Feature Protection For Out-of-distribution Generalization
2405.16027
0
0
Abstract
With the availability of large pre-trained models, a modern workflow for building real-world machine learning solutions is to fine-tune such models on a downstream task with a relatively small domain-specific dataset. In such applications, one major challenge is that the small fine-tuning dataset does not have sufficient coverage of the distribution encountered when the model is deployed. It is thus important to design fine-tuning methods that are robust to out-of-distribution (OOD) data that are under-represented by the training data. This paper compares common fine-tuning methods to investigate their OOD performance and demonstrates that standard methods will result in a significant change to the pre-trained model so that the fine-tuned features overfit the fine-tuning dataset. However, this causes deteriorated OOD performance. To overcome this issue, we show that protecting pre-trained features leads to a fine-tuned model more robust to OOD generalization. We validate the feature protection methods with extensive experiments of fine-tuning CLIP on ImageNet and DomainNet.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates why fine-tuning deep learning models can hurt their performance on out-of-distribution (OOD) data, and proposes a new method called "Feature Protection" to address this issue.
- The authors find that fine-tuning causes the model to overfit to the training data, leading to a loss of "general" features that are important for OOD generalization.
- The Feature Protection method aims to preserve these general features during fine-tuning by regularizing the model to retain the original pre-trained representations.
Plain English Explanation
Deep learning models are often pre-trained on large, general datasets and then fine-tuned on specific tasks. While this fine-tuning process can improve the model's performance on the target task, it can sometimes hurt the model's ability to generalize to data that is different from the training data (i.e., out-of-distribution or OOD data).
The authors of this paper investigated why this happens. They found that during fine-tuning, the model tends to "overfit" to the training data, meaning it learns features that are specific to the training data but may not be useful for other types of data. This causes the model to lose some of the more "general" features it had learned during the initial pre-training process, which are important for good OOD generalization.
To address this issue, the researchers developed a new technique called "Feature Protection." The idea is to regularize the fine-tuning process so that the model retains more of its original pre-trained representations, which contain the valuable general features. This helps the model maintain its ability to generalize to OOD data, even as it is being fine-tuned for a specific task.
The Feature Protection For Out-of-distribution Generalization paper provides a detailed technical explanation of this approach, and the authors demonstrate its effectiveness through experiments on several different datasets and tasks.
Technical Explanation
The paper first conducts an investigation to understand why fine-tuning can hurt OOD performance. They find that fine-tuning causes the model to overfit to the training data, leading to a loss of "general" features that are important for OOD generalization. This is supported by experiments showing that fine-tuned models exhibit higher sensitivity to training-data-specific shortcuts and have lower alignment between their pre-trained and fine-tuned representations.
To address this issue, the authors propose a new method called "Feature Protection." The key idea is to regularize the fine-tuning process so that the model retains more of its original pre-trained representations, which contain valuable general features. Specifically, they introduce a regularization term that encourages the fine-tuned model's representations to be close to the pre-trained model's representations.
The paper evaluates the Feature Protection method on various computer vision and language tasks, including image classification, visual question answering, and out-of-distribution detection. The results show that Feature Protection can significantly improve OOD generalization compared to standard fine-tuning, without compromising in-distribution performance.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a well-designed investigation into the issue of fine-tuning hurting OOD performance, and the proposed Feature Protection method appears to be an effective solution. However, the authors acknowledge some limitations:
-
The experiments focus on relatively simple OOD datasets, and it's unclear how the method would scale to more complex OOD scenarios, such as those involving new domains within diffusion models.
-
The method relies on having access to the pre-trained model's representations, which may not always be available in practical settings. Exploring ways to approximate the pre-trained representations could further improve the method's applicability.
-
The paper does not provide a thorough analysis of the computational and memory overhead introduced by the Feature Protection regularization, which could be an important consideration for real-world deployments.
Overall, the paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of out-of-distribution generalization, and the Feature Protection method shows promise as a way to address the pitfalls of fine-tuning. Continued research in this area, addressing the identified limitations, could lead to further advancements in improving the robustness and generalization capabilities of deep learning models.
Conclusion
The "Feature Protection For Out-of-distribution Generalization" paper investigates an important issue in deep learning: the tendency for fine-tuning to hurt a model's ability to generalize to out-of-distribution (OOD) data. The authors' proposed "Feature Protection" method offers a practical solution by regularizing the fine-tuning process to preserve the model's original pre-trained representations, which contain valuable general features.
The paper's thorough analysis and experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of Feature Protection in improving OOD generalization across various computer vision and language tasks. While the method has some limitations that warrant further research, it represents a significant step forward in addressing a crucial challenge in deep learning deployments, where models need to perform reliably in diverse real-world scenarios.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📈
An Empirical Study of Pre-trained Model Selection for Out-of-Distribution Generalization and Calibration
Hiroki Naganuma, Ryuichiro Hataya, Ioannis Mitliagkas
0
0
In out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization tasks, fine-tuning pre-trained models has become a prevalent strategy. Different from most prior work that has focused on advancing learning algorithms, we systematically examined how pre-trained model size, pre-training dataset size, and training strategies impact generalization and uncertainty calibration on downstream tasks. We evaluated 100 models across diverse pre-trained model sizes, update{five} pre-training datasets, and five data augmentations through extensive experiments on four distribution shift datasets totaling over 120,000 GPU hours. Our results demonstrate the significant impact of pre-trained model selection, with optimal choices substantially improving OOD accuracy over algorithm improvement alone. We find larger models and bigger pre-training data improve OOD performance and calibration, in contrast to some prior studies that found modern deep networks to calibrate worse than classical shallow models. Our work underscores the overlooked importance of pre-trained model selection for out-of-distribution generalization and calibration.
6/3/2024
📈
Overcoming the Pitfalls of Vision-Language Model Finetuning for OOD Generalization
Yuhang Zang, Hanlin Goh, Josh Susskind, Chen Huang
0
0
Existing vision-language models exhibit strong generalization on a variety of visual domains and tasks. However, such models mainly perform zero-shot recognition in a closed-set manner, and thus struggle to handle open-domain visual concepts by design. There are recent finetuning methods, such as prompt learning, that not only study the discrimination between in-distribution (ID) and out-of-distribution (OOD) samples, but also show some improvements in both ID and OOD accuracies. In this paper, we first demonstrate that vision-language models, after long enough finetuning but without proper regularization, tend to overfit the known classes in the given dataset, with degraded performance on unknown classes. Then we propose a novel approach OGEN to address this pitfall, with the main focus on improving the OOD GENeralization of finetuned models. Specifically, a class-conditional feature generator is introduced to synthesize OOD features using just the class name of any unknown class. Such synthesized features will provide useful knowledge about unknowns and help regularize the decision boundary between ID and OOD data when optimized jointly. Equally important is our adaptive self-distillation mechanism to regularize our feature generation model during joint optimization, i.e., adaptively transferring knowledge between model states to further prevent overfitting. Experiments validate that our method yields convincing gains in OOD generalization performance in different settings. Code: https://github.com/apple/ml-ogen.
4/17/2024
CRoFT: Robust Fine-Tuning with Concurrent Optimization for OOD Generalization and Open-Set OOD Detection
Lin Zhu, Yifeng Yang, Qinying Gu, Xinbing Wang, Chenghu Zhou, Nanyang Ye
0
0
Recent vision-language pre-trained models (VL-PTMs) have shown remarkable success in open-vocabulary tasks. However, downstream use cases often involve further fine-tuning of VL-PTMs, which may distort their general knowledge and impair their ability to handle distribution shifts. In real-world scenarios, machine learning systems inevitably encounter both covariate shifts (e.g., changes in image styles) and semantic shifts (e.g., test-time unseen classes). This highlights the importance of enhancing out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization on covariate shifts and simultaneously detecting semantic-shifted unseen classes. Thus a critical but underexplored question arises: How to improve VL-PTMs' generalization ability to closed-set OOD data, while effectively detecting open-set unseen classes during fine-tuning? In this paper, we propose a novel objective function of OOD detection that also serves to improve OOD generalization. We show that minimizing the gradient magnitude of energy scores on training data leads to domain-consistent Hessians of classification loss, a strong indicator for OOD generalization revealed by theoretical analysis. Based on this finding, we have developed a unified fine-tuning framework that allows for concurrent optimization of both tasks. Extensive experiments have demonstrated the superiority of our method. The code is available at https://github.com/LinLLLL/CRoFT.
5/28/2024
🏋️
LEVI: Generalizable Fine-tuning via Layer-wise Ensemble of Different Views
Yuji Roh, Qingyun Liu, Huan Gui, Zhe Yuan, Yujin Tang, Steven Euijong Whang, Liang Liu, Shuchao Bi, Lichan Hong, Ed H. Chi, Zhe Zhao
0
0
Fine-tuning is becoming widely used for leveraging the power of pre-trained foundation models in new downstream tasks. While there are many successes of fine-tuning on various tasks, recent studies have observed challenges in the generalization of fine-tuned models to unseen distributions (i.e., out-of-distribution; OOD). To improve OOD generalization, some previous studies identify the limitations of fine-tuning data and regulate fine-tuning to preserve the general representation learned from pre-training data. However, potential limitations in the pre-training data and models are often ignored. In this paper, we contend that overly relying on the pre-trained representation may hinder fine-tuning from learning essential representations for downstream tasks and thus hurt its OOD generalization. It can be especially catastrophic when new tasks are from different (sub)domains compared to pre-training data. To address the issues in both pre-training and fine-tuning data, we propose a novel generalizable fine-tuning method LEVI (Layer-wise Ensemble of different VIews), where the pre-trained model is adaptively ensembled layer-wise with a small task-specific model, while preserving its efficiencies. By combining two complementing models, LEVI effectively suppresses problematic features in both the fine-tuning data and pre-trained model and preserves useful features for new tasks. Broad experiments with large language and vision models show that LEVI greatly improves fine-tuning generalization via emphasizing different views from fine-tuning data and pre-trained features.
6/21/2024