference. Conventionally, the input data pass through a fixed neural network architecture. However, easy examples can be classified at early stages of processing and conventional networks do not take this into account. In this paper, we introduce 'Early-exit CNNs', EENets for short, which adapt their computational cost based on the input by stopping the inference process at certain exit locations. In EENets, there are a number of exit blocks each of which consists of a confidence branch and a softmax branch. The confidence branch computes the confidence score of exiting (i.e. stopping the inference process) at that location; while the softmax branch outputs a classification probability vector. Both branches are learnable and their parameters are separate. During training of EENets, in addition to the classical classification loss, the computational cost of inference is taken into account as well. As a result, the network adapts its many confidence branches to the inputs so that less computation is spent for easy examples. Inference works as in conventional feed-forward networks, however, when the output of a confidence branch is larger than a certain threshold, the inference stops for that specific example. The idea of EENets is applicable to available CNN architectures such as ResNets. Through comprehensive experiments on MNIST, SVHN, CIFAR10 and Tiny-ImageNet datasets, we show that early-exit (EE) ResNets achieve similar accuracy with their non-EE versions while reducing the computational cost to 20% of the original. Code is available at https://github.com/eksuas/eenets.pytorch
Read more9/10/2024
🧠
0
Early-Exit Neural Networks with Nested Prediction Sets
Metod Jazbec, Patrick Forr'e, Stephan Mandt, Dan Zhang, Eric Nalisnick
Early-exit neural networks (EENNs) enable adaptive and efficient inference by providing predictions at multiple stages during the forward pass. In safety-critical applications, these predictions are meaningful only when accompanied by reliable uncertainty estimates. A popular method for quantifying the uncertainty of predictive models is the use of prediction sets. However, we demonstrate that standard techniques such as conformal prediction and Bayesian credible sets are not suitable for EENNs. They tend to generate non-nested sets across exits, meaning that labels deemed improbable at one exit may reappear in the prediction set of a subsequent exit. To address this issue, we investigate anytime-valid confidence sequences (AVCSs), an extension of traditional confidence intervals tailored for data-streaming scenarios. These sequences are inherently nested and thus well-suited for an EENN's sequential predictions. We explore the theoretical and practical challenges of using AVCSs in EENNs and show that they indeed yield nested sets across exits. Thus our work presents a promising approach towards fast, yet still safe, predictive modeling
Read more6/4/2024
🤯
0
Jointly-Learned Exit and Inference for a Dynamic Neural Network : JEI-DNN
Florence Regol, Joud Chataoui, Mark Coates
Large pretrained models, coupled with fine-tuning, are slowly becoming established as the dominant architecture in machine learning. Even though these models offer impressive performance, their practical application is often limited by the prohibitive amount of resources required for every inference. Early-exiting dynamic neural networks (EDNN) circumvent this issue by allowing a model to make some of its predictions from intermediate layers (i.e., early-exit). Training an EDNN architecture is challenging as it consists of two intertwined components: the gating mechanism (GM) that controls early-exiting decisions and the intermediate inference modules (IMs) that perform inference from intermediate representations. As a result, most existing approaches rely on thresholding confidence metrics for the gating mechanism and strive to improve the underlying backbone network and the inference modules. Although successful, this approach has two fundamental shortcomings: 1) the GMs and the IMs are decoupled during training, leading to a train-test mismatch; and 2) the thresholding gating mechanism introduces a positive bias into the predictive probabilities, making it difficult to readily extract uncertainty information. We propose a novel architecture that connects these two modules. This leads to significant performance improvements on classification datasets and enables better uncertainty characterization capabilities.
Read more5/13/2024