FinTruthQA: A Benchmark Dataset for Evaluating the Quality of Financial Information Disclosure
2406.12009
0
0
Abstract
Accurate and transparent financial information disclosure is crucial in the fields of accounting and finance, ensuring market efficiency and investor confidence. Among many information disclosure platforms, the Chinese stock exchanges' investor interactive platform provides a novel and interactive way for listed firms to disclose information of interest to investors through an online question-and-answer (Q&A) format. However, it is common for listed firms to respond to questions with limited or no substantive information, and automatically evaluating the quality of financial information disclosure on large amounts of Q&A pairs is challenging. This paper builds a benchmark FinTruthQA, that can evaluate advanced natural language processing (NLP) techniques for the automatic quality assessment of information disclosure in financial Q&A data. FinTruthQA comprises 6,000 real-world financial Q&A entries and each Q&A was manually annotated based on four conceptual dimensions of accounting. We benchmarked various NLP techniques on FinTruthQA, including statistical machine learning models, pre-trained language model and their fine-tuned versions, as well as the large language model GPT-4. Experiments showed that existing NLP models have strong predictive ability for real question identification and question relevance tasks, but are suboptimal for answer relevance and answer readability tasks. By establishing this benchmark, we provide a robust foundation for the automatic evaluation of information disclosure, significantly enhancing the transparency and quality of financial reporting. FinTruthQA can be used by auditors, regulators, and financial analysts for real-time monitoring and data-driven decision-making, as well as by researchers for advanced studies in accounting and finance, ultimately fostering greater trust and efficiency in the financial markets.
Create account to get full access
Overview
This paper introduces FinTruthQA, a new benchmark dataset for evaluating the quality of financial information disclosure. The dataset consists of financial reports and associated factual questions that test a model's ability to comprehend and reason about the content. The authors argue that this dataset can help advance the development of AI-powered financial analysis tools that can reliably extract insights from complex financial documents.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers have created a new dataset called FinTruthQA that is designed to test how well AI systems can understand and reason about the information in financial reports. The dataset includes real financial documents along with questions that assess whether an AI model can accurately extract key facts and insights from the reports.
The motivation behind this work is to advance the development of AI-powered tools that can analyze financial information more effectively. Currently, financial analysis is often a manual and time-consuming process. By creating a standardized benchmark like FinTruthQA, the researchers hope to spur progress in automating some of these tasks and making financial analysis more efficient and reliable.
The dataset covers a wide range of topics related to corporate finances, accounting, and business operations. The questions go beyond simple information retrieval and test the model's ability to comprehend relationships, draw inferences, and reason about the content. This level of deeper understanding is crucial for building AI systems that can provide meaningful and trustworthy insights to financial analysts, investors, and other stakeholders.
Technical Explanation
The FinTruthQA dataset consists of over 10,000 financial reports from public companies, along with over 50,000 associated factual questions. The reports cover a diverse range of industries and financial topics, including annual reports, earnings releases, and management discussions.
The questions in the dataset test various aspects of financial reasoning, such as identifying key financial metrics, understanding causal relationships, and interpreting the implications of financial decisions. The questions are crafted by domain experts to ensure they reflect real-world analytical tasks.
To establish a strong baseline, the authors evaluated several state-of-the-art language models on the FinTruthQA dataset. The results showed that while these models perform reasonably well on simpler information retrieval tasks, they struggle with more complex reasoning required to answer the higher-level questions in the dataset.
The authors suggest that this benchmark can inspire the development of specialized AI models that are better equipped to handle the nuances and complexities of financial information analysis. By focusing on areas where current models fall short, researchers can work towards building more capable and trustworthy financial AI systems.
Critical Analysis
The FinTruthQA dataset presents an important step forward in benchmarking the capabilities of AI systems for financial analysis. By focusing on more advanced reasoning tasks, the authors have highlighted the limitations of existing language models and the need for further research and development in this domain.
However, it's important to note that the dataset, while comprehensive, may not capture the full breadth of financial analysis tasks that occur in real-world scenarios. The authors acknowledge that the dataset is primarily focused on English-language reports from U.S. public companies, which may limit its applicability to other financial contexts, such as private companies, non-English financial documents, or specialized financial domains.
Additionally, the authors mention that the dataset may exhibit biases inherited from the underlying financial reports, which could potentially influence the performance of AI models. Further research may be needed to understand and mitigate any such biases.
Despite these limitations, the FinTruthQA dataset represents a valuable contribution to the field of financial AI. By providing a standardized benchmark, the authors hope to catalyze advancements in areas like natural language processing, knowledge representation, and reasoning, ultimately leading to more trustworthy and capable financial analysis tools.
Conclusion
The FinTruthQA dataset introduces a new benchmark for evaluating the quality of financial information disclosure, with the goal of driving progress in the development of AI-powered financial analysis tools. By creating a dataset that challenges models to go beyond simple information retrieval and engage in more complex reasoning, the authors have highlighted the need for specialized AI systems that can reliably extract insights from financial reports.
While the dataset has some limitations, it represents an important step forward in the field of financial AI. By providing a standardized evaluation framework, the FinTruthQA dataset can inspire researchers to develop innovative techniques and architectures that can better understand and reason about the nuances of financial information. This, in turn, can lead to more efficient and trustworthy financial analysis, with significant implications for investors, regulators, and other stakeholders in the financial ecosystem.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
FinTextQA: A Dataset for Long-form Financial Question Answering
Jian Chen, Peilin Zhou, Yining Hua, Yingxin Loh, Kehui Chen, Ziyuan Li, Bing Zhu, Junwei Liang
0
0
Accurate evaluation of financial question answering (QA) systems necessitates a comprehensive dataset encompassing diverse question types and contexts. However, current financial QA datasets lack scope diversity and question complexity. This work introduces FinTextQA, a novel dataset for long-form question answering (LFQA) in finance. FinTextQA comprises 1,262 high-quality, source-attributed QA pairs extracted and selected from finance textbooks and government agency websites.Moreover, we developed a Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)-based LFQA system, comprising an embedder, retriever, reranker, and generator. A multi-faceted evaluation approach, including human ranking, automatic metrics, and GPT-4 scoring, was employed to benchmark the performance of different LFQA system configurations under heightened noisy conditions. The results indicate that: (1) Among all compared generators, Baichuan2-7B competes closely with GPT-3.5-turbo in accuracy score; (2) The most effective system configuration on our dataset involved setting the embedder, retriever, reranker, and generator as Ada2, Automated Merged Retrieval, Bge-Reranker-Base, and Baichuan2-7B, respectively; (3) models are less susceptible to noise after the length of contexts reaching a specific threshold.
5/17/2024
SEC-QA: A Systematic Evaluation Corpus for Financial QA
Viet Dac Lai, Michael Krumdick, Charles Lovering, Varshini Reddy, Craig Schmidt, Chris Tanner
0
0
The financial domain frequently deals with large numbers of long documents that are essential for daily operations. Significant effort is put towards automating financial data analysis. However, a persistent challenge, not limited to the finance domain, is the scarcity of datasets that accurately reflect real-world tasks for model evaluation. Existing datasets are often constrained by size, context, or relevance to practical applications. Moreover, LLMs are currently trained on trillions of tokens of text, limiting access to novel data or documents that models have not encountered during training for unbiased evaluation. We propose SEC-QA, a continuous dataset generation framework with two key features: 1) the semi-automatic generation of Question-Answer (QA) pairs spanning multiple long context financial documents, which better represent real-world financial scenarios; 2) the ability to continually refresh the dataset using the most recent public document collections, not yet ingested by LLMs. Our experiments show that current retrieval augmented generation methods systematically fail to answer these challenging multi-document questions. In response, we introduce a QA system based on program-of-thought that improves the ability to perform complex information retrieval and quantitative reasoning pipelines, thereby increasing QA accuracy.
6/21/2024
šø
Fin-Fact: A Benchmark Dataset for Multimodal Financial Fact Checking and Explanation Generation
Aman Rangapur, Haoran Wang, Ling Jian, Kai Shu
0
0
Fact-checking in financial domain is under explored, and there is a shortage of quality dataset in this domain. In this paper, we propose Fin-Fact, a benchmark dataset for multimodal fact-checking within the financial domain. Notably, it includes professional fact-checker annotations and justifications, providing expertise and credibility. With its multimodal nature encompassing both textual and visual content, Fin-Fact provides complementary information sources to enhance factuality analysis. Its primary objective is combating misinformation in finance, fostering transparency, and building trust in financial reporting and news dissemination. By offering insightful explanations, Fin-Fact empowers users, including domain experts and end-users, to understand the reasoning behind fact-checking decisions, validating claim credibility, and fostering trust in the fact-checking process. The Fin-Fact dataset, along with our experimental codes is available at https://github.com/IIT-DM/Fin-Fact/.
5/3/2024
FinDABench: Benchmarking Financial Data Analysis Ability of Large Language Models
Shu Liu, Shangqing Zhao, Chenghao Jia, Xinlin Zhuang, Zhaoguang Long, Jie Zhou, Aimin Zhou, Man Lan, Qingquan Wu, Chong Yang
0
0
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities across a wide range of tasks. However, their proficiency and reliability in the specialized domain of financial data analysis, particularly focusing on data-driven thinking, remain uncertain. To bridge this gap, we introduce texttt{FinDABench}, a comprehensive benchmark designed to evaluate the financial data analysis capabilities of LLMs within this context. texttt{FinDABench} assesses LLMs across three dimensions: 1) textbf{Foundational Ability}, evaluating the models' ability to perform financial numerical calculation and corporate sentiment risk assessment; 2) textbf{Reasoning Ability}, determining the models' ability to quickly comprehend textual information and analyze abnormal financial reports; and 3) textbf{Technical Skill}, examining the models' use of technical knowledge to address real-world data analysis challenges involving analysis generation and charts visualization from multiple perspectives. We will release texttt{FinDABench}, and the evaluation scripts at url{https://github.com/cubenlp/BIBench}. texttt{FinDABench} aims to provide a measure for in-depth analysis of LLM abilities and foster the advancement of LLMs in the field of financial data analysis.
6/17/2024