A Framework for Neurosymbolic Robot Action Planning using Large Language Models

Overview

• Symbolic task planning is a widely used approach to enforce robot autonomy, but it struggles to scale in real-world, human-robot collaboration scenarios due to poor performance in complex planning domains or when frequent re-planning is needed.
• The authors present a framework called Teriyaki, which aims to bridge the gap between symbolic task planning and machine learning approaches by training a Large Language Model (LLM), namely GPT-3, into a neurosymbolic task planner compatible with the Planning Domain Definition Language (PDDL).
• Potential benefits of this approach include better scalability as planning domain complexity increases, and the ability to synthesize a plan action-by-action instead of end-to-end, enabling concurrent planning and execution.

Plain English Explanation

The paper discusses a new approach to robot task planning called Teriyaki. Traditional symbolic task planning, where robots follow a pre-defined set of rules to plan their actions, can be hard to scale to complex real-world scenarios, especially when the robot needs to frequently re-plan its actions.

The researchers behind Teriyaki have developed a way to combine symbolic task planning with machine learning, using a Large Language Model (LLM) like GPT-3. The LLM is trained to become a "neurosymbolic task planner" that can understand and generate plans in the standard Planning Domain Definition Language (PDDL) format.

This hybrid approach has some key advantages. First, the LLM-based planner can scale better as the planning problem becomes more complex, since the LLM's response time grows linearly with the input and output size. Second, the LLM can generate plans action-by-action, rather than all at once, allowing the robot to start executing parts of the plan while the rest is still being planned. This enables more efficient concurrent planning and execution.

The researchers have tested this Teriyaki framework on various planning domains and found that it can solve 95.5% of test problems, produce plans up to 13.5% shorter than traditional planners, and reduce the average waiting time for a plan by up to 61.4%.

Technical Explanation

The Teriyaki framework aims to address the limitations of traditional symbolic task planners by leveraging the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs). The authors train a GPT-3 model to become a "neurosymbolic task planner" that can understand and generate plans in the Planning Domain Definition Language (PDDL) format.

Key elements of the Teriyaki approach include:

1. PDDL Compatibility: The LLM is trained to accept PDDL-formatted inputs describing the planning domain and problem, and to output PDDL-compliant plans.
2. Action-by-Action Planning: Instead of generating entire plans at once, the LLM can synthesize plans action-by-action, allowing the robot to start executing parts of the plan while the rest is still being generated.
3. Scalability: The authors argue that the LLM-based planner can scale better than traditional symbolic planners as the planning domain complexity increases, since the LLM's response time scales linearly with the input and output size.

In their experiments, the researchers tested the Teriyaki framework on various planning domains and found that it could solve 95.5% of test problems, produce plans up to 13.5% shorter than a traditional symbolic planner, and reduce the average waiting time for a plan by up to 61.4%.

Critical Analysis

The Teriyaki framework presents a promising approach to combining the strengths of symbolic task planning and machine learning, but it also has some potential limitations and areas for further research:

• Explainability: While the LLM-based planner may offer improved performance, the "black box" nature of large language models can make it difficult to understand and explain the reasoning behind the generated plans. Maintaining transparency and interpretability in the planning process is an important consideration for real-world applications.
• Robustness: The paper does not extensively discuss the robustness of the Teriyaki framework to changes in the planning domain or to unexpected situations that may arise during execution. Further research is needed to assess the framework's ability to handle these types of challenges.
• Deployment Challenges: Integrating an LLM-based planner into a real-world robot architecture may pose technical and computational challenges, such as managing the model's resource requirements and ensuring reliable performance in dynamic environments.

Overall, the Teriyaki framework represents an interesting and potentially valuable contribution to the field of robot task planning. However, as with any emerging technology, further research and validation will be necessary to fully understand its capabilities, limitations, and potential real-world applications.

Conclusion

The Teriyaki framework presented in this paper offers a novel approach to bridging the gap between symbolic task planning and machine learning, with the potential to improve the scalability and flexibility of robot task planning in complex, real-world scenarios. By training a Large Language Model to become a neurosymbolic task planner, the researchers have demonstrated promising results in terms of planning performance, plan quality, and execution efficiency.

While the framework has some limitations and areas for further research, the core ideas behind Teriyaki represent an important step forward in the integration of symbolic and machine learning techniques for robot autonomy. As the field of robotics continues to evolve, approaches like Teriyaki may play a significant role in enabling robots to operate more seamlessly and effectively in dynamic, human-centric environments.