Feature Accentuation: Revealing 'What' Features Respond to in Natural Images

Read original: arXiv:2402.10039 - Published 6/11/2024 by Chris Hamblin, Thomas Fel, Srijani Saha, Talia Konkle, George Alvarez

✨

Overview

This paper introduces a new method called "feature accentuation" for interpreting neural network vision models.
Existing methods like attribution and feature visualization have limitations in explaining both "where" and "what" a model is attending to in an image.
Feature accentuation combines aspects of these prior approaches to provide a more comprehensive understanding of a model's internal representations.

Plain English Explanation

The paper focuses on helping us understand how neural network vision models work under the hood. These models are used for tasks like image recognition, but it's not always clear what they're "looking at" or what specific visual features they're using to make their decisions.

Existing techniques like saliency maps and feature visualization provide some insights, but they each have limitations. Saliency maps show where the model is focusing, but not necessarily what it's recognizing. Feature visualization shows what individual features respond to, but not how they're applied to specific images.

The new "feature accentuation" method tries to combine the best of both worlds. It takes a particular image, figures out which visual features the model is using to process that image, and then creates a new image that highlights or "accentuates" those key features. This gives you a clearer view of both where the model is looking and what it's recognizing in that location.

The authors validated that these accentuated images are processed naturally by the model, rather than just being artificial visualizations. They've also made their code publicly available as an extension to the popular Lucent feature visualization library.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces a new method called "feature accentuation" for interpreting neural network vision models. Unlike existing attribution-based approaches that generate saliency maps (e.g. Contextual Encoder-Decoder Network for Visual Saliency Prediction), or feature visualization techniques that synthesize optimal stimuli (e.g. Parallel Backpropagation for Shared Feature Visualization), feature accentuation aims to convey both the "where" and "what" underlying a model's feature responses.

At its core, feature accentuation is an image-seeded (rather than noise-seeded) feature visualization method. The authors find that by carefully tuning the parameterization, augmentation, and regularization, they can generate naturalistic visualizations that resemble the seed image while also highlighting the target feature. This yields insights into both the spatial and semantic aspects of the model's internal representations.

Furthermore, the authors validate that these accentuated images are processed along a natural circuit by the model, rather than just being artificial constructs. They make their precise implementation of feature accentuation available as the Faccent library, an extension of the open-source Lucent feature visualization tool.

Critical Analysis

The feature accentuation method presented in this paper provides a compelling approach to improving the interpretability of neural network vision models. By combining the strengths of attribution and feature visualization techniques, it offers a more comprehensive understanding of a model's internal representations.

However, the paper does not address some potential limitations of the method. For example, the generated accentuated images may still be somewhat idealized or stylized, and may not fully capture the nuanced and context-dependent way that real-world features are processed by the model. Additionally, the method is limited to explaining individual features, and does not directly address how features interact or how higher-level concepts emerge from their combinations.

Further research could explore ways to extend feature accentuation to better understand the learned feature representations and their biases within neural networks. Investigating how feature accentuation could be applied to other modalities beyond vision, such as natural language processing, may also yield valuable insights.

Conclusion

This paper presents a new method called "feature accentuation" that aims to provide a more comprehensive understanding of how neural network vision models process visual information. By generating naturalistic visualizations that highlight both the spatial and semantic aspects of a model's feature responses, feature accentuation offers a powerful tool for interpreting the inner workings of these complex systems.

The authors have made their implementation publicly available, allowing the research community to build upon and extend this work. As the field of machine learning interpretability continues to evolve, methods like feature accentuation will be increasingly important for ensuring the transparency and accountability of AI systems deployed in real-world applications.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

✨

Feature Accentuation: Revealing 'What' Features Respond to in Natural Images

Chris Hamblin, Thomas Fel, Srijani Saha, Talia Konkle, George Alvarez

Efforts to decode neural network vision models necessitate a comprehensive grasp of both the spatial and semantic facets governing feature responses within images. Most research has primarily centered around attribution methods, which provide explanations in the form of heatmaps, showing where the model directs its attention for a given feature. However, grasping 'where' alone falls short, as numerous studies have highlighted the limitations of those methods and the necessity to understand 'what' the model has recognized at the focal point of its attention. In parallel, 'Feature visualization' offers another avenue for interpreting neural network features. This approach synthesizes an optimal image through gradient ascent, providing clearer insights into 'what' features respond to. However, feature visualizations only provide one global explanation per feature; they do not explain why features activate for particular images. In this work, we introduce a new method to the interpretability tool-kit, 'feature accentuation', which is capable of conveying both where and what in arbitrary input images induces a feature's response. At its core, feature accentuation is image-seeded (rather than noise-seeded) feature visualization. We find a particular combination of parameterization, augmentation, and regularization yields naturalistic visualizations that resemble the seed image and target feature simultaneously. Furthermore, we validate these accentuations are processed along a natural circuit by the model. We make our precise implementation of feature accentuation available to the community as the Faccent library, an extension of Lucent.

6/11/2024

Deciphering 'What' and 'Where' Visual Pathways from Spectral Clustering of Layer-Distributed Neural Representations

Xiao Zhang, David Yunis, Michael Maire

We present an approach for analyzing grouping information contained within a neural network's activations, permitting extraction of spatial layout and semantic segmentation from the behavior of large pre-trained vision models. Unlike prior work, our method conducts a holistic analysis of a network's activation state, leveraging features from all layers and obviating the need to guess which part of the model contains relevant information. Motivated by classic spectral clustering, we formulate this analysis in terms of an optimization objective involving a set of affinity matrices, each formed by comparing features within a different layer. Solving this optimization problem using gradient descent allows our technique to scale from single images to dataset-level analysis, including, in the latter, both intra- and inter-image relationships. Analyzing a pre-trained generative transformer provides insight into the computational strategy learned by such models. Equating affinity with key-query similarity across attention layers yields eigenvectors encoding scene spatial layout, whereas defining affinity by value vector similarity yields eigenvectors encoding object identity. This result suggests that key and query vectors coordinate attentional information flow according to spatial proximity (a `where' pathway), while value vectors refine a semantic category representation (a `what' pathway).

6/21/2024

Understanding Visual Feature Reliance through the Lens of Complexity

Thomas Fel, Louis Bethune, Andrew Kyle Lampinen, Thomas Serre, Katherine Hermann

Recent studies suggest that deep learning models inductive bias towards favoring simpler features may be one of the sources of shortcut learning. Yet, there has been limited focus on understanding the complexity of the myriad features that models learn. In this work, we introduce a new metric for quantifying feature complexity, based on $mathscr{V}$-information and capturing whether a feature requires complex computational transformations to be extracted. Using this $mathscr{V}$-information metric, we analyze the complexities of 10,000 features, represented as directions in the penultimate layer, that were extracted from a standard ImageNet-trained vision model. Our study addresses four key questions: First, we ask what features look like as a function of complexity and find a spectrum of simple to complex features present within the model. Second, we ask when features are learned during training. We find that simpler features dominate early in training, and more complex features emerge gradually. Third, we investigate where within the network simple and complex features flow, and find that simpler features tend to bypass the visual hierarchy via residual connections. Fourth, we explore the connection between features complexity and their importance in driving the networks decision. We find that complex features tend to be less important. Surprisingly, important features become accessible at earlier layers during training, like a sedimentation process, allowing the model to build upon these foundational elements.

7/9/2024

Saliency Suppressed, Semantics Surfaced: Visual Transformations in Neural Networks and the Brain

Gustaw Opie{l}ka, Jessica Loke, Steven Scholte

Deep learning algorithms lack human-interpretable accounts of how they transform raw visual input into a robust semantic understanding, which impedes comparisons between different architectures, training objectives, and the human brain. In this work, we take inspiration from neuroscience and employ representational approaches to shed light on how neural networks encode information at low (visual saliency) and high (semantic similarity) levels of abstraction. Moreover, we introduce a custom image dataset where we systematically manipulate salient and semantic information. We find that ResNets are more sensitive to saliency information than ViTs, when trained with object classification objectives. We uncover that networks suppress saliency in early layers, a process enhanced by natural language supervision (CLIP) in ResNets. CLIP also enhances semantic encoding in both architectures. Finally, we show that semantic encoding is a key factor in aligning AI with human visual perception, while saliency suppression is a non-brain-like strategy.

4/30/2024