Federated Temporal Difference Learning with Linear Function Approximation under Environmental Heterogeneity
2302.02212
0
0
✅
Abstract
We initiate the study of federated reinforcement learning under environmental heterogeneity by considering a policy evaluation problem. Our setup involves $N$ agents interacting with environments that share the same state and action space but differ in their reward functions and state transition kernels. Assuming agents can communicate via a central server, we ask: Does exchanging information expedite the process of evaluating a common policy? To answer this question, we provide the first comprehensive finite-time analysis of a federated temporal difference (TD) learning algorithm with linear function approximation, while accounting for Markovian sampling, heterogeneity in the agents' environments, and multiple local updates to save communication. Our analysis crucially relies on several novel ingredients: (i) deriving perturbation bounds on TD fixed points as a function of the heterogeneity in the agents' underlying Markov decision processes (MDPs); (ii) introducing a virtual MDP to closely approximate the dynamics of the federated TD algorithm; and (iii) using the virtual MDP to make explicit connections to federated optimization. Putting these pieces together, we rigorously prove that in a low-heterogeneity regime, exchanging model estimates leads to linear convergence speedups in the number of agents.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper studies the problem of federated reinforcement learning under environmental heterogeneity.
- The setup involves N agents interacting with environments that share the same state and action space, but differ in their reward functions and state transition kernels.
- The key question is whether exchanging information can expedite the process of evaluating a common policy in this heterogeneous setting.
Plain English Explanation
In this study, the researchers are looking at a scenario where multiple agents (let's call them "learners") are trying to learn how to perform a task by interacting with their own unique environments. These environments all have the same basic structure, but they differ in terms of the rewards the learners get and how the environments change over time.
The researchers want to know whether having the learners share information with each other, through a central server, can help them learn the task more quickly. This is an important question because in many real-world applications, the environments that different agents are operating in may not be exactly the same, and being able to leverage shared information could be a big advantage.
To answer this question, the researchers developed a new algorithm for federated reinforcement learning and analyzed its performance. They showed that if the differences between the environments are not too large, then sharing information can lead to a significant speedup in the learning process.
Technical Explanation
The paper provides a comprehensive finite-time analysis of a federated temporal difference (TD) learning algorithm with linear function approximation. The key technical contributions include:
-
Deriving perturbation bounds on TD fixed points as a function of the heterogeneity in the agents' underlying Markov decision processes (MDPs). This allows the researchers to quantify how much the learned policies will differ across agents due to environmental differences.
-
Introducing a "virtual MDP" to closely approximate the dynamics of the federated TD algorithm. This virtual MDP is used to make explicit connections to federated optimization techniques.
-
Leveraging the virtual MDP analysis to rigorously prove that in a low-heterogeneity regime, exchanging model estimates leads to linear convergence speedups in the number of agents. This means that as more agents participate, the learning process becomes significantly faster.
The technical analysis accounts for key practical considerations such as Markovian sampling, heterogeneity in the agents' environments, and the use of multiple local updates to reduce communication.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes several important contributions to the understanding of federated reinforcement learning under heterogeneous environments. By providing a rigorous theoretical analysis, the researchers have laid the groundwork for more advanced federated RL algorithms and applications.
That said, the analysis does rely on several assumptions, such as the low-heterogeneity regime and linear function approximation. It would be valuable to explore the performance of the algorithm in more realistic, high-heterogeneity settings, as well as with more expressive function approximation schemes.
Additionally, the paper focuses on the policy evaluation problem, whereas many real-world applications require policy optimization. Extending the analysis to the policy optimization setting would be an important next step.
Conclusion
This paper takes an important step towards understanding the potential benefits of federated reinforcement learning in the presence of environmental heterogeneity. By providing a rigorous theoretical analysis, the researchers have shown that under certain conditions, sharing information between agents can lead to significant speedups in the learning process.
These insights could have important implications for a wide range of applications, from robotics and autonomous vehicles to personalized recommendation systems and healthcare. As the field of federated learning continues to evolve, this work lays a strong foundation for developing more advanced algorithms and deploying them in real-world, heterogeneous environments.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Finite-Time Analysis of On-Policy Heterogeneous Federated Reinforcement Learning
Chenyu Zhang, Han Wang, Aritra Mitra, James Anderson
0
0
Federated reinforcement learning (FRL) has emerged as a promising paradigm for reducing the sample complexity of reinforcement learning tasks by exploiting information from different agents. However, when each agent interacts with a potentially different environment, little to nothing is known theoretically about the non-asymptotic performance of FRL algorithms. The lack of such results can be attributed to various technical challenges and their intricate interplay: Markovian sampling, linear function approximation, multiple local updates to save communication, heterogeneity in the reward functions and transition kernels of the agents' MDPs, and continuous state-action spaces. Moreover, in the on-policy setting, the behavior policies vary with time, further complicating the analysis. In response, we introduce FedSARSA, a novel federated on-policy reinforcement learning scheme, equipped with linear function approximation, to address these challenges and provide a comprehensive finite-time error analysis. Notably, we establish that FedSARSA converges to a policy that is near-optimal for all agents, with the extent of near-optimality proportional to the level of heterogeneity. Furthermore, we prove that FedSARSA leverages agent collaboration to enable linear speedups as the number of agents increases, which holds for both fixed and adaptive step-size configurations.
4/16/2024
Momentum for the Win: Collaborative Federated Reinforcement Learning across Heterogeneous Environments
Han Wang, Sihong He, Zhili Zhang, Fei Miao, James Anderson
0
0
We explore a Federated Reinforcement Learning (FRL) problem where $N$ agents collaboratively learn a common policy without sharing their trajectory data. To date, existing FRL work has primarily focused on agents operating in the same or ``similar environments. In contrast, our problem setup allows for arbitrarily large levels of environment heterogeneity. To obtain the optimal policy which maximizes the average performance across all potentially completely different environments, we propose two algorithms: FedSVRPG-M and FedHAPG-M. In contrast to existing results, we demonstrate that both FedSVRPG-M and FedHAPG-M, both of which leverage momentum mechanisms, can exactly converge to a stationary point of the average performance function, regardless of the magnitude of environment heterogeneity. Furthermore, by incorporating the benefits of variance-reduction techniques or Hessian approximation, both algorithms achieve state-of-the-art convergence results, characterized by a sample complexity of $mathcal{O}left(epsilon^{-frac{3}{2}}/Nright)$. Notably, our algorithms enjoy linear convergence speedups with respect to the number of agents, highlighting the benefit of collaboration among agents in finding a common policy.
5/31/2024
SCAFFLSA: Taming Heterogeneity in Federated Linear Stochastic Approximation and TD Learning
Paul Mangold, Sergey Samsonov, Safwan Labbi, Ilya Levin, Reda Alami, Alexey Naumov, Eric Moulines
0
0
In this paper, we analyze the sample and communication complexity of the federated linear stochastic approximation (FedLSA) algorithm. We explicitly quantify the effects of local training with agent heterogeneity. We show that the communication complexity of FedLSA scales polynomially with the inverse of the desired accuracy $epsilon$. To overcome this, we propose SCAFFLSA a new variant of FedLSA that uses control variates to correct for client drift, and establish its sample and communication complexities. We show that for statistically heterogeneous agents, its communication complexity scales logarithmically with the desired accuracy, similar to Scaffnew. An important finding is that, compared to the existing results for Scaffnew, the sample complexity scales with the inverse of the number of agents, a property referred to as linear speed-up. Achieving this linear speed-up requires completely new theoretical arguments. We apply the proposed method to federated temporal difference learning with linear function approximation and analyze the corresponding complexity improvements.
5/28/2024
🏅
Federated Reinforcement Learning with Constraint Heterogeneity
Hao Jin, Liangyu Zhang, Zhihua Zhang
0
0
We study a Federated Reinforcement Learning (FedRL) problem with constraint heterogeneity. In our setting, we aim to solve a reinforcement learning problem with multiple constraints while $N$ training agents are located in $N$ different environments with limited access to the constraint signals and they are expected to collaboratively learn a policy satisfying all constraint signals. Such learning problems are prevalent in scenarios of Large Language Model (LLM) fine-tuning and healthcare applications. To solve the problem, we propose federated primal-dual policy optimization methods based on traditional policy gradient methods. Specifically, we introduce $N$ local Lagrange functions for agents to perform local policy updates, and these agents are then scheduled to periodically communicate on their local policies. Taking natural policy gradient (NPG) and proximal policy optimization (PPO) as policy optimization methods, we mainly focus on two instances of our algorithms, ie, {FedNPG} and {FedPPO}. We show that FedNPG achieves global convergence with an $tilde{O}(1/sqrt{T})$ rate, and FedPPO efficiently solves complicated learning tasks with the use of deep neural networks.
5/7/2024