FogROS2-Config: Optimizing Latency and Cost for Multi-Cloud Robot Applications
0
🚀
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Cloud service providers offer a vast and constantly changing array of cloud server options, making it challenging for roboticists to select cost-effective configurations.
- FogROS2-Config is an open-source toolkit that automatically benchmarks ROS2 nodes on a small set of "edge case" servers to recommend the best cloud compute services that balance cost and latency.
- The toolkit was evaluated on three robotics tasks: visual SLAM, grasp planning, and motion planning, demonstrating up to a 20x cost reduction compared to manual configuration.
Plain English Explanation
FogROS2-Config is a tool that helps roboticists choose the most cost-effective cloud computing services for their ROS2 applications. Cloud providers offer thousands of server options, which can be overwhelming to sort through.
Instead of testing every possible configuration, FogROS2-Config runs a few "representative" benchmarks on a small set of cloud servers. Based on the results, it recommends the best balance of cost and latency for the user's specific ROS2 application, whether that's visual SLAM, grasp planning, or motion planning. By automating this process, FogROS2-Config can save roboticists a lot of time and money compared to manually testing configurations.
Technical Explanation
FogROS2-Config takes ROS2 nodes as input and automatically runs relevant benchmarks on a small set of "edge case" cloud server configurations. Since it is infeasible to test every possible hardware option, the toolkit quickly identifies a representative sample to evaluate cost and latency tradeoffs.
The authors evaluated FogROS2-Config on three robotics tasks: visual SLAM, grasp planning, and motion planning. By comparing the toolkit's recommendations to a "Pareto frontier" of the most efficient server configurations, they found that FogROS2-Config could reduce costs by up to 20x while still meeting latency requirements.
The paper also presents cost and latency models to help explain FogROS2-Config's recommendations. These models confirm that the toolkit is selecting the most efficient hardware configurations to balance the competing priorities of cost and performance.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough evaluation of FogROS2-Config, but it does not explore the potential limitations of the toolkit's benchmarking approach. For example, the selected "edge case" servers may not fully represent the diversity of cloud offerings, and the benchmarks may not capture all the nuances of real-world robotics workloads.
Additionally, the paper does not discuss how FogROS2-Config would handle future changes in cloud server options or evolving ROS2 application requirements. Maintaining an up-to-date and comprehensive database of cloud configurations and their performance characteristics could be a significant ongoing challenge.
While the paper demonstrates impressive cost savings, it would be helpful to understand the potential trade-offs in terms of development time, maintenance overhead, or other factors that roboticists might need to consider when adopting FogROS2-Config.
Conclusion
FogROS2-Config is a promising toolkit that can help roboticists navigate the complex landscape of cloud computing options and select the most cost-effective configurations for their ROS2 applications. By automating the benchmarking process, the toolkit can save time and money compared to manual testing, which is especially valuable given the rapid pace of change in the cloud computing market.
While the paper presents a strong technical foundation and evaluation, further research could explore the long-term viability of the toolkit's approach and potential limitations. Nonetheless, FogROS2-Config represents an important step in empowering roboticists to make more informed and efficient use of cloud resources.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🚀
0
FogROS2-Config: Optimizing Latency and Cost for Multi-Cloud Robot Applications
Kaiyuan Chen, Kush Hari, Rohil Khare, Charlotte Le, Trinity Chung, Jaimyn Drake, Jeffrey Ichnowski, John Kubiatowicz, Ken Goldberg
Cloud service providers provide over 50,000 distinct and dynamically changing set of cloud server options. To help roboticists make cost-effective decisions, we present FogROS2-Config, an open toolkit that takes ROS2 nodes as input and automatically runs relevant benchmarks to quickly return a menu of cloud compute services that tradeoff latency and cost. Because it is infeasible to try every hardware configuration, FogROS2-Config quickly samples tests a small set of edge case servers. We evaluate FogROS2-Config on three robotics application tasks: visual SLAM, grasp planning. and motion planning. FogROS2-Config can reduce the cost by up to 20x. By comparing with a Pareto frontier for cost and latency by running the application task on feasible server configurations, we evaluate cost and latency models and confirm that FogROS2-Config selects efficient hardware configurations to balance cost and latency.
Read more5/14/2024
🔗
0
ROS 2 on a Chip, Achieving Brain-Like Speeds and Efficiency in Robotic Networking
V'ictor Mayoral-Vilches, Juan Manuel Reina-Mu~noz, Marti~no Crespo-'Alvarez, David Mayoral-Vilches
The Robot Operating System (ROS) pubsub model played a pivotal role in developing sophisticated robotic applications. However, the complexities and real-time demands of modern robotics necessitate more efficient communication solutions that are deterministic and isochronous. This article introduces a groundbreaking approach: embedding ROS 2 message-passing infrastructure directly onto a specialized hardware chip, significantly enhancing speed and efficiency in robotic communications. Our FPGA prototypes of the chip design can send or receive packages in less than 2.5 microseconds, accelerating networking communications by more than 62x on average and improving energy consumption by more than 500x when compared to traditional ROS 2 software implementations on modern CPUs. Additionally, it dramatically reduces maximum latency in ROS 2 networking communication by more than 30,000x. In situations of peak latency, our design guarantees an isochronous response within 11 microseconds, a stark improvement over the potential hundreds of milliseconds reported by modern CPU systems under similar conditions.
Read more4/30/2024
0
Safety-Critical Edge Robotics Architecture with Bounded End-to-End Latency
Gautam Gala, Tilmann Unte, Luiz Maia, Johannes Kuhbacher, Isser Kadusale, Mohammad Ibrahim Alkoudsi, Gerhard Fohler, Sebastian Altmeyer
Edge computing processes data near its source, reducing latency and enhancing security compared to traditional cloud computing while providing its benefits. This paper explores edge computing for migrating an existing safety-critical robotics use case from an onboard dedicated hardware solution. We propose an edge robotics architecture based on Linux, Docker containers, Kubernetes, and a local wireless area network based on the TTWiFi protocol. Inspired by previous work on real-time cloud, we complement the architecture with a resource management and orchestration layer to help Linux manage, and Kubernetes orchestrate the system-wide shared resources (e.g., caches, memory bandwidth, and network). Our architecture aims to ensure the fault-tolerant and predictable execution of robotic applications (e.g., path planning) on the edge while upper-bounding the end-to-end latency and ensuring the best possible quality of service without jeopardizing safety and security.
Read more6/24/2024
0
Performance Comparison of ROS2 Middlewares for Multi-robot Mesh Networks in Planetary Exploration
Loick Pierre Chovet, Gabriel Manuel Garcia, Abhishek Bera, Antoine Richard, Kazuya Yoshida, Miguel Angel Olivares-Mendez
Recent advancements in Multi-Robot Systems (MRS) and mesh network technologies pave the way for innovative approaches to explore extreme environments. The Artemis Accords, a series of international agreements, have further catalyzed this progress by fostering cooperation in space exploration, emphasizing the use of cutting-edge technologies. In parallel, the widespread adoption of the Robot Operating System 2 (ROS 2) by companies across various sectors underscores its robustness and versatility. This paper evaluates the performances of available ROS 2 MiddleWare (RMW), such as FastRTPS, CycloneDDS and Zenoh, over a mesh network with a dynamic topology. The final choice of RMW is determined by the one that would fit the most the scenario: an exploration of the extreme extra-terrestrial environment using a MRS. The conducted study in a real environment highlights Zenoh as a potential solution for future applications, showing a reduced delay, reachability, and CPU usage while being competitive on data overhead and RAM usage over a dynamic mesh topology
Read more7/4/2024